Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutVI (B) Amoco Petroleum Products Special Exception - Case No.1-1SE-97DATE: TO: FROM: THROUGH: SUBJECT: ISSUE: "CENTER OF GOOD LIVING - PRIDE OF WEST ORANGE" \ CITY OF OCOEE \ 150-N. LAKESHORE DRIVE OCOEE, FLORIDA 34761-2258 (407) 656-2322 STAFF REPORT October 15, 1997 The Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners Robert Lewis, Senior Planner Q_\__ Russ Wagner, AICP, Director of Planning Amoco Petroleum Products Special Exception Case # 1-1SE-97 Agenda 10-21-97 Item VI B MAYOR • COMNHSSIONER SCOTT VANDERGRIFT COMMISSIONERS DANNY HOWELL SCOTT ANDERSON SCOTT A. GLASS NANCY J. PARKER CITY MANAGER ELLIS SHAPIRO Should the Mayor and City Commission approve a Special Exception for Amoco Petroleum Products? BACKGROUND: This proposed Amoco convenience store with gas sales is located at the northeast corner of the intersection of Clarke Road and Silver Star Road. The property is zoned C-2 which permits the proposed use as a Special Exception. The subject property is part of a two -lot commercial subdivision which is currently undeveloped. Both the northwest and southwest corners of the intersection also have C-2 zoning and have been developed as shopping centers with outparcels. The southeast corner of the intersection is not within the City Limits and is currently undeveloped; however, it is currently the subject of an annexation application. The new library and at least one other commercial use are anticipated to be developed on that property within the next few years. Policy 6.8 in the Future Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan states that "Where commercial development is allowed at the intersection of major roads, no more than (2) two quadrants will be approved for gas stations or auto -related activities." There is an existing Exxon station with a convenience store located at the southwest corner of this intersection. The proposed Amoco station will be the second such station at this intersection. Page 2 Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners October 15, 1997 T)VgCTTgqTnN! Approval of a Special Exception typically includes a Preliminary Plan and a list of conditions of approval for the Special Exception. One of the main issues discussed during the review of this application was an existing 36 inch oak tree and efforts to preserve that tree. Planning Department staff worked closely with the site designers to rework the site to preserve the tree. However, due to the location of the tree on the site, it was necessary to move the gas pump island canopy 10' into the required 50' building setback from Clarke Road. The Planning Department feels that the benefit of saving the 36' oak tree justifies the 10' encroachment into the required 50' building setback from Clarke Road. All of the usual Special Exception conditions of approval have been incorporated into this Preliminary Plan. However, approval of the Amoco Petroleum Products Special Exception as currently submitted (plans received October 6, 1997) will require a waiver to the requirement for a 50' building setback from Clarke Road, in order to preserve the existing 36 inch oak tree on the site. The attached Preliminary Plan for this Special Exception for Amoco Petroleum Products was reviewed by the Development Review Committee (DRC) on September 23, 1997. The Committee voted unanimously to recommend approval of the proposed Preliminary Plan and Special Exception for Amoco Petroleum Products, including the waiver to the 50' building setback from Clarke Road in order to preserve the existing 36 inch oak tree on the site. PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION MEETING AND RECOMMENDATION: On October 14, 1997, the Planning and Zoning Commission held a public hearing on this Special Exception for Amoco Petroleum Products. During the public hearing, the developer's representatives were present but did not speak because staff was able to answer all the questions asked by the Commission. Two people from the audience spoke. One was concerned about possible needs for future right-of-way, and the other was concerned about the possibility of another gas station at the southeast corner. However, staff s responses appeared to address their concerns adequately and there was no opposition to the Special Exception. After a brief discussion, the Planning and Zoning Commission voted unanimously to recommend approval of the Special Exception for Amoco Petroleum Products, in accordance with staffs recommendation. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on the recommendations of the DRC the Planning and Zoning Commission, Staff respectfully recommends that the Mayor and City Commissioners approve a Special Exception for Amoco Petroleum Products, to be built according to the attached Preliminary Plan date stamped received by the City on October 6, 1997, including a waiver to the 50' building setback from Clarke Road in order to preserve the existing 36 inch oak tree on the site. Attachments: Preliminary Plan for Special Exception, date stamped October 6, 1997 Copy of the Public Hearing advertisement CAALL_DATA\rlpdfile\Staff Reports\CC AmocoSpecEx.doc The Orlando Sentinel, Sunday, October 5, 1997 r -- i CITY or OCOEE; .:_' NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING - TO CONSIDER APPLICATION. FOR SPECIAL EXCEPTION (CASE NO 1-1SE W7 eunrnc s10N well hold a PUBLIC•HEARING�on .October 14, 1997 atthe(rregularses _ Sion to be m at 7:30` m., end .the �U HEARINGMonIOc�toO er�21h.11 at their regularsession to begin td 7:15 0.m Bath public hearings will be held; at their specified times; -or as soon thereafter as possible, in the Commis- Sion Chambers, Ocoee City Hell, 150 North Lakeshore Drive, Ocoee; Florida, to consirinr ♦hn e.... .__ _ .. aaret,wL txCEPiION to have a gaso. line sales and convenience store, on certain real Props rtV located on the northeast comer of Silver Star and Clarke Roads, The complete case file, including a le- gal desrsiption of thesubject property, Tay be inspectad at the Ocoee Plan- ning Department, 150 North Lakeshore Drive, between - the hours of 0:00 am and 5:00 Pm; Monday through Friday - ex ceptlegalholidays.._:r_r:- s. .The Ocoee planning and`Zonfng Cpn mISSlarr:oi Ocoee .C(ty+Commission, Othere the publAia hearinggss to: and times as ...they deem• n Any int party shall e= advised the. dates. times; and or plea . tiinnuedOf mPublic Gtihearingst hale be an- nounced during the hearing and thatno further notices regarding these matters will be published. Interested parties may appear at the public hearings and be heard with re- sr thapplication. Any: peen Two desires to _appeal; any, decision for this purpose, a'�'" that a verbatim recoj�-ol the emceed (rigs is made which Indudes`the testF morry and -Iden- upon which the neeeedi �e Ons with disabilities of the proceedings shoould � contact the ';%Clerk's office 48 hours in advence Of e Meetiin�ngg at (407) 656 JFAN GRAFTON. CITY CLEHK„ CITY.OF'000EE. t t a i F X Y z t k Y."• f F s L { t+ 4 Y t' J 1� P L' x a ,X u , i. }" t •'i jrr t, t , K - +r, V '. ,: , - ss11. ttttt yl . „ r .. •. _.. ... .. - _ Ir:`:" s,..., n , .. .s , .y., - T rF A° Y Y •t..' ,i`# tv' t ,t , J 7 A 4s a F ,✓F :i i t C r N 4 l f R• i s a � r} %F • � L. �f .t t -#: t rn•, esu, > { •N 1Yj !1, i 1 r ` y, , t E' i y r. t F. � i6 � f4 , • .. � e Y Y F - b � 4 a• Y xN a 't L f� P" h� C[ +n < a, h' N .yt i f i' r* 1 5 r"1 RY L ;ro w .f • ✓ CV ,k 'iFt•`, {,. �jr.. k;Lr d. t h. f at .,R S k ♦ 7 fi •V isV }.,. F 1..• 'J d' } i1 g +r ri �, 3 •i t y s t' <4 1 , , , 3 tr 73 }` 3 ' 33�•• } fi AL S: - y w r Ri' ( S k, h /v 1 S { a t tk ti S 's/ # S t Y n n r 3. ry t 4 N" L hn4 1- �hh Pa ix -t } 1tL Yrl. rb•�, 4;S , 3 1t k,. i y f� �'+i'.y �i . ., .:p3 -s ., v' „'n':' 4 .>y.'.o a ,..., ,r+ :., f... , « S,y, ki::%-�, Y 'y�..k 4,t': •.�,.. .L�+�-,R'+r, w�.l ,} .., ,l4' .apt C �.r -k iVY d ', G •,iy x u ...s ... .. F 7 } ..r J. rtiY M: a 1 4 4� 1 t.i i• L t: too r.�1'c.m..� "7t 4 7 4 x 7 ,� h. _4, ) r ; .fir, S . , ,. i'i+• -. :- .,,. F , .;:.. .. a 'e s < ``_ { y 11 rt., - 4 t Z, 5 T,. tv . z. ] 'ik 5. M 5 b k Vt I 1 3 1 k L ' i i r �• `� I 3 ri r A Yrt k r rY 51,. b l L r h tr? i r L . , , f4 T r i Iq '. ti l Spl {C 33 1 [[ t r '4c l' f. t- 3 r �i i PRR t r( .} ., t .; ,. ,J^ .•.:. r.'aa. •S. :rl,„t N v.- ,.. irN... r=. ,?'ti`• >i ".. .'(-. 1...:: { g s ...E • : f' ,3F }*� a•1 F., r �p Ss ! .S i ,Y`" r•rr hT t, t , } t.. ,a r n .Y V S d3 y ! t t +3 F ry Y {, YYi 5 w k` h z Y•• i �`tti*' �r n � Y 3. ,t x 3 � Y t' S F A I 1�•i ':r r rr - } L W. s 3 - r 1,7 }jj,.,r,.- .. � ,. ,� 1 , i,. fit, .. � kk srs?r r. 4T�' r ,. ,,, ,.r , ... , :, '�;^:✓.': �'' A , r _ )e' � ..... : , t . y,,. P �. ff.. a+. 4,t" :54.. �'1,., a .. ' ,: ., ., ,..,.ii"' ,:..:•n« Cil§...r:i:craLGdas� :.,t `44kii Y t , t •" } 'K" s p s t �sr ,4 4 i'N , t i , A aY 6 y v� 1 ! kr f 4 4 .•°v'., .. dnap��� k:l'��F�.a ,;k ,e. _.. ��,-.,?,r :�' � �-.,..0 RJ Ir}' G RAN8E t, ' —41 \., SILVER VEP. STAR _ I STA9KE LAKE 00 Q N J Q _ LAKE o - m` ` OLYMPIA C� o LAKE CQ. _r_ w PRI N1A VISTA I m 0 O' �. ., COLONIAL DR Q - N yQ �T� Y M VICINITY SE IOC 1 P 2 v RJ Ir}' G RAN8E t, ' U IL w� r� C, t� I SO t ,fists: {�''•, r' Y r?} srr r, S,e �f4u ..i } �.r:8-' {S,4.Y�a,_ ��i4YeG�Tm '3'iv' .+`�."•, .N.,. J f } y f 4 t 4. 9 4r Yd .t r:Y". I F n, y 1- >w € n �- . IG T Plki FvA P A B'D A Y " E"N G I �&, ca" E '[ E R u�, N, Civil Eng* eering a Transportation &Err virorrmen told Planning CLEARWATER TAMPA 18167 U.S. 19 North 102 W. Whiting Street (813) 531-3505 (813) 221-0048 i r ((s � ,S ���'� . �t ls:sr �1 M�-c,� � SHEET NO. GESCR1P; I0N fi vI_FE PLAN t, PAV I NG, GRAD I i'G 8c D A I SAGE PLAN - i "�_!T4- ._ t r, ,^_``�f C"�t � i-rr✓1 :`t {��h. t '�' a L 10 'o"r Si IE 1 c I �NAUL PLAN k. t- { {� ., .. z . :>•*c"F;, mh-.�^'^.q' N r?, r,.. r, - „'_.rYR;""r.. .w`T' P'n-r.:..._-€-*•-,r.t�j ;xr;6Anda 10-21-97 6•^P ,.r ', :,.^t< .�a:•un, ,. -`vi,';"y:<+=;t;, ,' ,,',- .,Y ;.;"�nF _q�: ,.^:''fi.v�. T?'?•^�,_„•*;,-' rY..,,,:. .,t`.. �w�., a'le: ,c 7.,. .. m rs r.77, . r (M) , -jF- 4URED DRSEM104 F:P.L: iRORM POWER & wiT - -_— CENTERLINE SET REBAR AND CAP # 5170 R/W RIGHT-OF-WAY TEMPORARY BENCHMARK 0/H OVERHEAD POWER LINES CONC CONCRETE Q BOLLARD (TYP.) BORING HOLE C.B.S. CONCRETE BLOCK STRUCTURE R.C.P. REINFORCED CONCRETE PIPE P -LS, PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYOR GAS VALVE WATER VALVE SANITARY MANHOLE (J I UTILITY RISER SIGN T TELEPHONE MANHOLE POWER. POLE - GUY WIRE LIGHT POLE ELECTRIC MANHOLE S SIGNAL MANHOLE' - MANHOLE ` v-� SIGN. (2. POST)-' FIRE HYDRANT TRAFFIC SIGNAL BOX TRAFFIC'CONTROL BOX. Fi GASRISER MPH MILES PER -HOUR UG' 'UNDERGROUND SAN , .SANRARY, r: FOC FIBER :OPi1C CABLE . _.t ,..... .. , Ct1ECK :VALVE ... NA 1 ! ,. _,.: v !v A �... A _ GATE VALE .,. ,; _ W�2)�� N + r, SINGLE 400 Y�LI7�STATION EASE „ i s .< I «, ON BASE .1 OFR L NA ,,,.. ... <. CEPTO SEE UTI NT Q t: NA _ FIRE .HYDRA _ _.. i 0. H� TCO NER GF_ r c dORTHEAST 4 H�.. FDOT DRIVEWAY CONNECTION NOTES:; _ ... , . .. .. ,, +, ... . , _ , _. E �• t. SOl1 ALL WORK PERFORMED WITHIN THE FLORIDA DEPAR'T'MENT OF ..TRA S ORTAT}p : : � ' _. 1 . Td �.�NiP 12 fH RANGE28 EAST ,,, _ _ CONFORM- T0: RIGHT OF WAY SHALL CO. FO M ,.. RoPO ED EDESCRIPT}aN _ (( RE Rp6X� CO�CREC f0t�NTE c , .. -. _ .1.991 A K.A. STANDARDAN ARDSPECSA. FLORIDA` DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS FOR ROAD AND BRIDGE CONSTRUCTION", :... AR L_}GH E:A T. FICFLORIDA DEPARTENT 0F. O AND TR F _ PA K}NG I1 4 PUCPIPE BU PERS.:FILLED ;.A DESIGN STANDARDS, CONSTRUCTION MAINTENANCE AND UTILITY STREETS AND HIGHWAYS ON STATE MAINTAINED r OPERATIONS FOR F.:. C FLOW D "aCtoNDICA6 . WIiN CONCR TEC4 . '—bol - _ SYSTEMS",. JANUARY 1994 (A.K.A. STANDARD INDEX) COMPLIANCE PA MRKGs 1 _: I 1 HIGH PAINTED WITH. (4'. VATH ALL APPLICABLE INDICES1S REQUIRED. � _ • _ ,. ,. L C SAFETYSTRIPING C.FLORIDA DEPARTMENT 0F TRANSPORTATION MANUAL F UNIFORM ORM . SCALE. 20 N MINIMUM STANDARDS FOR DESI I CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE CE :. PROPERTY LINE L 1 FOR STREETS AND HIGHWAYS 1989 A.K.A. GREEN BOOK). . _.... __ D. -FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF "TRANSPORTATION FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT DESIGN ELEVATION N A } _ MANUAL FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION. AND PAVEMENT ,REHABILITATION", "DESIGN . , : .. .... ..:. : 1992 DE IGH STANDARDS FOR RESURFACING RESTORATION AND , _. A GRATE }NL _ , _ - ` : ( k _. �> ( I POS OSS ACCESS PROPOSED CR _ : — — REHABILITATION R R R OF STREETSANDHIGHWAYS 1988. ( ) , _ �. { ;. _ T BE' DEbICATED EASEMENT TO '; L TRAFFIC STRIPE ANDMARKINGS ARE 0 B THERMOPLASTIC. 2 AL TR FF S A T E _ J :.. _.. , _ _, NA M} TERED EN D SECT}aN :: NA : I e I j I L x I I T I - . CO - ..: BY AMOCO ,:. 3. THE APPLICANT MUST NOTIFY THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPQRTATION _ r. U DISTRICT MAINTENANCE OFFICE 24 HOURS IN ADVANCE OF STARTING _ .. SW E STORtv}WATER FLOW _, NA o- �J .. _ V : •', u, I cz; WOR PERMIT R TELEPHONE NUMBER PROPOSED K. (SEE PE FO TE QN ) ,. , , N A ( _ : , . jj •� �{ l i: FUTURE PARK N I , _ W Flow NA SURFACE:.STORM ATER I THIS AREA BY '. :a. ,_ : .. :: ',• . . .WATER :FLOW DIRECTION OF STQRM . N A a y ! I, OTHERS ( _ N STORM .SEWE • . ,;. NA STRUCTURE NUMBER NA ! (, k l 20 ...:. . , :. ,.. . , •, : J .. .; EROSION: CONTROL , EROS 0 _ NA , � , ! •. •::,� SIGNAGE_ I ,.,: •. ,<- NA . ,. UTIL}TY/POWER P E A I ' • ,:: NA _ WATER MAIN NA j n,' ( 24 PAINTED STOP I r: n 6.0.00 l A. SANITARY LINE _ NA { - REFLECTIVE &-30 NIGH P GN I TENSITY s)ro sl - : _ NA OVER"HEA D WIRES NA n89 9 0I e :. _...... .,. 'NAUNDCRGROUNp .TLEP HONE NA .: WA ER METER NA; NA �• a !-11.25 ! J a : :. _.t ,..... .. , Ct1ECK :VALVE ... NA 1 ! ,. _,.: v !v A �... A _ GATE VALE .,. ,; _ W�2)�� N + r, SINGLE 400 Y�LI7�STATION EASE „ i s .< I «, ON BASE .1 OFR L NA ,,,.. ... <. CEPTO SEE UTI NT Q t: NA _ FIRE .HYDRA • ..,.. ,• -.;-. _. ...-_- J iV1I1GRGV L{VV JLV1 Vl C,_ - , - - � _ . ;Qi• e � .__ ,. , _ SWALE STORMWAT R FLOW .. N U - . 91 r eek ' �,,6 h - �..t(V v CL f `Y to . I mono,o i to - _ BEFORE G SURFACE STORMWATER FL OW � ` a 4. 1 Ir - I I UNSHINE" , Ix Of OM�43 70 , E r I L_Li Lu coU00 DIRECTION- OF STORM WATER FLOW .� Q ( ;,, l J l , , � � CL n- t7 ( 7 ( . - . - •st- .... _... , STORM SEWER —S't— , f- F- ( a ( -z co m NA STRUCTURE UR R )/114 ... � ,._,. ' _. .� i1•'. - �O 7 .1?c w'\ n.. .�` O -.tl. ...: :, t�' � �. ,' :.�h ry 1: I �' ;..._ '.1 "�.' ': '. .. ) ��: CJ C7 • �. •.... .... � '.-. AIA <c. �..:.. :.:.:.. - CY ..: „onc .e 1i o > i 4 tiS l/ h h w- S ^s 3 X\ _ /l O � ro �b 0) 41 O to O. U 2 0Q_ •- (L> 4r O NIM OaO`N V) :2;V -- O t7.; 0.� �•QQ: �.� LL_ C O' N a7) r M'; 00. °c � _ . ;Qi• e � a N 91 eek ' �,,6 h - , f, v f s, n 0 or trat c alp f `Y to . I mono,o i to - _ BEFORE G .CSX Oct AL UNSHINE" , OM�43 70 cn�®� 0) 41 O to O. U 2 0Q_ •- (L> 4r O NIM OaO`N V) :2;V -- O t7.; 0.� �•QQ: �.� LL_ C O' N a7) r M'; 00. °c FULK No — 00-0 i � o, ;Qi• e � a N 91 eek ' �,,6 h - v o. to : rn N�M cit Y- . .CSX Oct cn�®� coU00 FULK No — 00-0 i � ;Qi• eek ' �,,6 h - FULK No — 00-0 i P j ��' }z � )i . 4 N C+1 co r!!,- 6 �\ I 7 U i �r suoisrna�j • ..t.,. . _: ... - i. � i �. ,-.....,_,�.:.._-mow -- � • .. .. - r � BLOWOFF ..., r€( r -�- I � i ( 1 � _.. ..�; � , [�?t7rn� _ e .. _ _ e`' i � ♦ I . I 'i r' r h :a l 4i p a' N f � ti c fia 0 to U -) Z 4 L C; x n. d J o).E�+�; T � C co" Fi l t f i x t I `x � OON ti c fia 0 to L C; x n. d o).E�+�; . � C co" Fi T SjCNI N i co r r� F� .Q nftl tlAH l t f i x t I `x � ARL CENTERLINE ,- M HOW =0 A P m- -�. -.R/W RINT OF -WAY - I BENCHMARK' 0/H, .OVERHEAD POWER UNE$' CONC CONCRETE..:.. POLLARD (TYP.) . ' 3ORING. HDLE - C.B:S;CG,NCRETE BL0.^ir'-STRUCNRE ',. log REINFORCED CONCRETE PIPE P.LS. PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYOR'. sv GAS VALVE :.WATER VALVE`., SANITARY MANHOEE LJ:_: UTIUTYRSER. _ SIGiF T . , .POWER POLE --i GUY .WIRE a4' UGH,r- POLE -. - - �� ELECTRIC MANHOLE L.-' SIGNAL MANHOLE .• - MANHOLE' m .v- SIGN (2 POST). r. 77 HYDRANT : - - .iRAFFlCSIGNAL BOX. .- ''T - TRAFFIC CONTROL BOX - G < -iRAFFlC.CONLROL SO J _ F , VQ 1.. : 1l N _ 3 f ; _ II • ' 4 '090k .u. zun� ,: , r �Ie n r_ , c .: , G _ .._ .... , .. .: .. .. .. ..CL ORS W ns n,.N ..... - ,.. ,. ..,W ,.. :. r 4 PWO VALbE '. 3 r e _ NX4TPN r _ .. : LL IL TAN : f AT LkRp ..... ... _.. .._ .., ..'. .... :. :.. .. - .. .. r. ,. :. ,. :. .' .' .. .. •.• - :: to ,.. „.. } 1 r w W 11a _ 1 f (. r r _. „. , � ( . _ -.•.-. 1_E END. c33nrc3n�i3 ARL CENTERLINE ,- M HOW =0 A P m- -�. -.R/W RINT OF -WAY - I BENCHMARK' 0/H, .OVERHEAD POWER UNE$' CONC CONCRETE..:.. POLLARD (TYP.) . ' 3ORING. HDLE - C.B:S;CG,NCRETE BL0.^ir'-STRUCNRE ',. R_C,P. REINFORCED CONCRETE PIPE P.LS. PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYOR'. sv GAS VALVE :.WATER VALVE`., SANITARY MANHOEE LJ:_: UTIUTYRSER. _ SIGiF T . TELEPHONE MANkaiE ' .POWER POLE --i GUY .WIRE a4' UGH,r- POLE -. - - �� ELECTRIC MANHOLE L.-' SIGNAL MANHOLE .• - MANHOLE' m .v- SIGN (2 POST). r. � .`:SRE. HYDRANT : - - .iRAFFlCSIGNAL BOX. .- ''T - TRAFFIC CONTROL BOX - G < -iRAFFlC.CONLROL SO TOTAL BIGN AREAS. ID / PRICE SIGN: 2 ®40.20 SF = 80.4 SF Amodo CANOPY LOGO: 3 ® 13.4 SF = 40.2 SF Food Shop LOGO: 1 ®`16.1 SF = 16.1 SF TOTAL AREA: 136.7 SF o� rn � 4 to" M