HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-26-2010 Minutes
MINUTES OF THE CITY OF OCOEE
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD MEETING
OCTOBER 26, 2010
CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Godek
called the regular meeting of the Ocoee Code Enforcement Board to order
Member Hopper
at 7:00 p.m. in the Commission Chambers at City Hall. led the Invocation
Member Lowery
and led the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. The roll was called and a
quorum was declared present.
PRESENT:
Chairman Godek, Vice Chair M. Godek, Members Alexander, Hopper,
Lowery, Osborne, and Alternate Member Kelley. Also present were Deputy
Fire Chief Butch Stanley, Code Enforcement Officer Delgado, Code
Enforcement Officer Loeffler, Code Enforcement Officer Siegrist, Fire
Inspector Sorenson, Administrative Assistant Ballard, Attorney Sneed, Deputy
City Clerk Sibbitt, and Recording Clerk Stella McLeod.
ABSENT:
Member Sais and Alternate Member Amey were absent excused.
GUESTS:
None.
Administrative Assistant Ballard
administered the oath to the Code Enforcement Officers,
Fire Inspector, and anyone intending to speak regarding a case.
CONSENT AGENDA
ALL MATTERS LISTED UNDER THE CONSENT AGENDA ARE CONSIDERED ROUTINE BY THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD AND WILL BE
ACTED UPON BY ONE MOTION. THERE WILL BE NO SEPARATE DISCUSSION OF THESE ITEMS UNLESS DISCUSSION IS DESIRED BY A
MEMBER OF THE BOARD, IN WHICH CASE THE CHAIRMAN WILL INSTRUCT THE BOARD CLERK TO REMOVE THE ITEM FROM THE
CONSENT AGENDA AND SUCH ITEM WILL BE CONSIDERED SEPARATELY.
The Consent Agenda consisted of approval of Items A, B and C. *Note: Consent Agenda was
amended.
A. Minutes of the September 28, 2010, Code Enforcement Board Meeting
B. Dismissal or Compliance. (Case Number 10-249 was transferred to consent.)
Case Number Respondent Location of Violation
1)10-243 Nga Hoang Phung & 2130 Laurel Blossom Circle
Kevin Dong Huyhn
2)10-249 Silvio Vargas 1411 Darla Street
C.Order of Continuance - None.
Vice Chair M. Godek, Member Lowery,
seconded by moved to approve the Consent Agenda
as presented by city staff. Motion carried unanimously.
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
Vice Chair M. Godek, Member Lowery
seconded by, moved to hear the cases in the following
order: Case Nos. 10-248, 10-266, 10-252, 10-251, 06-117, 08-121; then revert back to the
agenda. Motion carried unanimously.
COMMENTS FROM CITIZENS - None.
HEARINGS OF STATEMENTS OF VIOLATIONS
PURSUANT TO THE HEARING RULES ADOPTED BY THIS BOARD ON JUNE 27, 1995, VARIOUS DOCUMENTS ARE USED BY THE CODE
ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS IN EACH CASE AND ARE REPORTED IN THE CASE TESTIMONY GIVEN BY THE CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER.
IN THESE MINUTES THE TITLES TO THOSE DOCUMENTS WILL BE ABBREVIATED AS FOLLOWS:
ACFD - AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE FOR DEMOLITION, AOC - AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE, AONC - AFFIDAVIT OF NON-COMPLIANCE,
ATF-APPLICATION TO FORECLOSE, CO - COMPLIANCE ORDER, CMFD – COMMISSION MEETING FOR DETERMINATION, CS – CONTINUED
STAY, CTR - COPY TO RESPONDENT, ECO – EXTENDED COMPLIANCE ORDER, EX-EXHIBITS, FS- FEES STAYED, LDC – Land Development
Code, NOCV - NOTICE OF CODE VIOLATION, NOH - NOTICE OF HEARING, NS-No Service, OAF - ORDER AUTHORIZING FORECLOSURE, OIF/L-
ORDER IMPOSING FINE/LIEN, ONC - ORDER OF NON-COMPLIANCE, OOC - ORDER OF CONTINUANCE, , ORF – ORDER REDUCING FINE,
PDFS - PER DAY FINE SUSPENDED, POS - PROOF OF SERVICE, RFR - REQUEST FOR REHEARING, RFRDUC-REQUEST FOR REDUCTION
DENIED UNTIL COMPLIANCE, ROF- REDUCTION OF FINE, SFH – SUBPOENA FOR HEARING, SOV - STATEMENT OF VIOLATION (S) and WD –
WITHDREW.
HEARINGS ON STATEMENT OF VIOLATIONS PURSUANT TO NOTICES OF
HEARINGS
Case No. 10-248 – Diane and Alfred Leopold
419 Abbeyridge Court. Officer Delgado
Violation (s) Cited: 51-13, 115-6, 108-25
09-15-10 NOV Re-inspection date: 09/28/10
09-30-10 SOV
09-30-10 NOH Meeting Date: 10/26/10
09-30-10 POS Reg. & Certified Mail
10-15-10 POS Posting
Observation:
Demolition of screen enclosure without required premier, plans, approval and inspections.
Swimming is pool green and dirty water, multiple people renting rooms in the house.
Officer Delgado
presented the case and gave history; exhibits were presented. As of today
the screen enclosure has been removed without a permit which is required.
Member Hopper
asked who the home belongs to. He asked if the HOA (homeowners
Officer Delgado
association) is addressing the matter at all. replied that the HOA had asked
Vice-Chair M. Godek
the City to get involved. clarified that this case is strictly about the
demolishment of the screen for the pool. The officer replied affirmatively.
Chairman Godek
invited guests to speak at the podium.
Mr. Christopher Blake
, 6147 Huckleberry Avenue, nephew to Alfred Leopold, said that
there was wind shear damage to the main beam which cannot be replaced; it must be rebuilt.
He admitted that he did not pull a permit, but he did stop the work when the stop work order
was issued. He took responsibility for not paying the $22.00 for the permit. He claimed that
the doors to the house were left unlocked. He said that he did not remove the aluminum. The
pool has been sprayed but not drained, Mr. Blake explained, because the house has no power.
Page 2 of 14
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
The house has been cleaned up and Mr. Blake plans to move into it.
Chairman Godek
asked what needs to be done and when he will come into compliance. Mr.
Blake responded that he can come into compliance by Monday, November 1st, which includes
the demolition of the pool screen (after obtaining a permit) and the securing of the pool water.
Officer Delgado
confirmed that this would be satisfactory.
Member Hopper, Vice-Chair M. Godek
seconded by , moved in Case No. 10-248 to give the
respondent until November 5, 2010 to come into compliance or be fined of $100 per day per
each violation for everyday thereafter. Motion carried unanimously.
Case No. 10-266 – Diane / Alfred Leopold
419 Abbeyridge Court Officer Delgado
Violation Cited: 108-23 Q, 108-35
10-05-10 NOV Re-inspection date: 10/11/10
10-11-10 SOV
10-11-10 NOH Meeting Date: 10/26/10
10-11-10 POS Reg. & Certified Mail
10-15-10 POS Posting
Observation:
Aluminum awning half detached and hanging from structure, to unsanitary condition without
electric and water supply, after requesting to obtain permit on September 15, 2010.
Officer Delgado Officer
presented the case and gave history. Exhibits were also presented.
Delgado
testified that she has called the owner. Mr. Chris Blake told her that he had not been
Officer Delgado
able to get the occupants to leave. secured the dwelling and cited the
Office Delgado
occupants. The property is now vacant and in compliance. is requesting the
cost that it took to secure the structure: $300.
Member Osborne
asked if code enforcement told him to stop work and then cited them for
stopping the work. She was not clear as to how City could cite him for stopping and leaving
Officer Delgado
the property in an unsafe condition. explained that she had requested that he
pull the permit to finish the work.
Member Hopper
felt that the City should split the cost with the HOA. He said that the City
Member Osborne
should not bear the entire cost. reminded the board that the HOA had
Alt. Member Kelley
contacted code enforcement about the problem. added that the HOA
had no authority to take action.
Vice-Chair M. Godek
said that the board had gotten off topic. He said that if a store was
Officer
robbed, Code Enforcement would not be called. They would call the police.
Delgado
explained that she was called due to her notices being left at the property.
Vice-Chair M. GodekOfficer Delgado
said that he is not sure that it is a 'fineable' matter.
Member Osborne
said that she is looking for the owner to be responsible. asked what
Page 3 of 14
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
Officer Delgado
exactly was done to merit the $300. said that the City had rekeyed the left
front door lock, installed a bolt to secure the other door (the front door is a double door),
replaced wood into the sliding door track to keep it closed, two fence boards were replaced,
and a police officer worked 1 hour and 45 minutes securing the property.
Vice-Chair M. Godek
concluded that basically they abated the nuisance before it was a
Officer Delgado
documented nuisance. answered no, since she cited the property on October
th
Vice-Chair M. Godek
5. said that the citation was for the awning. He continued that it
seemed as though the City abated the nuisance prior to it becoming a documented nuisance.
Officer Delgado
agreed noting that she has three cases on the property, but the current case is
actually for the structure and for the awning.
Member OsborneMember Lowery
concluded that this case links to the previous case. said
Officer Delgado
that he questioned what the photos really showed. explained the photos.
Attorney Sneed
clarified that the previous case was about not having a permit. The current
case is about not maintaining the property correctly.
Mr. Chris Blake,
6147 Huckleberry Lane, nephew to Alfred Leopold spoke about having
stopped the work according to the stop work order. He claims that the aluminum was stolen
Chairman Godek
which actually brought the property into compliance. asked if Officer
Delgado was asking the board to find the respondent in compliance and reimburse the City
Officer Delgado
$300. confirmed that this was her request.
Member HopperMember Alexander
, seconded by , moved in case number 10-266 to find the
respondent in violation as cited as of October 10, 2010, and in compliance as of October 13,
2010; that no fine be assessed, as cited and that the city be reimbursed $300 for City’s time
and labor to secure the building . Motion carried unanimously.
Case No. 10-252 – Diane / Alfred Leopold
419 Abbeyridge Court Officer Delgado
Violation Cited: 108-19A, C, D, E, (1)(2), 108-25B
09-30-10 NOV Re-inspection 10-01-10
10-11-10 SOV
10-11-10 NOH Meeting Date: 10-26-10
10-11-10 POS Reg. & Certified Mail
10-15-10 POS Posting
Observation:
No open water account since September with City of Ocoee Utilities Department. The wastewater
system was not properly being disposed without active utilities. There were multiple people renting rooms in the
home.
Officer Delgado
presented the case and gave its history. She found the property to be in
compliance as of today's date given the rooms are not being rented and the house is empty.
Page 4 of 14
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
Mr. Chris Blake
, 6147 Huckleberry Avenue, thanked Officer Delgado for her assistance, and
agreed to comply with the directions given to him.
Attorney Sneed
clarified that the city has already found the property in violation in 10-248;
hence, the board can just deal with the 108-19 matter.
Member OsborneAlt. Member Kelley
, seconded by , moved that in case no. 10-252 the
respondent be found in violation as of October 1, 2010, but in compliance as of 10/26/10 and
no be fine assessed. The motion carried unanimously.
Case No. 10-251 – Mohammed Hassan
250 Misty Meadow Drive Officer Delgado
Violation Cited: 165-3, 165-4, 165-7
09-30-10 NOV Re-inspection date: repeat violation
10-01-10 SOV
10-01-10 NOH Meeting Date: 10-26-10
10-01-10 POS Reg. & Certified Mail
10-15-10 POS Posting
Observation:
Truck in driveway with two flat tires / inoperable vehicle.
Officer Delgado
presented the case and gave its history. This is a repeat violator, the officer
declared. Due to a computer glitch, there are no photos, but the vehicle is the same one that
was in violation on March 1, 2010. On October 11, 2010, she received a call to re-inspect,
and found that the vehicle was gone from the property. As of today the property is in
compliance.
Member HopperOfficer Delgado
clarified that the property is in compliance. responded
affirmatively.
Mr. Joaquin Gutierrez
, 250 Misty Meadow Drive, said that the truck is getting fixed and
that he did not know what more that he could do.
Attorney Sneed
clarified that the only violation the board is looking at is 165-3.
Chairman Godek
thanked Mr. Gutierrez and asked him to have a seat. The chairman then
stated that the board has the option to forgive the debt or fine him $500 per day.
Member Osborne
asked if the complaint was made by a neighbor. She confirmed that it was
made by a neighbor.
Alt. Member KelleyOfficer Delgado
asked how long the truck had been that way. answered
that the truck was that way for about a month.
Attorney Sneed
said that the evidence they have before them is as of the date of the officer's
Page 5 of 14
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
observance of the violation which was for 12 days.
Mr. Hassan
, (inaudible), spoke about the property. He denied that the truck was there for a
Chairman Godek
month. confirmed that there has been a repeat violation based on the
evidence.
Mr. Gutierrez
spoke again and said that he got injured working construction and tries to do
Member Hopper
whatever work he can. explained that the violation had happened more
than one time, and that it is not all about Mr. Gutierrez. The neighbors have rights also. The
board member reminded Mr. Gutierrez that as a renter, he has an obligation to the City to at
least make contact with the City.
Member OsborneMember Hopper
, seconded by , moved that the respondent in case no. 10-
251 be found in violation of 165-3 as of September 30, 2010, but in compliance as of October
11, 2010 and be assessed a fine of $50 because of the repeat violation. Motion carried
unanimously.
Chairman Godek
greeted Mayor Scott. He asked to address the board about HOAs.
Mayor Vandergrift
said that HOAs have become a panacea to staff to pass the buck. He
urged the board to keep in mind to assist the HOAs who assists the City in making folks
aware of the rules; they are not the end all, be all when it comes to code enforcement.
Case No. 06-117 – David W. Driesse
471 Little Aspen Court, Ocoee
Violation Cited: 115-5; 115-3; 108-23 Q
08-10-06 NOV Re-inspection date: 08-28-06
08-30-06 SOV
08-30-06 NOH Meeting date: 09-26-06
08-30-06 POS Certified mail
09-06-06 POS Regular mail
09-06-06 POS Posting
09-26-06 CO Given until 10-10-06 or pay $150 per day.
10-11-06 ANC
10-24-06 OIFL As of 10-11-06
10-12-09 AOC
10-14-09 OIFL Total due: $j164,400.00
10-14-09 POS Reg. & certified mail
09-29-10 OIFL Corrected copy
Observation:
Weed/grass growth over 10”. Also large dead tree limbs and branches in backyard. Also 8ft.
white fence, in backyard in poor condition..
Officer Siegrist
presented the case and gave its history. This case is a continuation from the
Officer Siegrist
meeting of September 28, 2010. said that there was an error in the report, but
the error was corrected.
Page 6 of 14
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
Member HopperAttorney Sneed
asked if any action needs to be taken. said that this is a
lien reduction case, so the board will be making a recommendation to the Commission.
Mr. David Driesse
, 471 Little Aspen Court, said that at the last meeting he was not actually
sure if the letter was for him because it had the wrong name on it. He said that the citation he
received about a boat in his driveway was actually his neighbor's boat. He asked his neighbor
to move the boat, and the neighbor did. He is requesting a reduction in fine or a dismissal of
the violation.
Member HopperMr. Driesse
asked if he knew what the fine was for. said he did know; it
Member Hopper
was for a tree down in the backyard and tall grass and weeds in the yard.
Mr. DriesseMember Hopper
asked if Mr. Driesse ever got a notice in 2006. said no. asked
Officer Siegrist.
staff if there was documentation about the matter. answered affirmatively
Member Osborne
asked where the notice could have gone.
Mr. Driesse
said that the property is being maintained and has been brought up to code.
Member HopperMr. Driesse
asked what the notice was for. said it was for a tree that had
Member Hopper
fallen. asked if it just took him a while to clean it up.
Attorney Sneed
said that Mr. Driesse received satisfactory notice but there is not proof that
he actually got it.
Mr. DriesseMr. Driesse
said that he has no idea how long he was out of compliance. said
that he has spent an awful lot of money bringing the property into compliance.
Member Hopper
said that he was really trying to help Mr. Driesse out, and that he needed
Mr. Driesse to tell them that he made contact with the City about the matter. Mr. Driesse said
that if he knows he needs to correct something, he does so right away.
Alt. Member Kelley
asked how Mr. Driesse found out that the tree was in his backyard, and
Mr. Driesse
when did he know it. replied that he is sure that the tree came down during the
Alt. Member Kelley
storm, but he does not know the date. continued that Mr. Driesse had
Alt. Member Kelley
said that he hired a group of men to help clean up the property. asked
Mr. Driesse
Mr. Driesse when he hired those people. could not give a specific date.
Member AlexanderMr.
asked if he notified the city once the problem was corrected.
Driesse
replied that he did not.
Vice Chair Godek
asked if he mentioned before that people were hired to cut the tree down.
Mr. Driesse
The vice chair expressed doubt that this fact just slipped Mr. Driesse's mind. said
that he mentioned the matter in his letter to Deputy Fire Chief Butch Stanley.
Page 7 of 14
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
Alt. Member Kelley
said that Mr. Driesse said that he borrowed money to pay someone to
Mr. Driesse
clean it up. The member asked when that was. said he would have to check his
bank records.
Member Hopper
A motion was made. Discussion ensued as follows: said that he thinks that
Vice-Chair M. Godek
Mr. Driesse has done a good job cleaning up the property. said that he
felt the same way, it is just a matter of how they got here with the matter.
Member Hopper
advised Mr. Driesse to attend the commission meeting when this matter
comes before the commission.
Member HopperMember Osborne
, seconded by , moved in case no. 06-117 that the board
recommend to the Commission that the fine be reduced to $2,500. The motion carried
unanimously.
(Member Lowery stepped out 8:17 p.m.)
Case No. 08-121 – Juan T. Patino and Yadira Vasquez
2000 Lauren Beth Avenue Officer T. Rodriguez
Violation Cited: 105.4, 54-128
04-30-08 NOCV Re-inspection date: 5-15-08
06-03-08 SOV
06-03-08 NOH Meeting date: 6-24-08
06-03-08 POS Reg. & certified mail
06-11-08 POS Posting
07-02-08 POS Reg. & certified mail
07-10-08 POS Posting
07-22-08 CO In v/ as cited on 5-14-08 and given until 8-15-08 to comply or be fined
$100/day
08-16-08 ANC
08-26-08 OIFL Recorded
10-13-09 ANC
12-14-09 ANC
Observation:
Failure to obtain any required final inspections for an additional garage, permit #0602442, issued
on October 16, 2006 expired on April 14, 2007 and $50.00 due for re-inspection fee.
Vice Chair M. GodekMember Alexander
, seconded by , moved to re-hear case no. 08-121
regarding a reduction of fine. The motion carried unanimously with Member Lowery away
from the dais.
Office SiegristAttorney Sneed
presented the case and gave its history. clarified that the
compliance was as of September 23, 2010.
Ms. Evelyn Pilchick,
a real estate agent representing the listed property at 2000 Lauren Beth
,
Avenue said that this is a property that was foreclosed upon. She met with Officer Bob Frost
to find out what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance by September 23rd.
Page 8 of 14
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
The bank acquired the property as of June 10th.
Member OsborneMs Pilchick
asked the listing price on the house. replied that the list price
Member HopperMs. Pilchick
is $51,900. asked if the property is in compliance. responded
Alt. Member Kelley
affirmatively. said it appeared that the property was cleaned up in less
than six weeks of notification of the violations.
Alt. Member Kelley
moved to recommend the reduction of the fine to $0. The motion died
for lack of a second.
Member OsborneeMember Hopper
, seconded by , moved to recommend that the fine in case
08-121 be reduced to $250. The motion carried with one ‘no’ vote by Alt. Member Kelley.
Chairman Godek
(8:27 p.m. - calls for a five minute recess)
Chairman Godek
(8:34 p.m. – calls the meeting to order; all board members are present.)
Case No. 10-271 – Jose Gonzalez
403 Little Spring Hill Drive Officer Loeffler
Violation Cited: 115-3
09-08-10 NOV Re-inspection date: 09-16-10
10-13-10 SOV
10-13-10 NOH Meeting date: 10-26-10
10-13-10 POS Reg. & certified mail
10-14-10 POS Posting
Observation:
Miscellaneous junk, trash, debris, orange fencing material in backyard visible to adjacent
neighbors and across lake park visitors.
Officer Loeffler
presented the case and gave its history. He presented exhibits (including
th
photos). As of September 16, the property was non-compliant and remains so.
Member HopperOfficer
asked if the officer inspected the property today or yesterday.
Loeffler
answered that he inspected the property yesterday and today.
Alt. Member Kelley
asked if the respondent had been spoken to by code enforcement staff.
Officer Loeffler
answered affirmatively.
Member AlexanderVice Chair M. Godek,
, seconded by moved to find in case no. 10-271 that
the respondent is in violation as of September 15, 2010, and that the respondent be given until
November 22, 2010, to come into compliance or face $100 /day fines. The motion carried by
4 – 3 with Members Hopper, Lowery, and Kelley opposing.
Case No. 10-272 – Marla Colli
472 Wurst Road Officer Loeffler
Page 9 of 14
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
Violation Cited: 168-6 D
09-03-10 NOCV Re-inspection date: 09-16-10
10-13-10 SOV
10-13-10 NOH Meeting Date: Meeting date: 10-26-10
10-14-10 POS Posting
Observation:
Bus type vehicle parked / stored on property; prohibited by code.
Officer Loeffler
gave a brief history of the case. The property is in compliance as of today.
Vice Chair M. GodekMember Alexander,
, seconded by moved in case no. 10-272, the
property be found in violation as of September 11, 2010, and in compliance as of October 26,
2010, and that no fine be assessed at this time. The motion carried unanimously.
Vice Chair M. Godek
made mention that the respondent would be subject to being classified
as a repeat offender should this violation be filed against the respondent within the next five
years.
OTHER BUSINESS
Case No. 10-081 – Maggie Jones
1104 Doreen Avenue Officer Rodriguez
Violation Cited: 51-13
04-14-10 NOCV Re-inspection date: 05-03-10
05-06-10 SOV
05-06-10 NOH Meeting Date: 05-25-10
05-06-10 POS Regular & certified mail
05-13-10 POS Posting
05-27-10 OC Extension until 8-24-10
05-27-10 POS Reg. & certified mail
08-24-10 OC Extension until 10-15-10
10-19-10 ANC
Observation:
OBTAIN REQUIRED PERMITS
Officer Siegrist
presented the case and gave its history. The case was originally heard at the
th
May 25, 2010 meeting. There is an Affidavit of non-compliance as of October 19. A fine
should be imposed.
Board members discussed the matter that extensions had been granted previously in this case.
An order of compliance was extended until October 15th.
Member Osborne
began to make a motion to impose a fine effective October 16th until
Attorney Sneed
compliance is reached; however, advised that the board should find the
respondent in violation first.
Member OsborneMember Hopper,
, seconded by movedthat in case no. 10-081, that the
respondent be found in violation as of October 15, 2010 and be given until November 13,
Page 10 of 14
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
2010 to comply or be assessed a fine of $100/day. The motion carried unanimously.
Case No. 10-219 Joseph C. Elcinette / Emmanuel J-Pierre
2026 Cassingham Circle Officer Delgado
Violation Cited: 115-5, 115-7
08-19-10 NOCV Re-Inspection Date: REPEAT VIOLATION
08-19-10 SOV
08-19-10 NOH Meeting Date: 09-28-10
08-19-10 POS Regular & Certified Mail
09-28-10 PER C.E.B. FOUND IN REPEAT VIOLATION AS CITED 8-1-10 & FINED
$750.00 FOR THE REPEAT VIOATION. GIVEN UNTIL 10-05-10 TO
COMPLY OR BE FINED ADDITIONAL FEE OF $100.00 PER DAY.
0928-10 CO Regular & Certified Mail
10-07-10 ANC
Observation:
Excessive weed or grass growth duty of property owner.
Officer Delgado
presented the case and gave its history. The property is in compliance as of
today. This is a repeat violation and was assessed a fine of $100/day. No one connected with
the property has called code enforcement.
Attorney Sneed
said that because it is a repeat violation, they can be assessed $500/day.
Vice Chair M. Godek
asked if they could combine it all into one lump sum.
Attorney Sneed
said if they want to stay with order, it is $2,850 total. The board can raise
the amount or lower it and do an order of fine in the amount of ‘X’.
Vice Chair Godek
said that this is the property’s fourth violation, and given that the
Member Hopper
paperwork is in order, the violator appears to be choosing not to comply.
agreed.
Vice Chair M. GodekMember Hopper
, seconded by , moved in case no. 10-219 to impose a
fine of $2500. The motion carried unanimously.
Case No. 10-236 – Gaitree / Rory Shanahan
1334 Vickers Lake Drive Officer Delgado
Violation Cited: 115-1, 115-5A, 108-23 (1) (2)
08-19-10 NOCV Re-Inspection Date: 09-01-10
09-03-10 SOV
09-03-10 NOH Meeting Date: 09-28-10
09-03-10 POS Regular and Certified Mail
09-17-10 POS Posting
09-28-10 PER C.E.B. Found in violation as cited on 8-29-10. To comply by 10-08-10 or fine of
$100 per day, per violation. Also allow City to Abate and add costs to fine.
09-28-10 CO Regular & Certified Mail
Page 11 of 14
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
09-15-10 ANC
Observation:
Conditions constituting a nuisance general requirements interior / exterior excessive weed or
grass growth.
Officer Delgado
presented the case and gave its history. She presented exhibits (including
photos). An affidavit of non-compliance was issued on October 11, 2010. The property is in
Officer Delgado
compliance as of October 21, 2010. received a letter from the bank
(Chase), dated October 14, 2010, that the property maintenance was completed. The officer
received the letter on October 21, 2010.
Chairman GodekAttorney Sneed
clarified that they could decide to not assess a fine.
confirmed this.
Alt.
A motion was made that no fine be assessed. During the discussion phase of the motion,
Member Kelley
asked what the difference was between this case and the last case that the
bank owned the property, but a fine was still assessed $250.
Member Osborne
said the other case was a fine reduction and the property was out of
Alt. Member Kelley
compliance for quite some time. noted that the bank was not out of
compliance, but rather the previous owner. Bank took ownership in June and got it cleaned
up right away.
Member Osbornee
said this case (10-236) was of much shorter duration.
Member Hopper Member Osborne,
, seconded bymoved in case no. 10-236, that no fine be
assessed. The motion carried unanimously.
Deputy Chief Butch Stanley’s Agenda
Staff will be requesting a motion to authorize the city attorney to proceed with foreclosure or
Attorney Sneed
money judgment on each property. clarified how it is that the city can
foreclose on the properties based on statute requirement.
Member OsborneAttorney Sneed
asked if the properties were in the mall or freestanding.
said that the board is authorizing the city attorney to foreclose or get a judgment. All real
Chairman Godek
property, as well as the liened property, is subject to action. remarked that
Deputy Chief Stanley
this had not been done since his five years on the board. responded
that code enforcement is trying to move forward on the matter rather than keeping them in the
drawer for someone else to deal with.
Member Osborne
asked if these were properties in the mall or freestanding. She asked how
Attorney Sneed
the city can foreclose on them. said that the board can authorized code
enforcement to proceed. If it is property that cannot be foreclosed upon, they can file an
Page 12 of 14
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
action to recover the monetary amount. The lien is a lien on all real property, even if the
property included a Van Gogh, for example, the attorney said.
The deputy chief brought forward case number 09-027, Gaterson Inc. at the West Oaks Mall,
9401 West Colonial Drive. He declared that staff is asking that the city attorney be authorized
to foreclose and sue for money damages to recover the amount of the fine on the property.
Vice Chair M. GodekMember Alexander
, seconded by , moved to authorize the City
Attorney’s office to proceed to foreclosure or reduce the lien to a judgment. The motion
carried unanimously.
Attorney Sneed
For the remaining cases said that the deputy chief could read the cases into
the record and then the board could make a motion on the cases as a group.
09-216 Savanah Grace Bridal, LLC 9401 West Colonial Drive
09-199 Perfect Brow Fl, Inc., same
09-240 Intouch Wireless, same
09-244 1991 Rushden Drive
09-012 844Patirot’s point drive
10-032 709 Lakeview Drive
07-106 709 Lakeview Drive
10-049 709 Lakeview Drive
09-258 2717 Plumberry Ave
10-112 2717 Plumberry Ave.
09-155 2243 Laurel Blossom Circle
09-304 2243 Laurel Blossom Circle
09-182 2226 Cassingham Circle
10-047 2026 Cassingham Circle
07-149 1400 Samantha St
99-087 160 Little Springhill Dr
09-246 2388 Elmira Drive
09-005 1709 Cambridge Village
09-064F 1515 Wurst Road
Deputy Chief Stanley
declared that all of the properties read into the record are within the
City of Ocoee.
Vice Chair GodekMember Hopper
, seconded by moved to authorize the city attorney to
foreclose or reducing the lien to judgment in the cases of 09-216, 09-199, 09-240, 09-244,
09-012, 10-032, 07-106, 10-049, 09-258, 10-112, 09-155, 09-304, 09-182, 10-047, 07-149,
99-087, 09-246, 09-005, 09-064F. The motion carried unanimously.
The deputy fire chief said that there will be a few more of these properties coming to the
board.
Page 13 of 14
Code Enforcement Board Minutes
October 26, 2010
Board Meeting Schedule
Vice Chair M. GodekMember Alexander
, seconded by , moved to have a meeting in
November and not December. The motion carried unanimously.
COMMENTS
Member Alexander
wished everyone a Happy Halloween
Vice Chair M. Godek
thanked the code enforcement staff for their work.
Member Hopper
– commended the deputy fire chief for his efforts to batch the cases which
will save both time and money.
ADJOURNMENT
Meeting adjourned at 9:15 p.m.
Attest: APPROVED:
________________________________ _______________________
Stella McLeod, M. R. Coordinator Robert Godek, Chairman
Page 14 of 14