HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem #01 Approval of Minutes for the Regular Commission Meeting held December 15, 2015 MINUTES
December 15,2015;201$at 7:15 P.M.
REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING
PRE MEETING PRESENTATIONS ♦6:45 PM
Ocoee Bulldogs Presentation
Mayor Johnson introduced the Ocoee Bulldogs Cheerleaders as well as the Ocoee Bulldogs Pop
Warner Football Players and coaches who recently won the National Championships.
Christmas Parade Trophies Presentation—Ocoee Lions Club
Before awarding parade trophies, Ocoee Lions Club Member Cathy Sills presented a $300
check to the Ocoee Police Department to go toward their Kids In Need Program. Monetary
donations as well as toys were collected during the parade.
Youth
1st Place—Young Blacks in Action
2"dPlace— Central Florida Youth Football League (CFYFL) Ocoee Cardinals Cheer and Football
3rdPlace— Ocoee Bulldogs
Honorable Mention — Cub Scout Pack 217
Non-Commercial
1st Place—American Legion Post 109
2"dPlace — Mrs. Orange County International 2015
3rdPlace — Bahia Shrine
Commercial
1St Place— Martial Arts World of MetroWest
2"dPlace— Ready, Set, Dance!
3rdPlace—West Orange Chamber of Commerce Ambassadors
Honorable Mention — Metro-State Special Services
Honorable Mention — H&R Block
Church
1st Place — Knights of Columbus
2"dPlace — First Baptist Church of Ocoee
3rdPlace — Liberty Lighthouse Church
Honorable Mention — Starke Lake Baptist Church
REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING
A. CALL TO ORDER ♦7:15 PM
Mayor Johnson called the regular session to order at 7:15 p.m. in the Commission Chambers of
City Hall. Commissioner Keller gave the invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance to
the Flag, led by Boy Scout Pack 217. City Clerk Eikenberry called roll and declared a quorum
present.
Roll Call: Commissioner Grogan, Commissioner Wilsen, Mayor Johnson, Commissioner
Keller.
Regular City Commission
December 15,2015
B.PRESENTATIONS AND PROCLAMATIONS
Presentation by Jack Vinson—Tennis Player of the Year Jason Joseph—Cancelled
Life Saving Award to Officer Fabiola Parke by Police Chief Brown
Police Chief Brown gave a brief summary of the heroic event by Officer Fabiola Parke that
helped save the life of a citizen who was in crisis. Officer Fabiola Parke is unable to attend the
commission meeting but was publicly recognized for her heroic efforts. She will also receive
department commendation as well as a ribbon which she can wear for 30 days on her uniform.
Presentation by Support Services Department Regarding the City's Website, use of Social
Media and Sunshine Law Communication Restrictions
Support Services Director Butler gave a PowerPoint presentation explaining the City's
website, website maintenance, broken links, and archiving. Social media benefits were also
covered as well as the retaining of social media postings and Florida Sunshine Laws
requirements.
Before public presentation and public comments, Mayor Johnson briefly read the civility code
and advised the time limits allowed for presentations and public comments. He further advised
that from now forward they will try to comply with these time constraints unless there is an issue
that requires more time.
Ocoee World Fest Presentation
William Maxwell, Chairman of the Ocoee World Fest Sub-Committee said he is before the
Commission seeking permission to proceed with an event that has been in the making for several
years. He briefly gave a PowerPoint presentation introducing the event team of the Ocoee World
Fest Sub-Committee. Included in his presentation were the site layout, event budget, revenue
plan, and timeline efforts for their website and sponsorship.
Mr. Maxwell inquired if this event is something that the City really needs or wants and if it is
not would the Commission consider allowing their sub-committee to continue to plan for
consideration of an event in a future year. He further addressed several questions from the
Commission regarding the budget and sponsorships. Support Services Director Butler briefed
the board regarding the commitment of the city as the legal entity and the receipt of donations
which would be payable to the City. After a brief discussion, consensus of the Commission was
to move forward with the Ocoee World Fest event by having Mr. Maxwell meet with City staff
and the City Attorney to finalize any issues so they may bring this item back to discuss at a later
meeting.
♦8:30 PM 15 MIN. RECESS —Arrival of Operation Santa
C.COMMENTS FROM CITIZENS/PUBLIC ♦8:45 PM
Gary Hood, 2028 Hedgerow Circle, addressed the Commission regarding the condition of
several scoreboards out on the fields which need to be replaced. He provided a handout with
price quotes for various scoreboards and asked the Commission to please consider replacing or
splitting the cost for replacement of those scoreboards since they are located in City park/ball
fields.
2IPage
Regular City Commission
December 15,2015
Consensus of the Commission was that this should be covered by the City since the scoreboards
are located in City parks. Discussion ensued regarding where the funds would be allocated from
to cover the cost of the scoreboards since this not a capital item during the last budget process.
Commissioner Keller, seconded by Commissioner Grogan, moved to grant the
Ocoee Little League up to $18,000 out of Contingency for the scoreboards with
the caveat that as much as possible would be returned to Contingency at the mid-
year budget review. Motion carried 4-0.
D.STAFF REPORTS AND AGENDA REVIEW
City Manager Frank announced there is an Emergency Item on the dais for them to consider:
Emergency Item - Contract Extension with Genuine Parts Company, doing business as
NAPA and Assigned to Glenn Joiner & Sons, Inc., Providing On-Site Management of the
Fleet Parts Supply
Public Works Director Krug briefly explained that the original NJPA contract was to expire on
February 24, 2016; however, NJPA re-bid and awarded a new contract in July 2015, superseding
and voiding the original contract. NJPA has awarded a new contract to Genuine Parts Company
(NAPA) which offers the same benefits to the City as the original contract. Public Works was in
the process of obtaining a new agreement with NAPA under the new NJPA contract when we
were notified the original contract was voided.
While contract documents are obtained to be presented to the Commission at a meeting in the
near future, Public Works is requesting Commission approval to continue using the existing
contract pricing with Glenn Joiner & Sons, Inc. for parts until the new contract can be brought
before the Commission for execution. There is no anticipation in costs or material changes to the
contract at this point.
Commissioner Wilsen, seconded by Commissioner Keller, moved to grant a
Contract Extension with Genuine Parts Company, doing business as NAPA and
Assigned to Glenn Joiner & Sons, Inc., Providing On-Site Management of the
Fleet Parts Supply. Motion carried 4-0.
E. COMMISSIONERS ANNOUNCEMENTS ♦8:45 PM
Commissioner Grogan-None
Commissioner Wilsen- 1) thanked Ocoee Lions Club for the Christmas Parade. It was a
wonderful event. 2) Announced this Saturday and Sunday the Ocoee Lions Club and Ocoee
Rotary Club will be volunteering to ring the bell for the Salvation Army. 3) Announced the
Annual Spring Fling Event is coming up March 12th and she is asking the Commission if they
can grant the use of the Ocoee Lakeshore Center for the Saving Young Hearts group which will
be providing heart screenings during the event. It was clarified that they would possibly need it
Friday night for set-up and Saturday all day for the heart screenings.
Commissioner Grogan, seconded by Commissioner Keller, moved to approve the
use of the Ocoee Lakeshore Center by Saving Young Hearts for the evening of
March 11th (if available) and all day March 12th, for their heart screenings during
the Spring Fling Event. Motion carried 4-0.
3 (Page
Regular City Commission
December 15,2015
Mayor Johnson-None
Commissioner Keller-None
F. CONSENT AGENDA •8:5L1 PM
Consent Agenda Motion
Motion: Commissioner Keller, seconded by Commissioner Wilsen moved to
adopt the Consent Agenda as presented by staff. Motion carried 4-0.
1. Approval of Minutes for the Regular Commission Meeting held December 1, 2015.
(City Clerk Eikenberry)
Approved on Consent. Motion carried 4-0
2. Reappointment to the Citizen Advisory Council for Ocoee Police Department (three-
year term). (City Clerk Eikenberry)
Members of the Citizen Advisory Council for Ocoee Police Department serve three-year terms. The Resolution
creating the Board allows no more than fifteen (15) members. Currently the board has eleven (11) members
and no applications on file. The terms of Members Victoria Laney and Timothy Alcuri will expire on January 1,
2016. Member Victoria Laney has indicated she is willing to serve another three-year term, if reappointed.
Member Timothy Alcuri has declined reappointment.
Approved on Consent. Motion carried 4-0
3. Approval of Utility Easement with SprintCo, Inc.,for the Maintenance and Installation
of Underground Facilities on a City Parcel located at 843 Marshall Farms Road. (City
Engineer Wheeler)
Back in December of 1993,the then property owners of the parcel of land located at 843 Marshall Farms Road
granted a Perpetual Easement for Egress and Ingress to then owners of the parcel located at 835 Marshall Farms
Road. The easement was a 12 foot wide easement located along the northern boundary of the parcel at 843
Marshall Farms Road. The parcel at 843 Marshall Farms Road is now owned by the City and is to be used for a
retention pond for the construction of the widening of Maguire Road from Mercantile Court to Geneva/Story
Road. The parcel at 835 Marshall Farms Road is owned by Dobson Holding LLC, and the parcel has been
further subdivided to allow for a SprintCom cell tower. Both Dobson and SprintCom have been using the
easement to access their property.
Approximately three years ago, the City received a permit application to modify the cell tower and to replace
from underground facilities from the cell tower to Marshall Farms Road. Staff reviewed the permit application
and numerous other documents to determine that no utility easement existed over the parcel at 843 Marshall
Farms Road. SprintCom had assumed that the utility easement granted by the previous owners of the lot at 835
Marshall Farms Road also provided for a utility easement over the parcel now owned by the City. After a few
years of research and discussions by City staff and SprintCom, it was determined that a utility easement did not
exist. However, there are underground conduits already existing in the Perpetual Easement for Egress and
Ingress. By providing a Utility Easement to SprintCom, Inc.this will clean up an issue that has probably existed
since SprintCom first built the cell tower on the 835 Marshall Farms Road property in 2002.
Approved on Consent. Motion carried 4-0
41Page
Regular City Commission
December 15,2015
4. Approval of the Second Amendment to the Development Agreement Ocoee Pines
Planned Unit Development(PUD). (City Planner Rumer)
On October 6, 2015, the Preliminary/Final Subdivision Plan for Ocoee Pines PUD was approved by the City
Commissioners as presented. Accordingly, the Development Agreement is required to be amended in order to
be consistent with the Approved Preliminary/Final Subdivision Plan. As a result,the Second Amendment to the
Development Agreement incorporates the final agreed upon Conditions of Approval for the Ocoee Pines PUD.
Approved on Consent. Motion carried 4-0
5. Approval..of the First Amendment to the Development Agreement Westyn Bay
Commercial Planned Unit Development(PUD). (City Planner Rumer)
On October 7, 2014, the City Commission reviewed and approved the Westyn Bay Commercial PUD and
corresponding Land Use Plan for subject property. On September 15, 2015, the Preliminary/Final Subdivision
Plan for Westyn Bay Commercial PUD was approved by the City Commission, as presented. Accordingly,the
Development Agreement is required to be amended in order to be consistent with the Approved
Preliminary/Final Subdivision Plan. As a result, the First Amendment to the Development Agreement
incorporates the final agreed upon off-site improvements(Section 5)for the Westyn Bay Commercial PUD.
Approved on Consent. Motion carried 4-0
6. Approval of Cost-Share Grant from St. Johns River Water Management District for
Replacement of 500 Meters with Upgrade to AMI and Aquallawk Alerting. (Utilities
Director Smith)
The Utilities Department began to utilize the Sensus FlexNet®communication system in 2010 after Commission
approved its use, the first tower was installed, and the system was implemented. Water meters that are
connected to the Advanced Metering Infrastructure(AMI)which FlexNet®provides can be read at the touch of
a button. The AMI also enables the City to access nearly real-time usage data from the meters connected to it.
As of the commencement of this Staff Report, approximately 6,500 of the 14,000 water meters in Ocoee are
connected to the AMI.
Currently, the City has three (3)types of meters in the ground. The original touch read meters, which must be
read manually, one at a time. Radio read meters require a field technician to drive by them with a handheld
computer which receives the data. Finally, "smart" meters, those connected to the FlexNet® AMI, are
continually read. The Utilities Department's goal is to connect all water meters to the FlexNet®AMI. For many
meters,this requires replacement.Each year as the Department launches its regular meter replacement schedule,
those meters are replaced with Sensus iPerl®meters, which have the capability to be connected to the FlexNet®
AMI.This infrastructure also facilitates customers to utilize the AquaHawk customer portal.
The City of Ocoee has been awarded a matching Cost-Share Agreement from St. Johns River Water
Management District (SJRWMD), with funding support from the Florida Department of Environmental
Protection (FDEP), with a grant in the not-to-exceed amount of$55,735.00, for the replacement of 500 meters
with upgrade to AMI with AquaHawk Alerting capability. The neighborhoods designated for these meters
include Coventry,Hidden Glen,Lakewood Manor,Richfield,and Silver Bend.
Approved on Consent. Motion carried 4-0
7. Approval of Settlement Agreement for Past Due Development Review Fees, (City
Attorney Cookson)
In conjunction with the City's review of project SS-2008-005 for Shoppes at the Village, owner, Gustavo M.
Romer, President, Romerca International, Inc. (Romerca), incurred development review fees in the amount of
$4,693.65. The fees remain outstanding and,as part of the City's collection efforts, on September 29,2015,the
City Attorney's office sent a letter to Romerca requesting payment. Romerca responded to the City Attorney's
letter by requesting he pay fees on a monthly basis until paid in full. Romerca and the City Attorney's office
ultimately agreed to present a settlement agreement to the City Commission to allow Romerca to pay $200.00
per month for 23 months and$93.65 as the final payment in month 24. If approved,the first payment is due on
January 2,2016.
Approved on Consent. Motion carried 4-0
5IPage
Regular City Commission
December 15,2015
G. PUBLIC HEARING •8:51 PM
8. Capital Improvements Element—Amendment Addition of the Fiscal Years 2015/2016
2019/2020 Capital Improvements Program. (Advertised in the Orlando Sentinel On Sunday,
December 3,2015). (City Planner Rumer)
The Capital Improvement Element(CIE)of the City of Ocoee Comprehensive Plan is a requirement of Chapter
163,Florida Statutes(FS)and enables implementation of the Plan goals,objectives,and policies needing capital
funding for a 5-20 year planning horizon. Each year,the table section of the CIE will be updated to ensure that
the adopted list of capital projects in the CIE matches the City's newly adopted fiscal year budget and approved
five-year Capital Improvements Program (CIP). The CIE does not propose any new projects not previously
reviewed and approved by the Commission.
The Florida Legislature enacted legislation allowing adoption of the annual amendment to the CIE to be
accomplished with a single public adoption hearing.Additionally, State Statute no longer requires a copy of the
Ordinance to be transmitted to the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity (FKA: Department of
Community Affairs"DCA"). Therefore,adoption of this Ordinance is final in its form and content.
City Planner Rumer briefly explained the 5-year Capital Improvement Program was adopted
with the City budget and by statute they have one reading of the ordinance for adoption which
places the Capital Improvement Plan into the Capital Improvement Element of the City of Ocoee
Comprehensive Plan.
City Attorney Cookson read the title of the Ordinance.
Mayor Johnson opened the public hearing. As no one wished to speak the public hearing was
closed.
Commissioner Wilsen, seconded by Commissioner Keller, moved to adopt
Ordinance 2015-027, Capital Improvements Element— Amendment Addition of the
Fiscal Years 2015/2016 — 2019/2020 Capital Improvements Program. Motion
carried 4-0
H. REGULAR AGENDA ♦8:52 PM
9. Discussion and Appointment of District 3 Commissioner. (City Attorney Cookson)
City Attorney Cookson briefed the Commission on the process of appointing a new individual
to serve as the District 3 Commissioner. The appointed Commissioner would serve from the
swearing in at the next City Commission Meeting on January 5, 2016, until the General Election
in March.
Mayor Johnson named Angel de la Portilla as his recommendation. Felt it would be best to not
appoint any of the current candidates that have qualified to run for the District 3 seat in this
upcoming election.
Commissioner Wilsen said that she has been approached by the two candidates qualified to run,
Richard Firstner and Ronney Oliveira, as well as by Angel de la Portilla and Greg Batten
residents from District 3. She agreed that they should consider a person who is not running for
that District seat. She gave a brief summary of both residents.
Commissioner Grogan supported the idea of Angel de la Portilla who is also a member of the
Planning and Zoning Board.
6IPage
Regular City Commission
December 15,2015
Commissioner Keller said he has also been approached by both candidates running and by
Angel de la Portilla. He reiterated it would be best to not appoint any of the current candidates
running for this seat and supports the idea of Angel de la Portilla.
Public Comments
Richard Firstner introduced himself and said he agrees with the Commission's decision
because this will allow the candidates an equal opportunity to campaign and be elected on March
15tH
Michelle Greco, 1896 Compass Flower Way, shared her support for appointing Angel de la
Portilla as District 3 Commissioner.
Angel de la Portilla introduced himself and shared that he will not be running in the upcoming
election due to business and family commitments; however, he would be happy to serve on an
interim basis until the March election and swearing in of the new District 3 Commissioner. He
has served on the Planning and Zoning Commission since 2010 and has resided in the City of
Ocoee for 10 years.
City Attorney Cookson advised Mr. de la Portilla that he would have to resign from the
Planning & Zoning Commission to serve on the City Commission. Mayor Johnson informed
Mr. de la Portilla that they would hold his seat on P&Z so he could be reappointed after the
March election. City Attorney Cookson confirmed with Mr. de la Portilla that his current
consulting business does not represent any developers currently developing in the City. Mr. de
la Portilla answered in the affirmative stating that none of his clients have real estate holdings or
projects in the City of Ocoee so there are no conflicts.
♦9:1O PM MOTION
Commissioner Keller, seconded by Commissioner Grogan, moved to appoint
Angel de la Portilla to serve as interim District 3 Commissioner until the March
15th General Election. Motion carried 4-0.
I. STAFF ACTION ITEMS - none
J. COMMENTS FROM COMMISSIONERS •9:11 PM
Commissioner Keller— Congratulated Angel de la Portilla on his Commission seat appointment
to District 3.
Commissioner Wilsen—Happy Holiday and Happy New Year!
Commissioner Grogan — Congratulated Angel de la Portilla on his Commission seat
appointment to District 3.
Mayor Johnson - 1) inquired about getting a school crossing guard at Lady Ave. and Wurst
Road. Chief Brown said he would look into it 2) clean up at Vignetti Park, light? 3) said he saw
that the chain link fence was being put up at the Ocoee Middle School right along the sidewalk.
He contacted Christine Moore and they have agreed to put a decorative fence and they will move
it back so it is not right on the sidewalk. 4) discussed that the Mayor position is only one vote
just like the rest of the commission and he looks forward to them working together as a team. 5)
7IPage
Regular City Commission
December 15,2015
said he got an e-mail from a resident about no judging of the Christmas Lights. Commissioner
Wilsen explained that the board made that determination because they were getting no new
applicants this year from one's that had won many times in the past.
Commissioner Wilsen wished everyone a Happy Holiday and Happy New Year.
ADJOURNMENT— ♦9:23 PM
APPROVED:
Attest: City of Ocoee
Beth Eikenberry, City Clerk Rusty Johnson,Mayor
8IPage