HomeMy WebLinkAboutVII (A) Recommendation for Educational Services Consultant by Education Selection Committee Agenda 10-3-2000
Item VII A
'CEN/ER OF GOOD L117NG-PRIDE OF WEST ORA AGE MAYOR•COMMISSIONER
Ocoee S. SCOTT VANDFRORIFT
O a
t y� CITY OF OCOEE
O COMMISSIONERS
�� �r DANNHOWELI.
v Q 150 N. LAKI:RIIORI'DRIVE
p SCOTT ANDERSON
I'P.r.� PV OCU , FInRIDn 34761-2258 RUSTY JOI INSON
ry � 407)656-2322 NANCY l PARKER
!*OF G000 N`
Cfry MANAGER
ELLIS SHAH RO
September 27, 2000
Memorandum
To: City Manager, City Commission, Education Commission, Members of Education Consultant
Team, and interested staff
From: Mayor S. Scott Vandergrift
Subject: Charter School Consultants Selection team report
Last evening the selection committee for Charter Schools for Ocoee met to review RFQs from
consultants. A recommendation to the city commission was unanimously endorsed. The
committee made up of 2 members of the education commission, Martha Lopez Anderson, Johan
Bergh, staff members Bob Smith, Wanda Horton, and myself met to discuss each of our
rankings. To everyone's surprise there was a meeting of minds on the process, which was done
separately without conferring with each other, and the recommendation after totaling the grading
system was as follows:
I. The Haskell Company
2. Edison Schools Inc.
3. Design Works for Education
I would like to thank all who participated in the study and discussion, I am sure our children will
benefit in the long term.
Attachments are available from the Clerk's office of the actual individual evaluation forms upon
request.
power
RFQ#0005 EDUCATION CONSULTING SERVICES
(PURCHASING CHECKLIST)
criLI .T_ 7L, 42_.SAS t502515y TM ' Er nria_:+t
ovartage ShcMlls gnu
T • n taut aeon UIIk%M1i1R --� —�'— --
3 Clefts Saco&,USA —�
4 &Mon School.Ire. V VT � 1;95 ;�-
11 5 The Haskell Company ✓�`� i
5 eRafe•Group (/
SABIS Eluutlenal SPmm�Inc—
mero,woauia [auvyen--
7 ✓ �� 6
9 Irks
is
1t PaMon5RPee Im.
3F0 0005 Edocaton 3U13MITTatS a9
tltl 2 /Ltltltl IU:tlb the MAYUP 5LUI I PAUL ab
n
4- / AV
V v
✓' V 17) \ r/ 6OV \
nA ft'/ (m"/ w- / (1/ (Y
i c. 0 1` / NS/ %k)/ I ' 1
� ��o a 1 J I I � \ 2t 13 I D I
i _ f ! . i vi 1l VY i dr \\I :� . it Z 11_
c - �. ..
I
I I I I 1 1
I I1 I 1
I 1 1 I-- - 1 I -
I 111
I I
II 11 I I 1 11
II Il i II
Il II
I I 1 I I
1 I1 II 1I 1 I II I 1
I I
1 I I I I
I
I I I I
I
II I
I I
I
60 04 6z(-
� EVALUATION FORM
n �Y t' RR)fhlo05 --Poo iB o3 .
_ —1;1211GAI1011S92LS1 •S:_9ERVIC1S ________
L
a Evaluation Criteria resign Works lot Education The Haskell Company Erikson Sehools Inc.
utility to provide type
&gaal ty of serrices ' +1-
( ) Points 1 � ,2..-.
Q 7fiti&Extert cof_-.-_—__---
(. job i. ..s• __a_______
experience was mi ar 17
projects ( Z
s'( )Foirls
- Ability to dnderake e1 IL" tsavalk 61
project wii budget l
n tased upon current/ I _( 9p rojecfetl workload �-�_
S ( Points
r
I naginatkm,creativity
innovation,offx iency
& cost effectiveness ,,(( I/t
( ) Poin!s CJ /�--
-
'JS@M !DO NI (:(sL,
F financial oondieor
a.fiscal stability 9 ----y
( Paints I �-.... )
319.
n Minority Eus.ness / `5 �)
E nterpiso Participation {
L__
(r S. 287 055)
a ( ) Points
9 /
7O1AI.POINTS , (`e \ /
y2-toor E,
- _ Si
\ i(•
21 ` tl
SC),,+e • " <`�- (u) f< EVALUATION FORM
�7 no:- vfd pKP.iif
a_ PPG/MOS
Evahaatlon Criteria Design Works for Education TAc HaskellCompany Editor Schools Inc.
Ability to provide 4 pe ______...„�_'
8 goaldy of senices CO (1 ��
( )Paints
Quality &Extent of —/ � ,i � i—'�� _ 1
experience nenoe w/si Tnlar ,�tt -- C� A / ./ ,,[[ a r
projects ,,(c 5:nnio=, ec94/ I -"so rr,,JP U7" •I ./ /(i9 i lScl�>
( I Points i Si ,l/e ate /
a'tirec P
- Ability to indertakre—I ,/�) —•
5 project w/i budget (-� )
D ".1 / J 6/y / Nt4A K' )CCJ
n based upon covert/ Cis',did n7�' Yet l r r s nn f p^ / '' y Q IJ
projected workloac I)t'o� co1� 'CI A fC54 6SH
( ) Points on see),A(P_
r
'Irnaginatkn, creakvit) �e j�'1--'— T—�— - _
innevatior, efficiency ,1� J �` // p `�"/ .lo, - Sc Pv(relys �, (�.( p
8 ust-eM:ctweness l�£a t'lTbr> M'sv1 kirk '{>�Pw.t�>/c Jlol > l -«fe<,
( ) Points fa teY AoPJq roC ife'S 'JlJfec'etir V'E. - e--forxetl c.. - �
0..•3P .rr8 s SE_L _,
-
Financal contlifion ..7J `- ) � qIl'
8 fiscal sNbi ity 4r d ,/e, )/P �o�( 4rs 104,,
( ) Pont ,rceh'rvl 1st<E'E:VGtiy�
'---_---
—---- -- -- -i_----_
nklinor /Business en,( c nnf S�Gi ,l Jq -oAl- t o
Enterprise Participation F7Cac1N�' r 8
(I' 5. 237055) <z.vtt.- rec,
( ) Pants
D TOTAL P•Jlr I�ITItI�$ 1 (�1 r / 7} �/_�
n ___j
o J c
zS
.,�.e>haLI -� "q;/ /i' ',.ci r5 R�5! rifle ce
✓ / L- & 7)6 I( ?>C .
a
uv1 - t2 -- r coo - .L.-3 ,RM t<'
E'VALtIATION FORM
RFC 00005
t
11
LI
c Ev;lineation Criteria Design Work for Education The Haflell Company Edison Schools Inc.
Aoilily to provide type
& Quality at services l
( )Poirls _3 i ..-2-
•ua ity & E#en1 o1 —'
experience w/si nilar -�/t� 2P5/ ���L
projects ? �L� / "c 1yy ,.a
( ; Poirns
0O5Sd ,w
- Aoilily to undertake uk- 0o5#5•"*-
5 project won budget 5
nI based :pen current/
e.L-f / Ul c A.
11`'
projected wo-kkrad 2 4- 3 n
f ( ) Pcinls _ __ f3
Inagination, creativity �' rC P �,
innoreton, eic en oy
&costeflectivenees '' i� z Ic'�"1�'� J'�'
( ) Pcinls uQ,5 0 +,
. i
-
v �r �i
F nancial cordit on I C-) L,L.a r
&final stability - 7 i 2, 5
AC' 6 ,.,e-w c,
Minority Bisiness r
Enterprise Participation fJ I(U.S -�-
287:%5) _L `/
a ( ) Points___ t
��
~ TOTAL POINTS
n 4V' - -n
r �' •5�� �O I'i
r
///EVALt1ATICIN FORM
a RFQ/MOOS
al — iatird U4bSi !r!''iiiEELlllfif.r--���---�_���•
0
1 Eualua lion Criteria Cosign Words for Eduction The Haskell Company Edison Schools Inc.
Aoiiy b provide type
uality cfservices / ,
�' 8 q( )Poi Ms /9 c2[7
C ua ity 8 Extent of
eiperience Y/sirnidr
protocol /0 ..-9( ccO
c_ )10 [i ( ) Points
Ability to undertake
5 p'oj ect w/budget
u)
^ ccrc)D,c* based upon rurenV 2(projectedwo•kloec c, 0 COq�n IO
z ( ) Points
Irnaginalkn, aeativip
irnoealion, e'hciency
(7F.Ga 8 cst-efh,,cbveiess
( ) Pointsie5 /t� ��
Finanual cordlion
8 fiscal stibtity 0/1 K r+lO ra�P/ (-1n,K/x=li1/1 Ur k'('c. ri
/,5 Fes. Q ) Po nit.
se
n M1ltnaritr Business
Enterpise Participation
n 5 ira (ES. 2'.37.755) ---- ._,.
n ( ) Points
•
~ TOTAt Pn :3 /2 , 3 rt ,7(o130!
a — i
', CZ) pro)l rill"9 1'6 .:i`l/ Uric, Iv7 ' -, c/' v 0 o o n
= If r of
1
a (�) secye:-a, l /ar,7e r p rc Jert 1•5 G u ti 'JS 11) '1:46� GoOr`i5
I , , , ,
! | | % i | |
] | 3 g / § / | w '
i \ / \ I 1 ^ N
/ i , b »
\ / i 1
75 7 1 |
da
w I \}q I I
|
+
I a ] \} I
\ ■ ) / �\0 }) |
! 2 k % I
}}2 I 2 '9 | ^ ,\ / ` i-
—
I \I II T } $
. 4rg . , , lly Iif ; * f [ ; J , _ . �: \ i i _ ! §
52
.| ! - § # i # \ { ! : »! § ; ,
E ; f2 � � ° CO Cl. ! f %} �� ¥ /k / ; \ ± | _ /g„ £ ƒ 14iI
; al : .3 - m ; wQ4_ ! ! ; _ l ' _ , tlI e
;Ow‘ "
@' �:
( lc 7
/ % %
: /
= r