Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem #11b Approval of Code Enforcement Reduction of Fine/Lien - 1512 Lady Ave. Meeting Date: May 18, 2010 Item # LLb. ~ Background Summary: This property was cited on October 6, 2008 for a violation of Minimum Housing violations by Officer Delgado and one of the requirements was for a permit for a partial re-roofing. The code violation was for failure to obtain final inspection for the partial re-roof for permit # 08-000865 issued on June 26, 2008. On February 24, 2009, the Code Enforcement Board issued an order to comply by March 23, 2009 or be fined $150.00 per day. On March 24, 2009 Code Enforcement Board extended to comply by April 27, 2009. On April 27, 2009 Code Enforcement Board extended to comply by May 15, 2009. On May 25, 2009 the Code Enforcement Board extended to comply by June 22,2009. On June 22,2009 the Code Board extended to comply on July 24, 2009. Issue: Flat Sun Investment LLC, c/o Hat Cheoung Lau is requesting a reduction of fine/lien of $4,050.00 plus City's cost of $1,695.70 totaling $5,745.75 since they did not take control over the property until December 03, 2009 with a Title search being preformed on June 18, 2009. On August 20, 2009, the property was observed to be in full compliance. Recommendations The Code Enforcement Board is recommending the fine/lien be reduced to $1,695,70 to cover the City's cost. The discussion by the board was to reduce the amount; due to the fact the respondent was unaware of any pending code violations. Attachments: Minutes from the April 27, 2010 Code Enforcement Board meeting. Financial Impact: None Type of Item: (please mark with an "x') Public Hearing Ordinance First Reading Ordinance Second Reading Resolution Commission Approval Discussion & Direction For Clerk's Deat Use: Consent Agenda Public Hearing Regular Agenda Original Document/Contract Attached for Execution by City Clerk Original Document/Contract Held by Department for Execution Reviewed by City Attorney Reviewed by Finance Dept. Reviewed by 0 N/A N/A N/A 2 City Manager Robert Frank Commissioners Gary Hood. District 1 Rosemary Wilsen. District 2 Rusty Johnson. District 3 Joel Keller. District 4 Mayor S. Scott Vandergrift STAFF REPORT TO: FROM: The Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners Butch Stanley, Deputy Fire Chief ~ DATE: May 03, 2010 RE: Reduction of Fine/Lien for 1512 Lady Avenue (District 1 Commissioner Hood) ISSUE Flat Sun Investment LLC, c/o Hat Cheoung Lau is requesting a reduction of fine/lien of $4,050.00 plus City's cost of $1,695.70 totaling $5,745.75 since they did not take control over the property until December 03, 2009 with a Title search being preformed on June 18, 2009. On August 20, 2009, the property was observed to be in full compliance BACKGROUNDIDISCUSSION This property was cited on 10-06-08 for a violation of Minimum Housing violations by Officer Delgado and one of the requirements was for a permit for a partial re-roofing. The code violation was for failure to obtain final inspection for the partial re-roof for permit # 08000865 issued on June 26, 2008. On 02-24-09, the Code Enforcement Board issued an order to comply by 03-23-09 or be fined $150.00 per day. On 3-24-09 Code Board extended to comply by 4-27-09. On 4-27-09 Code Board extended to comply by 5-15-09. On 05-25-09 the Code Board extended to comply by 6-19-09. On 6-22-09 the Code Board extended to comply on 07-24-09. RECOMMENDATION The Code Enforcement Board is recommending the fine/lien be reduced to $1,695.70 to cover the City's cost. The discussion by the board was to reduce the amount; due to the fact the respondent was unaware of any pending code violations. 1 MINUTES OF THE CITY OF OCOEE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD MEETING APRIL 27, 2010 CALL TO ORDER Chairman Godek called the regular meeting of the Ocoee Code Enforcement Board to order at 7:01 p.m. in the Commission Chambers at City Hall. Member Lowery led the Invocation and Member Hopper led the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. The roll was called and a quorum was declared present. PRESENT: Chairman Godek, Members Alexander, Hopper, Lowery, Osborne, Alternate Member Arney, and Alternate Member Kelley. Also present were Code Enforcement Officer Loeffler, Code Enforcement Officer Delgado, Code Enforcement Officer Siegrist, Code Enforcement Officer Rodriguez, Deputy Fire Chief Stanley, Administrative Assistant Ballard, Attorney Segal-George, and Deputy City Clerk Sibbitt. ~ JI I ABSENT: Vice Chair M. Godek and Member Sais were absent excused. ,., r I II GUESTS: None. \ I 1 -",,, II . -,'1' I.~ I I ,,..~ Administrative Assistant Ballard. admini'sierbd the oath to Code Enforcement Officer J '.... · .... Loeffler, Code Enforcement Officer Delgado, Code Enforcement Officer Siegrist, Code Enforcement Officer Rodriguez, DeputY Fire Chief Stanley, and anyone intending to speak regarding a case. CONSENT AGENDA ALL MATIERS LISTED UNDER THE CONSENT AGENDA ARE CONSIDERED ROUTINE BY THE CODE ENFORCE!\.1ENT BOARD AND WILL BE ACTED UPON BY ONE MOTION. THERE WILL BE NO SEPARATE DISCUSSION OF THESE ITEMS UNLESS DISCUSSION IS DESIRED BY A MEMBER OF THE BOARD, IN WHICH CASE THE CHAIRMAN WILL INSTRUCT THE BOARD CLERK TO REMOVE THE ITEM FROM THE CONSENT AGENDA AND SUCH ITEM WILL BE CONSIDERED SEPARA TEL Y. The Consent Agenda consisted of approval of Items A, Band C. *Note: Consent Agenda was amended. A. Minutes of the March 23,2010, Code Enforcement Board Meeting B. Dismissal or Compliance. (Case Numbers 10-051, 10-060, and 10-061 were transferred to consent.) Case Number Respondent Location of Violation 1. 10-037 Natalie Williams & Johnny Mitchell 706 Russell Drive 2. 10-040 Edna W P Holzworth 906 Starke Lake Circle 3. 10-042 Suzanne & William Clark 711 Starke Lake Circle 4. 10-051 George William MacFadden Jr. 714 Crystal Drive 5. 10-057 Heather Johnson 1700 Ison Lane 6. 10-058 Danald P. & Brenda G. Buck 409 Tranquille Oaks Drive Code Enforcement Board Minutes April 27, 2010 7. 10-060 8. 10-061 9. 10-063 10. 10-064 Lee & Octavia Rushin Jamie Farwig & William Roosa Deborah Adams & Arnie Damonte Russ Christopher, Ramchand & Karen Persaud 2729 Springfield Drive 2704 Cullens Court 1421 Prairie Lake Blvd. 1411 Royal Marquis Circle C. Order of Continuance (May 25, 2010, Meeting). 062 were transferred to consent.) Case Number Respondent 1. 10-036 Michael & Karen M. Walls 2. 10-038 Jerry A. & Sharon A. Walker 3. 10-043 Clara R Arnie Life Estate 4. 10-056 Edward N. Tudor 5. 10-062 Armando Torres (Case Numbers 10-038, 10-043, and 10- Location of Violation 9019 Floribunda Drive 1053 Red Dandy Drive (Cont, to Oct.) 330 Spring Bluff Court 605 E Lakeshore Drive 93 Deer Key Court Member Lowerv. seconded bv Member Alexander. moved to approve the Consent Azenda as presented bv city staff. Motion carried unanimous Iv. Member HODDer. seconded bv Alternate Member Kellev. move}] tb. hear the cases in the . 0'" r followinz order: Case Nos. 10-035. 10-052. 08-232. 09-028, 09-058. and 10-059; then revert back to the azenda. Motion carried unanimous Iv. .., \ I II I , ,.vII. I "'J COMMENTS FROM CITIZENS - None, 1). I' ,/ ~ I.) I! HEARINGS OF STATEMENTS OF WIOEATIONS PURSUANT TO THE HEARING RULES ADOPTED BY THlSrBOARD ON JUNE 27. 1995, VARIOUS DOCUMENTS ARE USED BY THE CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS IN EACH CASE AND ARE REPORTED IN THE CASE TESTIMONY GIVEN BY THE CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER. IN THESE MINUTES THE TITLES TO THOSE DOCUMENTS WILL BE ABBREVIATED AS FOLLOWS: ACFD _ AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE FOR DEMOLITION. AOC - AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE. AONC - AFFlDA VIT OF NON-COMPLIANCE, ATF-APPLICATION TO FORECLOSE. CO - COMPLIANCE ORDER, CMFD - COMMISSION MEETING FOR DETERMINATION. CS - CONTINUED STAY. CTR _ COpy TO RESPONDENT. ECO - EXTENDED COMPLIANCE ORDER, EX-EXHIBITS. FS- FEES STAYED. LDC - Land Development Code, NOCV _ NOTICE OF CODE VIOLATION. NOH - NOTICE OF HEARING. NS-No Service, OAF - ORDER AurnORIZING FORECLOSURE, OIF/L- ORDER IMPOSING FINE/LIEN, ONC - ORDER OF NON-COMPLIANCE. OOC - ORDER OF CONTINUANCE. , ORF - ORDER REDUCING FINE, PDFS _ PER DAY FINE SUSPENDED, POS - PROOF OF SERVICE, RFR - REQUEST FOR REHEARING, RFRDUC-REQUEST FOR REDUCTION DENIED UNTIL COMPLIANCE. ROF- REDUCTION OF FINE. SFH - SUBPOENA FOR HEARING. SOV - STATEMENT OF VIOLATION (S) and WD- WITHDREW. HEARINGS ON STATEMENT OF VIOLATIONS PURSUANT TO NOTICES OF HEARINGS Case No, 10-035 - Victor Borja, Carmen Borja, & Carmen Laura Borja 901 Wurst Road Officer Loeffler Violation Cited: 6-4 (6) (b), 5-15 (A) (1), 108-25 (B) 02-17-10 NOCV Re-Inspection Date: 03-08-10 03-09-10 SOY 03-09-10 NOH 03-09-10 POS 03-23-10 OC 03-23-10 POS Regular & Certified Mail 04-02-10 POS Hand Delivery Observation: Off street parking (commercial vehicle), specific use/development standards (no recreational Meeting Date: 03-23-10 Regular & Certified Mail Page 2 of9 Code Enforcement Board Minutes April 27, 2010 vehicle), 108-25 Rooming houses (licensed required). Officer Loeffler gave a brief history of the case providing exhibits and stated, as of today, no communication has been made by the property owner and the property appears to still be in non-compliance. Member Hopper clarified that the placement of the trailer behind the property line was not an issue. Officer Loeffler stated that was correct. Victor Borja, 2207 Alclobe Circle, stated he was not aware of any notices that were sent before April. The notices were handed to the tenants and he was recently just given one which is why he is present tonight to find out what he is doing wrong and how to fix the problem. He further stated that he was not aware that he was not able to have the RV on his property. Member Hopper stated the RV is not the problem. Officer Loeffler informed the owner that he is in violation of the RV being used as a studio apartment and the uninhabitable portions of the house being occupied. Mr, Borja stated his friend has been occupying the trailer for a couple of days but he will give him notice that he needs to move and find a new place. He further stated that he did get a permit for a garage several years ago, but when his daughter was unable to work he converted the garage into a living area to rent out to help her keep up with the house. Mr, Borja stated if this is a problem; please advise him so he can correct it as well. Member Alexander inquired if he had pulled a permit to convert his garage into a living area. Mr, Borja stated he did not. Member Osborne inquired as to who is living in the home and who is in the garage. Mr, Borja stated he has a family living in the home and the garage has two separate individuals since he only added two rooms out there. He further stated they are not related, but they do know each other. Officer Loeffler gave the definition of a rooming house and explained to Mr. Borja that, in addition to his current violations, he did not get a permit to convert the garage into a dwelling unit. He further stated no one should be living in the garage until it is permitted and inspected. Member Hopper expressed his concern with too many residents living in a home and the effect it will have to their septic tank and drain field. Member Kelley asked if he understands there are four dwelling units on one single-family resident zoned lot. Officer Loeffler stated that is correct; and he only cited Mr. Borja with the zoning violation because he was unaware of how many people were residing in the home until today. He further stated compliance right now would be to discontinue occupancy of the garage and trailer. Member Hopper informed Mr. Borja that he really did need to visit with city staff so they can explain to him everything that needs to be corrected. Mr, Borja inquired if he would be allowed about a month to have all the tenants look for a new place to reside. Member Hopper inquired if this was a resident's complaint. Officer Loeffler stated it was multiple complaints. Member Hopper stated he can sympathize with the neighbors and is not sure if he agrees with a month for compliance. Member Lowerv. seconded bv Member Alexander. moved in Case No. 10-035 to find the resvondents in violation as cited as of March 5. 2010. and be given until Mav 21. 2010. to come into comvliance or be fined $150/ver dav ver violation thereafter. Page 3 of9 Code Enforcement Board Minutes April 27, 2010 Alternate Member Kelley stated that he feels that May 21 st is too long of a time frame when there are neighbors complaining. He further stated that he thinks two working weeks is more then enough time for the tenants to find a new place to reside. Member Lowery stated he came up with the time frame because sometimes it is difficult to find a place to go; especially in this day and time. Member Alexander stated that she agrees with Member Lowery that a month is fair. Alternate Member Kelley inquired as to when the first complaint was made by a neighbor. Officer Loeffler stated a complaint was taken in late January, but it took some monitoring of the property for him to start his case. Member Osborne inquired as to why city staff was not able to track down Mr. Borja since he lives in the city limits. Officer Loeffler stated he's not sure. The property appraiser's office had him residing at the address on Wurst Road and he did a search, but there are a lot of people with the same last name. Member Osborne further inquired from Officer Loeffler as to how much of his time and energy he has invested on this case because that should be compensated as well. Officer Loeffler stated he has not finished documenting time and city expenses at this point, but as far as actual paperwork it is not that much. Member Osborne stated she would make a suggestion that they be given two weeks and if Mr. Borja would like to pay the fine until the tenants can find a place to reside then that would be up to him. Member Alexander stated that she feels the neighbors, once they find out the Code Enforcement Board is just hearing this case, would be okay with knowing that it will be taken care of within a month. Alternate Member Arney stated she agrees with Member Alexander. 1 I ' I I. ...1 Alternate Member Kellev. seconded bv Member HODDer. moved to amend the previous motion to be given until Mav 11. 2010. to come into comfm&nck hI' be fined $150/per day per violation thereafter. Motion carried 4-3 .with.:Memheh; Aiexander, Lowerv. and Amev 1-""[ '(". opposing. r ' I' ..no : I l I 1 Original motion with amendment: I ,,' ."" Member Lowerv. seconded bv Member Alexander. moved in Case No. 10-035 to find the respondents in violation as cited as of March 5. 2010. and be given until Mav 11. 2010. to come into compliance or be fined $150/per day per violation thereafter. Motion carried unanimous Iv. Case No. 10-052 - Dawn Carpenter 640 Jay Street Officer Delgado Violation Cited: 115-5,165-3,165-4,115-3 03-24-10 NOCV Re-Inspection Date: 04-02-10 04-07-10 SOY 04-07-10 NOH Meeting Date: 04-27-10 04-07-10 POS Regular & Certified Mail 04-16-10 POS Posting Observation: Prohibited Acts (Misc. junk/debris on property), overgrown grass/weeds, and two vehicles with flat tires and expire/no tag. Page 4 of9 Code Enforcement Board Minutes April 27, 2010 Officer Delgado gave a brief history of the case providing exhibits and further stated, as of today, the property is still in non-compliance of 165-3. Dawn Carpenter, 640 Jay Street, stated that she does have current tags for both cars and provided them as exhibits.. She further stated that she does admit that she did not put the stickers on the tag until recently. Member Hopper inquired if the vehicles are operable and if they are being driven. Ms, Carpenter stated they are operable; however, she does not drive the Corvette because she has two small children and it's against the law to put them in a Corvette. She further stated the Barracuda at this point is not operable and she is supposed to have someone come look at the car in the next few days. Chairman Godek inquired if she was still considered in violation. Officer Delgado stated the vehicle is inoperable, so yes. Member Hopper. moved in Case No. 10-052 to find the resvondents in violation of 165-3 as cited as of Avril 1. 2010. and be f!iven until Mav 21. 2010. to come into comvliance or be .fined $1001ver dav thereafter. Died due to lack of second. Member Osborne. seconded bv Alternate Member Kellev. moved in Case No. 10-052 to find the resvondents in violation of 165-3 as cited as of Avril 1. 2010. and be given until Mav 7. 2010. to come into comvliance or be fined $1001ver dav thereafter. Motion carried 6-1 with Member Alexander ovvosinf!. Member Alexander. seconded bv Member Hopper. moved in CaseiNumbers 08-232 and 09- 028 to re-hear cases for reauest of reduction of fines. Motion ca'r;ie~ unanimouslv. I I~ r Case No, 08-232 - Patricia Burney r) ~II 1 I 1512 Lady Avenue " J Officer Delgado t ,< ,~,I~ Violation Cited: 108-24D, 108-22, 108-23E !q(2)! 1?~-23W{l08.~191 and 108-19A 10-06-08 NOCV Re-Inspection 9ate: lOh2-08 11-05-08 SOY I t I I r' , , 11-05-08 NOH Meeting Date:"11-25-08 11-05-08 POS Regular a~ Certified Mail 11-13-08 POS Posting 11-25-08 OC 01-06-09 SOY 01-06-09 NOH 01-06-09 POS 01-27-09 OC 01-28-09 POS 02-17-09 POS 02-27-09 CO 03-24-09 CO 04-28-09 CO 06-23-09 CO 06-29-09 POS 07-28-09 ANC 07-30-09 OIF 08-04-09 POS Meeting Date: 01-27-09 Regular and Certified Mail Meeting Date: 02-24-09 Regular and Certified Mail Hand Delivery Given until 03-23-09 to comply or be fmed $150/per day Compliance date extended until 04-27-09 Extended until 06-12-09 Extended until 07-24-09 Regular & Certified Mail Regular & Certified Mail Page 5 of9 Code Enforcement Board Minutes April 27, 2010 03-15-10 AC 03-15-10 Received Partial Payment of$13,534.21 03-15-10 OIF Total Due: $35,100.00 Observation: No smoke detectors installed. Washing machine not connected to drainage system. Install cover- interior electrical panel box. Ceiling electrical wires exposed and no light fixture. Missing faceplate covers throughout house. Exposed wires at water heater. No door or door jams in bathroom. Front living room has large holes in ceiling from water damage repair or ceiling replacement. Need roofmg permit for holes and leaks in roof, from City of Ocoee, Building Department, contractor required due to owner not living in the home. Permit obtained, and no work has been done. Officer Delgado gave a brief history of the case and stated, the owner did come into compliance with most of their violations except the roof and ceiling. The owner during that time was Patricia Burney and the board had given her extension after extension to try to comply. The fine total incurred is $35,100 but does not include $2324.66 that the city has invested. Chairman Godek inquired about the partial payment received. Officer Delgado stated the prior owner Patricia Burney sold the property and monies from that sale was put toward the lien. Member Hopper clarified that someone purchased this property with a lien attached to it. Officer Delgado stated it was purchased through a tax deed sale, but the new owner can explain. Hat Lau, 4430 Prince Hall Blvd., Orlando (FL), stated he purchased the property and did not know the previous owner. He stated the previous owner lost the property to a tax sale due to not paying for her taxes. They did do a title search but no violations showed up. The property was purchased on December 3, 2009, and the County Tax Collector c~llected the money from them. Mr. Lau stated he was not aware of any violations but whentHey did obtain the house they immediately remodeled the house, which would have put ,th[ri1.~in1tompliance. He further stated it was not until an officer showed up to the property. andlirfformed his handyman of the code violations. Member Hopper clarified.that(wheth~p~rch'ase\i the home there was no lien. Officer Delgado stated the lien ~rreco~ded~n ~AtigJstIr31, 2009. Chairman Godek inquired if the property was in complia4ce. Jbffif~r Delgado stated it came into compliance with the city on March 15, 2010. Mr. LJu' slated it was in compliance before that date but because he was unaware of any issues t~e'c1fy was not called out to inspect. Attorney Segal- George stated that in the case packet there is reference to title work that was done; however, it is dated June 18, 2009. She further explained that the title company does have an obligation to pick up liens which is why they carry liability. Mr, Lau clarified that on a tax sale there is no title liability because the title company will not issue title insurance. He further stated that he has purchased other tax sale property and most counties will allow some relief on code violations if the new owner brings the code violations to compliance in a short time. Member HODDer, seconded bv Member Amev. moved in Case Numbers 08-232 to recommend to the City Commission to reduce the fine to $12.324.66. Motion carried unanimouslv. Page 6 of9 Code Enforcement Board Minutes April 27, 2010 Case No, 09-028 - Patricia Burney 1512 Lady Avenue Violation Cited: 105.4 01-22-09 02-09-09 02-09-09 02-10-09 02-16-09 03-11-09 03-24-09 04-28-09 05-18-09 05-26-09 06-23-09 06-23-09 06-29-09 07-28-09 07-30-09 08-04-09 08-20-09 08-20-09 08-20-09 Observation: "June 26, 2008. NOCV SOV NOH POS POS CO CO CO ANC CO ANC CO POS ANC OIF POS AC OIF Total due: $4,050.00 POS Regular & Certified Mail Failure to obtain any required fmal inspections for a partial re-roof, permit #08000865, issued on Officer Rodriguez Re-Inspection Date: Meeting Date: 02-24-09 Certified Mail Posting Given until 03-23-09 to comply or be fined $150/per day Compliance Date extended until 04-27-09 Date extended until 05-15-09 Date extended until 06-19-09 Extended until 07-24-09 Regular & Certified Mail Regular & Certified Mail Officer Rodriguez gave a brief history of the case and further stated, her case is in regards to , a roofing permit not being pulled. The total cost ofthe,lie'n~is $4,050.00 and the city invested , t I cost is $1,695.70. · Jl... ' .. t I I rJ I '. Member Hopper. seconded bv _Member Lowerev. moved m Case Numbers 09-028 to recommend to the City Commission\ 101reilzfce-.,.ihe fine to $1695.70. Motion carried unanimous Iv. , ' .1 I I J L:/ Member Alexander. seconded bv~Member Hopper. moved in Case Number 09-058 to re-hear case for reQuest of reduction offines. Motion carried unanimous Iv. Case No, 09-058 - Marilyn J" Daniel J, & Daniel J, Kelyman Jr, 6733 Lumberjack Lane Officer Delgado Violation Cited: 6-4 H (6) (b) 03-11-09 NOCV 03-19-09 SOV 03-19-09 NOH 03-19-09 POS 04-15-09 POS 04-28-09 CO 05-01-09 POS 05-26-09 ANC 05-26-09 OIF 06-02-09 POS 09-01-09 ANC Re-Inspection Date: 03-18-09 Meeting Date: 04-28-09 Regular & Certified Mail Hand Delivery Given until 05-22-09 to comply or be fined $1 OO/per day Certified Mail As of 05-23-09 - $lOO/per day Certified Mail Page 7 of9 Code Enforcement Board Minutes April 27, 2010 11-02-09 AC 11-02-09 OIF Total due: $16,200.00 11-02-09 POS Regular & Certified Mail Observation: White covered trailer must be stored behind front building line. Officer Delgado gave a brief history of the case and further stated she did not ever receive a call from the respondent, but the city went out on a quarterly inspection on November 2,2009, and the property was in compliance. The total cost for the lien is $16,200 and the city has invested $995.35. Daniel Kelyman, 9021 Mossy Oak Lane, Clermont (FL), stated the trailer is his but his son resides at the property. He further stated the property is owned by him and his mother and his son was quick-claimed to the property in 2007. Mr, Kelyman stated his son was out of town in Texas and his roommates that were residing at the home did not forward the code violation information to them. He further stated that when his son returned home he was told by a Code Enforcement Officer that as long as the trailer moves daily it could be kept on the side of the property. He further stated the trailer was moved to Clermont but they were not aware that fines were being accrued during that period of time. They found out about this lien when they tried to refinance the home. Mr. Kelyman stated they did not receive any notices because the address on the tax appraiser's office is wrong and that is something they will have to deal with. Member Hopper inquired ifhis son had ever seen any notices. Officer Delgado stated that she had spoken to a young gentleman who was rude and told her they were not going to move it. Officer Delgado stated she is not aware if it is the respondent's son she spoke with since he was not present tonight. I .. 'I I I [11 " Member Osborne. moved in Case No. 09-058 to recommend to the Citv Commission to reduce the fine to $2.995.35. Died due to lack ofsecon"d."1 I I ~J . c '" '~\ ' ~f'} >l7 ll) P . Member HODDer, moved In Casl7vo.1 09-058 rto- not recommend a reductIOn to the Commission but to leave the fine As it ls bn}j.'allow the Commission to vote on it. Died due to I .. f lack of second. I ,/ ...... Member Kellev. seconded bv Member Alexander. moved in Case Numbers 09-058 to recommend to the Citv Commission to reduce the fine to $11.195.35. Motion carried 5-2 with Chairman Godek and Member Hopper opposing. OTHER BUSINESS COMMENTS Page 8 of9 Code Enforcement Board Minutes April 27, 2010 ADJOURNMENT Meeting adjourned at 9:17 p,m, Attest: Melanie Sib bitt, Deputy City Clerk Page 9 of9 APPROVED: Robert Godek, Chairman