Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem VI (A) Short List of Geotechnical Engineering and Testing Services AGENDA 12-7-93 Item VI A "CENTER OF GOOD LIVING-PRIDE OF WEST ORANGE" MAYOR*COMMISSIONER • OGG 4 S.SCOTT VANDERGRIFF O. CITY O150 N. F F OCOEE ESHORE DRIVE RUSTY AUL W. R v (4_5 • 0 OCOEE FLORIDA 34761-2258 VERN COMBS �'e `yv (4� 22 JIM GLEASON 9 OF GOOD CITY MANAGER ELLIS SHAPIRO MEMORANDUM DATE: December 2, 1993 TO: The Honorable Mayor and Board of City Commissioners FROM: Montye E. Beamer, Director Administrative Services SUBJECT: Geotechnical Engineering and Testing Services At the November 02, 1993, Commission meeting, the selection committee was authorized to review submitted proposals for geotechnical engineering and testing services and short list for an additional review. The committee met on November 16, 1993, evaluating proposals based upon the RFP criteria. The ranking (scoring shown on the attached tabulation) was as follows: #1) L.J. Nodarse & Associates, Inc. #2) Professional Service Industries, Inc./Jammal & Associates Division #3) Universal Engineering Sciences #4) Hartman & Associates, Inc. #5) Ardaman & Associates, Inc. #6) Advanced Testing Laboratories of Florida, Inc. The top three (3) ranked firms made oral presentations to the Selection Committee on November 30, 1993. The Committee has evaluated the three (3) based upon written proposals, financials submitted, oral presentations, in house abilities and testing capabilities, and reference investigations (results attached). Using this evaluation, the committee ranked the firms as follows: • #1) L.J. Nodarse & Associates, Inc. #2) Professional Service Industries, Inc./Jammal & Associates Division #3) Universal Engineering Sciences The Honorable Mayor and Board of City Commissioners December 2, 1993 Page Two During the November 30, 1993 meeting, the committee also discussed the possibility of contracting with two firms, thus allowing the scope of services and cost to be on a competitive basis, providing an alternate for any project, and expanding resources to the fullest. Two firms on continuing services contracts are optimum without creating major administrative problems; Geotechnical Engineering and Testing Services are usually well- defined and short-lived with tracking much simpler when dealing with only two. The committee respectfully requests that the Mayor and Board of City Commissioners (1) hear the three (3) firms' presentations, (2) rank the firms, (3) allow for two continuing services contracts, and (4) authorize the Selection Committee to proceed with negotiations with the two top-ranked firms. MEB/jbw Attachments WPHI\Docm.OIHCH.MAyC2J c93\C:b.38 L J NODARSE & ASSOCIATES, INC. CITY OF OCOEE PROPOSAL SPECIFICATION CHECK LIST GEOTECHNICAL SERVICES AND TESTING 1 . Did the proposal include : a) Six copies? Yes x No b) The legal name , federal taxpayer identification number, address , and telephone number of the proposer? Yes x No c ) Professional qualifications of firm and specific individuals to be assigned to the project ( including resumes )? Yes x No d) The names of any anticipated subconsultants? Yes No NONE e ) Completed Standard Forms 254 and 255? Yes x No f ) Names, addresses , and previous qualifications if proposing to use specialty consultant services? Yes No NONE g ) Past performances in similar projects for governmental clients within the past three ( 3 ) years? Yes x No h) Current and near future workload with current list of projects and percentage of completion and the expected date for completion? Yes x No i ) Location of firm? Yes x Location: WINTER PARK No j ) Statement agreeing to obtain Professional Liability ( 1 , 000 , 000 ) and Comprehensive Liability ( 2 , 000 , 000 ) Insurance with the City of Ocoee named as an additional insured? Yes x No Page Two Check List - Geotechnical Services k) Disclosure of any potential conflict of interest due to any other clients, contacts, or property interests for this project only? Yes No 1 ) A notarized statement certifying that no member of the firm ownership, management , or staff has vested interest in any aspect of, or Department of the City of Ocoee? Yes x No m) Completed Public Entity Crimes Form? Yes x No n) Financial Statement? (Note: Financial Statements are not Public Information or a part of the Public Record until firms are short-listed) . Yes x No Possible Criteria Points Score 2 . Ability to provide the type and quality of services that will best meet the needs of the City: a) Does the proposal exhibit experience in: I . Subsurface groundwater mound analysis and groundwater modeling; including that related to effluent disposal? ( 0-3 ) 5 II . Subsurface investigations prior to construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 9 III . Soils testing for maximum densities and compaction for construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 8 IV. Concrete cylinder and slump testing for construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 4 V. Services related to the removal of underground storage tanks and assessments of contamination? ( 0-3 ) 4 Page Three Check List - Geotechnical Services VI . Installation and abandonment of water supply wells? ( 0-3 ) 7 b) Is the proposal specific and tailored to the City? ( 0-8 ) 20 c ) Does the firm' s experience meet or exceed the scope of services as stated on page one of the RFP? ( 0-8 ) 19 d) Does the additional data pertinent to the project regarding Firm' s capability ( item #7 of General Selection Criteria) represent added skills which could enhance this contract? ( 0-10 ) 18 3 . Quality and extent of experience with municipal governmental projects: a) Are the professional personnel assigned to work with or consult with the City experienced in the services outlined in the RFP? ( 0-10 ) 25 b) Are the project references commensurate with Ocoee ' s Scope of Services? ( 0-10 ) 23 4 . Willingness and ability to complete the project within the time and budget constraints , considering the proposer' s current and projected workload: a) Has the proposer provided concrete information indicating willingness to meet time and budget requirements? ( 0-8 ) 24 b ) Is the recent , current , and projected work under contract spelled out with provisions to add this contract? ( 0-8 ) 23 c ) Did the previous major projects completed within the last three years stay within the original budget? ( 0-10 ) 18 5 . Fiscal stability of firm: a) Based on the financial statement , does the firm appear stable? (0-10 ) 24 TOTAL 100 231 PROFESSIONAL SERVICE INDUSTRIES, INC. Jammal & Associates Division CITY OF OCOEE PROPOSAL SPECIFICATION CHECK LIST GEOTECHNICAL SERVICES AND TESTING 1 . Did the proposal include : a) Six copies? Yes x No b) The legal name, federal taxpayer identification number, address , and telephone number of the proposer? Yes x No c ) Professional qualifications of firm and specific individuals to be assigned to the project ( including resumes )? Yes x No d) The names of any anticipated subconsultants? Yes No NONE e ) Completed Standard Forms 254 and 255? Yes x No f ) Names , addresses , and previous qualifications if proposing to use specialty consultant services? Yes No NONE g ) Past performances in similar projects for governmental clients within the past three ( 3 ) years? Yes x No h) Current and near future workload with current list of projects and percentage of completion and the expected date for completion? Yes x No i ) Location of firm? Yes x Location: WINTER PARK No j ) Statement agreeing to obtain Professional Liability ( 1 , 000 ,000 ) and Comprehensive Liability ( 2 , 000 , 000 ) Insurance with the City of Ocoee named as an additional insured? Yes x No Page Two Check List - Geotechnical Services k) Disclosure of any potential conflict of interest due to any other clients , contacts, or property interests for this project only? Yes x NO CONFLICT REPORTED No 1 ) A notarized statement certifying that no member of the firm ownership, management, or staff has vested interest in any aspect of, or Department of the City of Ocoee? Yes x NO VESTED INTEREST No m) Completed Public Entity Crimes Form? Yes x No n) Financial Statement? (Note : Financial Statements are not Public Information or a part of the Public Record until firms are short-listed) . Yes x No Possible Criteria Points Score 2 . Ability to provide the type and quality of services that will best meet the needs of the City: a) Does the proposal exhibit experience in: I . Subsurface groundwater mound analysis and groundwater modeling ; including that related to effluent disposal? ( 0-3 ) 9 II . Subsurface investigations prior to construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 8 III . Soils testing for maximum densities and compaction for construction projects? ( 0-3 ) • 9 IV. Concrete cylinder and slump testing for construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 9 V. Services related to the removal of underground storage tanks and assessments of contamination? ( 0-3 ) 8 6 Page Three Check List - Geotechnical Services VI . Installation and abandonment of water supply wells? ( 0-3 ) 8 b) Is the proposal specific and tailored to the City? ( 0-8 ) 18 c ) Does the firm' s experience meet or exceed the scope of services as stated on page one of the RFP? ( 0-8 ) 19 d) Does the additional data pertinent to the project regarding Firm' s capability ( item #7 of General Selection Criteria) represent added skills which could enhance this contract? ( 0-10 ) 21 3 . Quality and extent of experience with municipal governmental projects : a) Are the professional personnel assigned to work with or consult with the City experienced in the services outlined in the RFP? ( 0-10 ) 25 b) Are the project references commensurate with Ocoee ' s Scope of Services? ( 0-10 ) 25 4 . Willingness and ability to complete the project within the time and budget constraints , considering the proposer' s current and projected workload: a) Has the proposer provided concrete information indicating willingness to meet time and budget requirements? ( 0-8 ) 20 b) Is the recent , current , and projected work under contract spelled out with provisions to add this contract? ( 0-8 ) 18 c ) Did the previous major projects completed within the last three years stay within the original budget? (0-10 ) 11 5 . Fiscal stability of firm: a) Based on the financial statement, does the firm appear stable? (0-10 ) 22 TOTAL 100 230 UNIVERSAL ENGINEERING SCIENCES CITY OF OCOEE PROPOSAL SPECIFICATION CHECK LIST GEOTECHNICAL SERVICES AND TESTING 1 . Did the proposal include: a) Six copies? Yes x No b) The legal name , federal taxpayer identification number, address , and telephone number of the proposer? Yes x No c) Professional qualifications of firm and specific individuals to be assigned to the project ( including resumes )? Yes x No d) The names of any anticipated subconsultants? Yes x No e ) Completed Standard Forms 254 and 255? Yes x No f ) Names , addresses , and previous qualifications if proposing to use specialty consultant services? Yes No g ) Past performances in similar projects for governmental clients within the past three ( 3 ) years? Yes x No h) Current and near future workload with current list of projects and percentage of completion and the expected date for completion? Yes x No i ) Location of firm? Yes x Location: ORLANDO No j ) Statement agreeing to obtain Professional Liability ( 1 , 000 , 000 ) and Comprehensive Liability ( 2 ,000 , 000 ) Insurance with the City of Ocoee named as an additional insured? Yes x ACORD MARKED EXAMPLE No Page Two Check List - Geotechnical Services k) Disclosure of any potential conflict of interest due to any other clients, contacts, or property interests for this project only? Yes x No 1 ) A notarized statement certifying that no member of the firm ownership, management, or staff has vested interest in any aspect of, or Department of the City of Ocoee? Yes x No m) Completed Public Entity Crimes Form? Yes x No n) Financial Statement? (Note: Financial Statements are not Public Information or a part of the Public Record until firms are short-listed) . Yes No DECLINED - NO SUBMITTAL Possible Criteria Points Score 2 . Ability to provide the type and quality of services that will best meet the needs of the City: a) Does the proposal exhibit experience in: I . Subsurface groundwater mound analysis and groundwater modeling ; including that related to effluent disposal? ( 0-3 ) 9 II . Subsurface investigations prior to construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 9 III . Soils testing for maximum densities and compaction for construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 8 IV. Concrete cylinder and slump testing for construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 8 V. Services related to the removal of underground storage tanks and assessments of contamination? ( 0-3 ) 7 Page Three Check List - Geotechnical Services VI . Installation and abandonment of water supply wells? ( 0-3 ) 8 b) Is the proposal specific and tailored to the City? ( 0-8 ) 22 c ) Does the firm' s experience meet or exceed the scope of services as stated on page one of the RFP? ( 0-8 ) 19 d) Does the additional data pertinent to the project regarding Firm' s capability ( item #7 of General Selection Criteria) represent added skills which could enhance this contract? ( 0-10 ) 19 3 . Quality and extent of experience with municipal governmental projects : a) Are the professional personnel assigned to work with or consult with the City experienced in the services outlined in the RFP? ( 0-10 ) 25 b) Are the project references commensurate with Ocoee' s Scope of Services? ( 0-10 ) 25 4 . Willingness and ability to complete the project within the time and budget constraints , considering the proposer' s current and projected workload: a) Has the proposer provided concrete information indicating willingness to meet time and budget requirements? ( 0-8 ) 20 b) Is the recent , current , and projected work under contract spelled out with provisions to add this contract? ( 0-8 ) 19 c ) Did the previous major projects completed within the last three years stay within the original budget? ( 0-10 ) 21 5 . Fiscal stability of firm: a) Based on the financial statement, does the firm appear stable? ( 0-10 ) 0 TOTAL 100 219 HARTMAN & ASSOCIATES, INC. CITY OF OCOEE PROPOSAL SPECIFICATION CHECK LIST GEOTECHNICAL SERVICES AND TESTING 1 . Did the proposal include: a) Six copies? Yes x No b) The legal name, federal taxpayer identification number, address, and telephone number of the proposer? Yes TAXPAYER ID MISSING No c ) Professional qualifications of firm and specific individuals to be assigned to the project ( including resumes )? Yes x No d) The names of any anticipated subconsultants? Yes No TESTING LABORATORIES ( 3 ) , NO NAMES e ) Completed Standard Forms 254 and 255? Yes x No f ) Names , addresses , and previous qualifications if proposing to use specialty consultant services? Yes No g ) Past performances in similar projects for governmental clients within the past three ( 3 ) years? Yes x No h) Current and near future workload with current list of projects and percentage of completion and the expected date for completion? Yes No PERHAPS - STAFFING SMALL i ) Location of firm? Yes x Location: ORLANDO No j ) Statement agreeing to obtain Professional Liability ( 1 , 000 , 000 ) and Comprehensive Liability ( 2 , 000 , 000 ) Insurance with the City of Ocoee named as an additional insured? Yes x No Page Two Check List - Geotechnical Services k) Disclosure of any potential conflict of interest due to any other clients, contacts , or property interests for this project only? Yes No x 1 ) A notarized statement certifying that no member of the firm ownership, management, or staff has vested interest in any aspect of, or Department of the City of Ocoee? Yes No x m) Completed Public Entity Crimes Form? Yes x No n) Financial Statement? (Note : Financial Statements are not Public Information or a part of the Public Record until firms are short-listed) . Yes No Possible Criteria Points Score 2 . Ability to provide the type and quality of services that will best meet the needs of the City: a) Does the proposal exhibit experience in: I . Subsurface groundwater mound analysis and groundwater modeling ; including that related to effluent disposal? ( 0-3 ) 6 II . Subsurface investigations prior to construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 8 III . Soils testing for maximum densities and compaction for construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 6 IV. Concrete cylinder and slump testing for construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 6 V. Services related to the removal of underground storage tanks and assessments of contamination? ( 0-3 ) 7 Page Three Check List - Geotechnical Services VI . Installation and abandonment of water supply wells? ( 0-3 ) b) Is the proposal specific and tailored to the City? ( 0-8 ) 15 c) Does the firm' s experience meet or exceed the scope of services as stated on page one of the RFP? ( 0-8 ) 12 d) Does the additional data pertinent to the project regarding Firm' s capability ( item #7 of General Selection Criteria) represent added skills which could enhance this contract? ( 0-10 ) 10 3 . Quality and extent of experience with municipal governmental projects : a) Are the professional personnel assigned to work with or consult with the City experienced in the services outlined in the RFP? ( 0-10 ) 25 b) Are the project references commensurate with Ocoee ' s Scope of Services? ( 0-10 ) 26 4 . Willingness and ability to complete the project within the time and budget constraints , considering the proposer' s current and projected workload: a) Has the proposer provided concrete information indicating willingness to meet time and budget requirements? ( 0-8 ) 13 b) Is the recent , current , and projected work under contract spelled out with provisions to add this contract? (0-8 ) 15 c ) Did the previous major projects completed within the last three years stay within the original budget? ( 0-10 ) 23 5 . Fiscal stability of firm: a) Based on the financial statement , does the firm appear stable? ( 0-10 ) 8 TOTAL 100 188 ARDAMAN & ASSOCIATES, INC. CITY OF OCOEE PROPOSAL SPECIFICATION CHECK LIST GEOTECHNICAL SERVICES AND TESTING 1 . Did the proposal include : a) Six copies? Yes x No b) The legal name , federal taxpayer identification number, address , and telephone number of the proposer? Yes x No c ) Professional qualifications of firm and specific individuals to be assigned to the project ( including resumes )? Yes x No d) The names of any anticipated subconsultants? Yes No x NONE NEEDED e ) Completed Standard Forms 254 and 255? Yes x No f ) Names, addresses , and previous qualifications if proposing to use specialty consultant services? Yes No x NONE NEEDED g ) Past performances in similar projects for governmental clients within the past three ( 3 ) years? Yes x No h) Current and near future workload with current list of projects and percentage of completion and the expected date for completion? Yes x No i ) Location of firm? Yes x Location: ORLANDO ( SOUTH ) No j ) Statement agreeing to obtain Professional Liability ( 1 , 000 , 000 ) and Comprehensive Liability ( 2 , 000 , 000 ) Insurance with the City of Ocoee named as an additional insured? Yes x No Page Two Check List - Geotechnical Services k) Disclosure of any potential conflict of interest due to any other clients, contacts , or property interests for this project only? Yes CITES ONLY AS NO VESTED INTEREST No 1 ) A notarized statement certifying that no member of the firm ownership, management , or staff has vested interest in any aspect of, or Department of the City of Ocoee? Yes x No m) Completed Public Entity Crimes Form? Yes x No n) Financial Statement? (Note : Financial Statements are not Public Information or a part of the Public Record until firms are short-listed) . Yes No x DECLINED Possible Criteria • Points Score 2 . Ability to provide the type and quality of services that will best meet the needs of the City: a) Does the proposal exhibit experience in: I . Subsurface groundwater mound analysis and groundwater modeling ; including that related to effluent disposal? ( 0-3 ) 6 II . Subsurface investigations prior to construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 8 III . Soils testing for maximum densities and compaction for construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 9 IV. Concrete cylinder and slump testing for construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 5 V. Services related to the removal of underground storage tanks and assessments of contamination? ( 0-3 ) 8 Page Three Check List - Geotechnical Services VI . Installation and abandonment of water supply wells? ( 0-3 ) 2 b) Is the proposal specific and tailored to the City? ( 0-8 ) 13 c ) Does the firm' s experience meet or exceed the scope of services as stated on page one of the RFP? ( 0-8 ) 12 d) Does the additional data pertinent to the project regarding Firm' s capability ( item #7 of General Selection Criteria) represent added skills which could enhance this contract? ( 0-10 ) 15 3 . Quality and extent of experience with municipal governmental projects : a) Are the professional personnel assigned to work with or consult with the City experienced in the services outlined in the RFP? ( 0-10 ) 18 b) Are the project references commensurate with Ocoee ' s Scope of Services? ( 0-10 ) 17 4 . Willingness and ability to complete the project within the time and budget constraints , considering the proposer' s current and projected workload: a) Has the proposer provided concrete information indicating willingness to meet time and budget requirements? ( 0-8 ) 18 b) Is the recent , current , and projected work under contract spelled out with provisions to add this contract? ( 0-8 ) 19 c ) Did the previous major projects completed within the last three years stay within the original budget? ( 0-10 ) 14 5 . Fiscal stability of firm: a ) Based on the financial statement , does the firm appear stable? ( 0-10 ) 0 TOTAL 100 164 ADVANCED TESTING LABORATORIES OF FLORIDA, INC. CITY OF OCOEE PROPOSAL SPECIFICATION CHECK LIST GEOTECHNICAL SERVICES AND TESTING 1 . Did the proposal include: a) Six copies? Yes x No b) The legal name, federal taxpayer identification number, address, and telephone number of the proposer? Yes x No c) Professional qualifications of firm and specific individuals to be assigned to the project ( including resumes)? Yes x No d) The names of any anticipated subconsultants? Yes No x NONE NEEDED e) Completed Standard Forms 254 and 255? Yes x No f ) Names, addresses, and previous qualifications if proposing to use specialty consultant services? Yes No x NONE NEEDED g) Past performances in similar projects for governmental clients within the past three ( 3 ) years? Yes x No h) Current and near future workload with current list of projects and percentage of completion and the expected date for completion? Yes x No i) Location of firm? Yes x Location: WINTER PARK No j ) Statement agreeing to obtain Professional Liability ( 1 ,000 ,000 ) and Comprehensive Liability ( 2,000 ,000 ) Insurance with the City of Ocoee named as an additional insured? Yes x General & Professional Liability,but Comprehensive No Liability not listed Page Two Check List - Geotechnical Services k) Disclosure of any potential conflict of interest due to any other clients, contacts, or property interests for this project only? Yes x WILL ABIDE BY CONTRACT IN FUTURE No 1) A notarized statement certifying that no member of the firm ownership, management, or staff has vested interest in any aspect of , or Department of the City of Ocoee? Yes x No m) Completed Public Entity Crimes Form? Yes x No n) Financial Statement? (Note : Financial Statements are not Public Information or a part of the Public Record until firms are short-listed) . Yes x No Possible Criteria Points Score 2 . Ability to provide the type and quality of services that will best meet the needs of the City: a) Does the proposal exhibit experience in: I . Subsurface groundwater mound analysis and groundwater modeling; including that related to effluent disposal? ( 0-3 ) 3 II . Subsurface investigations prior to construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 4 III . Soils testing for maximum densities and compaction for construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 7 IV. Concrete cylinder and slump testing for construction projects? ( 0-3 ) 5 V. Services related to the removal of underground storage tanks and assessments of contamination? ( 0-3 ) 0 Page Three Check List - Geotechnical Services VI . Installation and abandonment of water supply wells? (0-3 ) 0 b) Is the proposal specific and tailored to the City? ( 0-8 ) 6 c) Does the firm' s experience meet or exceed the scope of services as stated on page one of the RFP? ( 0-8 ) 10 d) Does the additional data pertinent to the project regarding Firm' s capability ( item #7 of General Selection Criteria) represent added skills which could enhance this contract? ( 0-10 ) 10 3 . Quality and extent of experience with municipal governmental projects: a) Are the professional personnel assigned to work with or consult with the City experienced in the services outlined in the RFP? (0-10 ) 13 b) Are the project references commensurate with Ocoee ' s Scope of Services? ( 0-10 ) 14 4. Willingness and ability to complete the project within the time and budget constraints , considering the proposer ' s current and projected workload: a) Has the proposer provided concrete information indicating willingness to meet time and budget requirements? ( 0-8 ) 12 b) Is the recent, current, and projected work under contract spelled out with provisions to add this contract? ( 0-8 ) 14 c) Did the previous major projects completed within the last three years stay within the original budget? ( 0-10 ) 13 5 . Fiscal stability of firm: a) Based on the financial statement, does the firm appear stable? ( 0-10 ) 15 TOTAL 100 126 m a) )-4 • 0 1 Oa) m -'1 a) -0 > �+ S1 a) 4 cD a) O -� a) Ori m u) 01 0 -0 a) ra WE M a) 0 r-1 4 4) m .-i (1) +) -0 Sa a) a) ,-1 -r1 ra -,-4 a) 0 E O k ra '0 •ri +) 3 •r1 f••r v) U) U) (a O 'o 4)0 A0 Sa 0 0 - U a) a) a) a) (Q 0 O CI X y U 0 •--i0 as >+ >+ >+ >+ _ (a Z E o?) a) 0 a) •,-i W 01 U) ca v) •r1 4) A 'o 0 4 U 1 Fa ri w a) 'o c/a • a) as o U +) >- .o w U ,--1 W 0 a) z m U) E ra ~ U O U 0 ra U) m U) >i O U) Z O o W ., 3 0 a) a) a) ki U1 a) 0 W U o a) 4, > ' z >-• >- >-I a) >4 >. Z Z 4 ,~ a°) vo - ,4 W � .� c., u) gas rzl w x � 4 4 = >4 a r-1 w 0 CO 0 -1w a rt O U 4 4 U) A 0 U 44 a) -N +) co 01 .0 --I •rl •r, -r1 4 a) 0 4 cd 4, Sr 0 U) 0 3 •1-) 3 A r-I O O1 a) O Q 4 a) )4 U) U) a) U) r•1 0 w (O U U Q, a) a) a) - en a) - O 4) O a) Z (1) •r1 0 >+ >. U) 'o >+ U) V 0 U) S-1 '3 >1 4) > >1 0 a) z a) Z ra 4 +) • 0 S., 0 Z >+ ,A >, c . U E c7 cn E ri ra V ri $•1 V a) (U U) a) • w -p q.., 0 0 > m N U O 0 •r, i-1 a) a0 •r•1 a) >� m 4 a) 0 U) U) a) 4) a) U) >C O 4) .,.1 0 U) $-, -in O a) a) +> CO >, a) a) Z .'., > a) a) 0 0 Z >-1 >-1 •'., a) >a O -r1 Q. - 4 U C7 O >a)) A Z ~ U) E VI W u) E E E0 >. -• 1 1 Q Q F, a) 0 0 x 4 a) a) I 0 I P• 1.1 •rl ri •r1 (d Fa +) E 4 '0 (a I I •r1 ca a) I b 0 U 4-4 -0 +) .0 0 •r, •r1 3 r••1 0 0 0 c•-• F, c'• i a) a) O O o ca +) +) 3 3 +) O ca •r, a) +) V a) 4-, o TJ 4- r-I >. 1 v] a) F+ Q m •r, a) 0 m E .0 0 a) (3,4-+ E 0 as 0 (4 .0 a•r1 oO 3 0 a) >a -P 3 (a a) Fa +) a) m o 0 m a) 0 4-+ cd +) 0 0 +) 0 F, •-I +) > 0 •-) F, +) +) m a 0 0 >. O O U) 0 0 m >> U) 0 0 44 O a) >. U) 0 a) k •r1 F♦ o!! b 0 E E a) b b m I a) +-) a) 4 V 0 Fa > 0 0 r-1 0 +) 'O •r+ •1-1 as E (d -r, cd o m 0 ,.0 in •- 0 a I 'U m 'O •r1 a) a) W V 0 0 .0 -4 a) 0 4 0 0 o ai CO ri I •r, 0 F, 0 b F, 4 v] a) 0 F, 0 a 0 0 F, +) c Li r-1 0 ,0 Fa 0 0 b •r, +) ad x Fa 0 0 >. a) >>'u a Q •,1 cd a) +) a .Z cd O 4t k C•• a) 0) oo 0 0 a) •r, a) Eo -o -1 3 I 4-, b +) 0'x A O a) ..0 X Q 0 4 a) ,c ca 4 a• a) 0 •rI 0 O 0 a) 0 >. a) c) c•-• O 3 'O +) +) a) 4) .1.7. a) a• +) m +) V 4 a) 4) cd 0 a) ca . r-1 'O 0 F♦ a) >. Z •r1 0 Fa +) .0 a) a) +) m ca +) —1 .0 b m +) •-1 a) cd ,4 0 +) > a) x 3 a) E +) E a) a) E m +) 0 0 r•1 x U (a 1" 0 O F, +) +) 4 O V 0 F, a) c`• Fa 0 'C F, Fa w F, m a) 0 m +) •r, m F, Fa F+ a) --I a) +) ,—•r1 0 F, 0 -0 0 a) O •-4 a) O a) ca ca •r1 :a a) ca 0000 4 3 a 3 3 .0 0 3 A -,i 4-4 3 +) 3 0' A to 4H ^Q a 3 +) 4,3 'O +) 3 3 +) 0 • a) > s~ —' E m rd +) ),I E 0 U E rVa w 4-1 �0 co a) a) -r O a) b1 QUI a) CU 1-1 0 a) A U Ul P. r 1 -'•1 Ul >4 ra rd -I 8 ad x .—I U U Z a) H A 0 - a) co 4 A a) O O -v-I I--I U U •n W s~ 3 m co )-+ U O U) a) >~ • ani z E ° a • Aa 03 I •v-I O +) 4) O O rd O U) • A -n a) a) 0 �, ul ((l x14 f~ •r 4 4 +) • a) a) 'V rd E O rrs U •4•1 +> >+ O O E O •,-i b rd • Z A 0 U -) rd a) 1 4-1 VI bl I f~ O a) U) -r1 S•1 U a) `A 0 4.4 f~ 4-I 4-4 O O O S 14-1 O ru 04 >t a) a) E 4-1 O--�. Ul +' •,4 >+ E r-I +) a) a) •^r > O E ni C.) � E U 0 U $.1 3 rd >1 + U a) v •,I a) >- A 0 al A A � U b O � 3 'ti ^Cs- (1) (1) O A a) •�I •� O U rd da da • a 0 •• • U) a) cr) ti b U •'I r1 4 a) z > O s:+ E 4 (1) O 0 crl Cr) 0 S-4 0 w Z cn v v, a) a) a v ›-1 ) U TS rd M . •'1 -PW >1 04 0 a >,a U) r-I a) ^i u] U .1-) re cr.'1 a -.-1 1-4 U) U!] "c) U v] m O a a) a a) >-. Z a $4 a, Z > > a) >-1 al u] a1 $.1 0 a) 0 rfa o C/2r-I 2 �°n x a) H W (3 rU a) W +) 1.1 o0 u] '� 4) a) U] I 0 .-i 0 W . l a) 0 -•-1 al a) a W 0 +I RS U 0 +] •r-1 a) U] U] u] v] u] 1-I 1.1 •1-1 0 0 fy a a) a) a) a) a) 0 CdE O > 1>1 >1 1-1 a �+ �+ �+ �+ �+ Z W (1) U a) a) 0 +) rU W U] U] U] 4-4 U] E W a b G; 0 a) •--I I -,1 .4.) U] it a) 44 .0 U 4-) H a) 1 a ,A 0 ITS U) U) 4-1 rU U >M rU •r1 ¢1 >., 0 at $.1 •r1 W U U) U] - a) +i U] U] X a a) > o a) a) U] v] 0 a) a) a) 4) E > $4 cn Z >i -• a) 0tri >4 > 0 • -,I E Cn v] 4-i (U 0 Z 4 2 o a I.r I ox 4-4 Sa rU I I '0 a) b a 0 ( v] • c1-4+ O O 0 b (.3 2,1 +) U] 0 Z a -r1 a U) . (U a) a) H >, cd a 0 a U] U] U) -� U] fn H a +3 -i ,O O >r 0 a) a) a) 4) a) a) ?S O ft ri L-1 U >+ as 2 >• >+ O >+ >+ +) a) Z cn OO a) 3 to 0 W +Pa ZU] H E o C.7 h cn -rI • U] A -.4 Z > u] I-I -.-1 E E a >. 0-• I I a A t-i a) 0 a .x .0 a) a) I a I P- W •,-I ,--I -'-I al la +) E 4 'tJ at I I •'-1 cd a) 1 -01 a U rn 44 a +3 0 0 -•-1 •r1 3 •-1 a a a cam• c.1 C-- la a) (1) 0 H a) 0 al +.) +) 3 3 4-) a cU •'-1 a a) 4) TJ 0 44 0 -0 +) '--I >. I > +) 0 ;•1 o U] •r.+ (1) o co E x o a) a 4a E c] of U x W 4 a•r1 ao 3 0 0 >. 4-3 3 cU a) I+ +3 a) u] 0 al u] a) a 4a cd W -,I +3 a a +3 0 la -'•1 +> > 0 •� 1.+ +) +) 0 a 0 0 UI O >. a 0 v] 0 al U U] 0 cd 4-1 0 a) >. U! O a) k •'-+ la o 'q 0 E E a) -0 'C7 U) I a) +) 0 0 17 0 Ia > al a rI a) -o •,1 a u) -r-1 cU E 0 -r1 cU 0 0 a 4 U] •,--) a a I 7) U] '0 --I a) 0 • 0 -0 0 0 X ;.1 a) 0 4 0 0 0 al cU r-1 I •.•1 0 1'•1 a ^O 1-i 4 Z d a) U 1.1 a a 0 0 Fr -P a 1-1 .—I 0 •0 I:1 0 al ^O •r1 +3 o x la 0 a) >. a) 77 a a •-i ai a) +3 a 4 al 0 H o?) i-1 o-• a) a) U10 a) >1 a a) •-1 a) E O 'o •-1 3 14H b +1 o'x Cl] 0 a) 4 x a al 4 a) 4 cd 4 c-• a) a) •.-1 a = >. 0 0) a) >. 0 U c•-- C/3 r-I 3 '0 4) 4 a) 4) ,4 a) C-. +) u] +8 -0 -004-) 00 00 0 ,-I 17 a IJ a) >. W al -r 1 a) 1-4 +) 4 a) a) - U] cd +) •.-i -0 E] +) •.-1 a) cd ,0 U W E +> > a) ,4 3 a) E +) E a) >. a) +) E Cn +3 a al - x U al O E al 0 G, +) +) .a 0 b (U a) C-• 1•d 0 17 la I~ N la U] a) 0 E) +) -r1 0 Cr Ix al X F+ W ••-4 a) +) 0 •.1 a 1-1 a) 4 a) a) a -r1 a) o a) cd cd 4 •••1 al a) cd cd 0 0 a at I-) 3 a 3 .0 0 '.1 C" 4i P0 3 0" A bnw+ 'a a 34) 4) 3TI +) 3 3 +3 0 0 U] 0 • E a) z En 4) •H 4-+ 0 W o +3 co E05 $4 0 0 a) S-4 a) E O 44000 a) U o 4a •'i U) W A X a) I 4a a) a) O cQ >4 44 fn )a r0 E A o +) 'O a) +-3 c r0 W E •H E-4 A fn a) E U 0 O+ O O >� 3 U U bt I CO • W E 4a O � A � $.4 cn a) - H O co >r 4•1 cd a) r-I +) - a) O O a) .N UO � y Co O al O H 0 b U • O c rof no 00 O 0 0 0 •- • U ;+ +P ^c1 U •,-4 ,0 a) O > E O PZ E -0 a) O 0 Ul Co U 7) +-) cn cn 0 r+ 'v F: o ao) 0 0 rt 0 CO 0 101[z4 L 3 0 it o O 0 a) a) a) c.) 0 U] •r+ 'v •-I 2 a) � 1m.,.r 4 a) 4 ra 4) co m -. .r, U) U) Sa z ,...1 0 0 0 0 0 0 a) a) U) it a) a) a) 0 F.+ O 4) •> 0+ S4 > z ›+ ›+ 4 +) >+ >+ 4 Z oa 0 $a 03 14 .N a) a) 0 o co c7cnH4-1 I 4 4) U) O Ux U 'O 41 10 +) a) $4 W W• E 0 a) � 3 0 U) I +-) its •r+ U) O g Sa W U) a) N 0 •r1 ,--1 it 'a0 'O a) r-1 U 0 a 0U al o ..-1 a o , N - U) 1 V •,i > a) >+ U) 01+> >' U) V U a) a) •r-1 •rl W ."4 E'' S.4 T3 Sa O a) a) •,.1 a) O (1) >+ w 4 0 W k A > vo) 3 aal) Z >+ Z >+ c07 X OA a r� >-, a) W O O I U Z r-1 Sa +) I a) rd O U 1-i 0 -r1 w ''n E 0 N 'a U 4a 0 U) O 0 0 N 0 a) r1 o ,.a° v U a --.p U) 0 E 0 0 0 -� E UO 0u)) E >+ m m a) E > I a) o x a) .-1 E V r1 u) co A a) 4a 0rC + ) r ) 4) O a1 US-1 U O S-r 4 •,i O a „.1 o a) a) a 4- al >> Fa 0 w -,n r-1 4) 7 a) 4 0 a) r1 0 0 a) U U) Sa 0 a) U) 0 O U) V U cn g U a o k >-, - U) >+ a) z W 3 O •r-1 .-1 W Cl] � )a 0 C0 )4 W > 3 z H CD CD '-1 at/) > 4 W cn rn E E 0 >, c.- 1 1 0 C., Fa a) 0 0 .x 4 a) (1) I 0 1 c'.• Z •- r-1 •r•1 ca F1 +-1 E ,C b ai I I •r-1 cd a) I V O 1-1 4•+ •.0 +) 0 0 •,4 •,-1 3 r-1 Z C Z 0-• - a• Fa a) a) 0 cx 0 ai +) 4) 3 3 4) O cd -- O a) +•) V a) 4•+ O -0 +) r1 7) 1 W 0 Fa 0 U) •'•1 a) 0 0 E 4 U a) a 4-+ E 0 al U W 4 a•'•1 00 3 0 0 >. +) 3 0 0 F+ 4) 0 U) 0 0 U! a) 0 4a a3 Z 4 00 +a 0 •r•1 +> > 0 • ) k 4) +' 0104 00 1-1 >, O 0 U) O 0 U) 7) U) U cd \4•+ 0 0 >, U) 0 a) k •,1 k 0 b 0EE0V V (1) 1 a) +) 0 .0 •00Fa > 0 0r-1a) +1V •� Z •-4 0E 0 -r 00 rn 0 .0 Cl) •--') 0 a I V U) V •r4 a) 0 W V 0 0 .0 Fa a) 0 +' 0 0 0 0 to r1 I •ri 0 Fa 0 'ti Fa 4 a) 0 Fa 0 a U U Fa +•1 O i--1 0 .0 0 0 -0 •i-+ +-) a x Fa 00 >, a) >, O a 0 •i-+ 0 0) +) a .. 00 d Fa a• a) a) b0 a) 7) 0 a) •r•1 a) E 0 V r1 3 1 44 V V V3 o a) _z 4 0 0 4 a) 4 0 4 c-• a) 0) •'•1 0 0 >, 0 a) a) >> a) U a• a' 3 V +) 41 a) +•) 4 0 c•-• +) U) +) V 4 a) +3 0 0 a) al 4 r-1 V o Fa a) >> W •.-I a) Fa +) 4 a) a) +3 U) ai 4-) •r•i b U) +3 •r4 a) CC, x U > +-) > a) 4 3 (1) E -' E a) 7) a) +4 E U) +) 0 al '•-1 x cu ca N 0 O Fa 4) +) 4 0 V 0 F-1 a) 0-- I~ 0 'O Fa c. Fa F♦ U) a) 0 U) 4) --4 U) F+ s, Z 4 F.+ a) •'4 a) +) 4 •-1 0F♦ 0) 4 a) a) z '-1 a) 0 a) os ai --1 os a) ai as O O 3 04 3 3 .0 0 3 01 •,-Iw 3 4) 4 3 01 Q o04-1 V a 3 +) +•) 3 '0 +) 3 3 ;) U rnCO 44 • c. E o o I l.•I ( I .,.r z 3 w >4 ni U o 1=1+ O 0 U " >+ b ta >14+ N • to.a +) 1`I U a rc o >~ woos� 0 • - a) w 4a� a) rt a) 0 > W f~ ,C) I d 4x o -i +) 9 rd .A b1 TJ 0 0 rd U) a) •4-+ O rl a W O 4) •- a) ri 4 4 3 cG E Z7 nO •rl +� 4.) rd •rl U) 0 ri • CD 4-) a) +3 = rd v rd a) a3 O O a rC •,i re; 34 • ,Z U a) $.1 Irl E v0 --i •rl 04 0 O -r•r a) - >C W f~ -rr E••1 rd U a) 4-4 a 0 a) )4 ae �•, O 0 - U E 4-4 O '0 •r+ r>s U 01 a) U) O O •rr 4a 0 a) a) a) >4a) a) +3 O 1-1 131 O -0A 4r•I 4-1 a.1 4-1 +) r0 a) • U a) %•r U 111 f-1 rd f~ •-1 4-4 > W41:1000 U O O rd O O )4 x 4-1 Cl]a O a 0 a) - � �+ W ° 00 +� a) 4.3 0 ••4 (TS a) �1 U A a) 131 •-1 Sa >4 3 c7 W )44 E a) O 9 .ti 4-4U O O U) , ^a• 0 O a) •'- •rl • cd toto O al 0 •• • U) a) m a) s4 +) b U •rr •-1 4 a) E O• f•+ E a) O 0 C U) U