Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem V (A) Resolution No. 93-13, vacating a Drainage Ditch Easement at Florida Auto Auction AGENDA 9-21-93 Item V A "CENTER OF GOOD LIVING-PRIDE OF WEST ORANGE" MAYOR•COMMISSIONER Ocoee S.SCOTT VANDERGRIFT 51) CITY OF OCOEESSIONERS RUSTYJOHNSON �. 150 N.LAKESHORE DRIVE PAUL W.FOSTER v O OCOEE,FLORIDA 34761 VERN COMBS (407)656-2322 SAM WOODSON yrOE� 0 V>>` CITY MANAGER P G00 ELLIS SHAPIRO SRP-401 REVISED STAFF REPORT TO: The Honorable Mayor and Board of City Commissioners✓ i FROM: Bruce C. Behrens, Director of Planning DATE: September 21, 1993 RE: APPLICATION TO VACATE DRAINAGE DITCH EASEMENT AT THE FLORIDA AUTO AUCTION ISSUE: Should the Honorable Mayor and Board of City Commissioners approve the application by the Florida Auto Auction to vacate a drainage ditch easement and adopt Resolution No. 93-13? BACKGROUND: The Florida Auto Auction has petitioned to vacate a 2 , 187 . 81 ' drainage easement , that runs south from the Courthouse Annex 632 . 03 ' and then turns east for 1 , 555 . 78 ' , as per DeYoung sketch of description dated May 22 , 1992 , located in case file. DISCUSSION: The procedure set forth in Section 153-10 of the City Code has been complied with and the application and attachments have been reviewed for sufficiency. Six requests for comment were mailed to the following agencies , with five responses , as follows : 1 . Orange County Engineering Dept . , Sami Saad, has no objection to the vacation application. 2 . City of Ocoee Building and Zoning Official , Don Flippen, does not object to the vacation application. 3 . P .E.C. , Tom Kelley, does not object to the vacation application. 4 . Jim Shira, City Engineer, does not object to the vacation application. Staff Report September 21 , 1993 Page 2 5 . Ray Brenner, Public Works Director , does not object to the vacation application. 6 . No objections were received from the Roper Partnership, an adjacent property owner . The Director of Planning has determined that the proposed vacation would be consistent with the City' s Comprehensive Plan. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Honorable Mayor and Board of City Commissioners approve the application by Florida Auto Auction to vacate the drainage ditch easement and adopt the attached Resolution No. 93-13 . BCB/emk cc : Curtis DeYoung, Florida Auto Auction u0'21,03 00:43 1T407 dos 1743 FOLE1 & L.AKUlMt,l{ RESOLUTION NO. 93-13 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF OCOSE, FLon=DA ABANDONING AND VACATING A PORTION OF THE CERTAIN DRAINAGE DITCH EASEMENT AS SET PORTE IN THE DITCE EASEMENT AGREEMENT 8E'i'wW ROPER BROS., INC. AND THE CITY OP OCOBE, DATED JULY 2, 1975, AND RECORDED IN OP$ICIAL RECORDS BOOK 2652, PAGES 643 TO 645, INCLUSIVE, OF TSL PUBLIC RECORDS OP ORANGE COQ, FLORIDA, AS !MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN A SKETCH OP DESCRIPTION OF EASEMENT VACATION PREPARED BY i =YOUNG ENGINEERS, INC., DATED NAY 22, 1992; PROVIDING FOA RECORDATION; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING EN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Ocoee desires to abandon and vacate a portion of a certain drainage ditch easement as set forth in the Ditch Easement Agreement between Roper Bros. , Inc. and the City of Ocoee, dated July 2, 1975, and recorded in Official Records Book 2652, Pages 643 to 645, inclusive, of the Public Records of Orange County, Florida, as more particularly described in a Sketch of Description of -Easement Vacation prepared by DeYoung Engineers, Inc. , dated May 22, 1992, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "An and by this reference made a part h(reof (the "Easement") in order to allow' for the relocation of the Easement and connection to adjacent parcels; and SEAS, pursuant to Article II of Chapter 153 of the Code of the City of Ocoee, an application has been filed by Florida Auto Auction of Orlando, Inc. (the "Applicant") to abandon and vacate the Easement; and waSREB5, the Applicant has complied with the provisions of Section 153-10 regarding the provision of certain information in connection with the application; and fir . _.L,,: =:. uv 2i,.» 1111:43 =4J7 a-t, 1-1.0L1.1 & ,.atw[IEE 4UU3/O0U 1 lW![EB, the Applicant owns simple fee title to the land upon which the Easement is located and the Easement is within the corporate limits of the City of Ocoee; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 153-13(D) (1) of the Code of the City of Ocoee notice of the public hearing before the City Commission was provided by regular mail to owners of real property abutting the Easement and all owners of property within three . hundred (300) feet in all directions of the Easement; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 153-13(D) (2) of the Code of the City of Ocoee a Notice of Public Hearings was published one (1) time in a newspaper of general circulation in the City of Ocoee; and WHEREAS, pursuant .to Section 153-13(D) (3) of the Code of the City of Ocoee, a sign setting forth notice of the public hearing before the City Commission was posted upon the land upon which the Easement is located; and WHEREAS, no person or persons have appeared in opposition to the granting of such application; and WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Ocoee finds that said application and supporting documents are in accordance with the requirements of Article II of Chapter 153 of the Code of the City of ocoee and that the requested action is not inconsistent with the City of Ocoee's Comprehensive Plan; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY TSE CITY COMMISSION OP THE CITY OP OCOEE, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOMB: 2NWT ' . 09/21/93 11:49 $407 648 1743 FOLEY & LARD\ER Ia 002/002 SECTION ONE. Authority. The City Commission of the City of Ocoee has the authority to adopt this Resolution pursuant to Article VIII of the Constitution of the State of Florida and Chapter 166, Florida Statutes. SECTION TWO. Abandonment and Vacation of Drainage Ditch Easement. The city Commission of the City of Ocoee, Florida, hereby abandons and vacates a portion of a certain drainage ditch easement as set forth in the Ditch Easement Agreement between Roper Bros. , Inc. and the City of Ocoee, dated July 2, 1975, and recorded ini Official Records Book 2652, Pages 643 to 645, inclusive, of the Public Records of Orange County, Florida, as more particularly described in a Sketch of Description of Easement vacation prepared by ,DeYoung Engineers, Inc. , dated May 22, 1992, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and by this reference made a part hereof (the "Easement") and renounces any rights to the Easement. SECTION THREE. Recordation. A certified copy of this Resolution shall be filed with the Orange County Comptroller and 1 duly recorded among the Public Records of Orange County, Florida. SECTION FOUR. Severability. If any section, subsection, sentence, clause, phrase or portion of this Ordinance is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portion hereto. SECTION FIVE. Effective Date. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon passage and adoption. 3 � C `_2i u0/21/93 09:44 /2407 64S 1743 FOLEY & LARDNER 4005/0013 PASSED AND ADOPTED this day of , 1993. APPROVED: ATTEST: CITY OF OCOEE, FLORIDA Jean Grafton, City Clerk S. Scott Vandergrift, Mayor (SEAL) 1 FOR USE AND RACE ONLY EY _THS CITY OF OCOEE, FLORIDA APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGALITY • this day of , 1993. FOLEY & LARDNER By: City Attorney •m vpsmocev .aa elle ast a.ios 4 ut). 1,'J3 av 45 =4U7 fd4 1743 kW-El & LA1WNER 4.1)116/001i UUti EXH1gf' "A • Seaton /! . Tates* Ag , X r aao' �Q?=wingl 723.44' %,- • Pained I Career aer.r-.e taeatloa Tee Ny Ila CIA. look-3672. Ihr 1•Irem the Northwest eoeer at tie let .t eertekikef tlweat a - ae r of lrleai 11, Tedt� !! 3e44. Afaye 21 bet, ore ese tiesetr. Marla % traverse • Serb WW2/6 11441 .i, sg the 'weed Alm .r sate esciesuee -w+etr et the 1.aolssot a.s,eleet r sod Illi.Omsk eeeteellse i>r' `1 .lb.mot; �.a .lt) fret; mane ands�'�'2T' omit. *mai rest fm Um awe tt��me Ilion/ilia lortb.eet eea6marter et the leothre.t Q t... Lb ,4'12'2!' seat, 70.i$ t,.tXia . �. I.99llsuee Meese • 1 .Z44beth p'W27" gest. leetyl 4 Nam* Uwe, 11.01 (.sI those,* Qeelk ot`Irtir teat, Mail h.ti gems, h Neett< $153'14 lust, j..211.71 beet' themes i II; earth UV'Or bet, 242.i1 test: 'horse k Scutt Ql'el'II'�.1f lert le ti.. 'wort 11.. 1 , the tlrrtlsast ' r of the P.it s141 soetheest eee'911ester of 'sense 1!. Tasman' 1* spry, santetl • Zees': themes A1.tb•Wlz'7o' Iles:Ila.OWI,.24'49 Cott t. tlwt seathoutt oar.reral aat ib t!t4401 IMI Imerier tot 1ewthoost q.ortst et the aforgoo1d tasserk slawwese bases the soeth.ee7et termer �22 ,aferewebt 433 . tkitll esompostie et swum 11, toweable ss d011C3a s it game 11 k� Sootk 111-23 l6' Meat. alewd tot foe Lies a! tot afesMaid Nbetbaao= ana-ler ,,• of Lbs Q.etJwe.t rao- 1411 ' lee'Nf of deetlea U, Tessuefelp U bo.t#i. knoll Gast. ' I g _14112.22 teas to tte•/amtelest come of the Northeast - I• IC Seetlm D. 1wujp ZZ 'of go t Mrpear2$ of the said ua Perth 44'3''7!"' ire 28 Usti neem. :3=11t7,11:7' tb.eei eeo-gayrrera.si tlb! s1tirart t Ilue 1`'ee••ay , afeteeehl �1 ` S.W fist !e ew lbtlf 0[ $5 kart, i a01�11 e.o.3aa �.aQ� '7t_t �1 vi (ci: —Ps eoir aw' 1 1,' ; th• ;:+-. ' 4 sVaIM121,27 ~SW IS,II 4i • \\ \ N\N . Aolflii, AIM; Nea `' AINIVAR As•' 11111, ,i442: fo,rowt, on �r-Asx-st Amer •mow►@, 4Cdu..4.41.111 111 I 'hbf cerli(T Mot, lo tta bumf of mule 1 latoododya ood Wel IIIA AGM, 45446090.401 JedtewatroVrAe reprewlted hire= meets the lelquk'aieu$s NAA anOrpev.,I e1 CleeOter 21 leb-e, Ptertdv roNee 123'_1 4P•4111111' • Code. EMWNERRSeVUNG e S 10e absffi image,ew answer,MOM 741121CURTfS J. 71G '1111• AVOW Mtr ' Registered Load Seaealar onr , ,,, .1(414 J . f.,� � 1 Medd* Number 2373 . Areaumo ,Wawa. ,71'171-7 ll:44H`1.'r- AGENDA 9-21-93 "CENTER OF GOOD LIVING-PRIDE OF WEST ORANGE" Item V A OcoeeJ.,T.V L L •A..VL:L\VL\11' '`iy °_ CITY OF OCOEEN RUSTY JOHNSON 150 N.LAKESHORE DRIVE PAUL W.FOSTER OCOEE,FLORIDA 34761 VERN COMBS I 0 (407)656-2322 SAM WOODSON yrE'P Or Gov � CITY MANAGER ELLIS SHAPIRO SRP-401 STAFF REPORT TO: The Honorable Mayor and Board of City Commissioners FROM: Bruce C. Behrens, Director of Planning t`v DATE: September 16, 1993 RE: APPLICATION TO VACATE DRAINAGE DITCH EASEMENT AT THE FLORIDA AUTO AUCTION ISSUE: Should the Honorable Mayor and Board of City Commissioners approve the application by the Florida Auto Auction to vacate a drainage ditch easement and adopt Resolution No. 93-13? BACKGROUND: The Florida Auto Auction has petitioned to vacate a 2 , 270 ' drainage easement , that runs south from the Courthouse Annex 646 ' and then turns east for 1 , 624' . DISCUSSION: The procedure set forth in Section 153-10 of the City Code has been complied with and the application and attachments have been reviewed for sufficiency. Six requests for comment were mailed to the following agencies, with five responses , as follows : 1 . Orange County Engineering Dept . , Sami Saad, has no objection to the vacation application. 2 . City of Ocoee Building and Zoning Official , Don Flippen, does not object to the vacation application. 3 . P.E.C. , Tom Kelley, does not object to the vacation application. 4 . Jim Shira, City Engineer, does not object to the vacation application. OIL tS Staff Report September 15 , 1993 Page 2 5 . Ray Brenner, Public Works Director, does not object to the vacation application. 6 . No objections were received from the Roper Partnership, an adjacent property owner . The Director of Planning has determined that the proposed vacation would be consistent with the City' s Comprehensive Plan. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Honorable Mayor and Board of City Commissioners approve the application by Florida Auto Auction to vacate the drainage ditch easement and adopt the attached Resolution No . 93-13 . BCB/emk cc: Curtis DeYoung, Florida Auto Auction u9/16/93 16;39 t2407 648 1743 FOLEY & L.1RDNER 4/3002/(108 RESOLUTION NO. 93- 13 A RESOLUTION OF TER CITY OF OCOEE, FLORIDA ABANDONING AVD VACATIWG TEAT CERTAIN DRAINAGE DITCH EASE' AS SET FORTE IN TSE DITCH EASEMENT AGREEMENT BETIMES' ROPER BROS., INC. AND THE CITY OF OCOEE, DATED JULY 2, 1975, AND RECORDED IN CFFICIaL RECORDS BOOR 2652, PAGES ' 643 TO 645, INCLUSIVE, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF ORANGE COUNTY, FLORIDA; PROVIDING FOR RECORDATION; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDIAA AN EFFECTIVE DATE. 'HERBAL the City Commission of the City of Ocoee desires to abandon and vacate that certain drainage ditch easement as set forth in the Ditch Easement Agreement between Roper Bros. , Inc. and tile City of Ocoee, dated July 2, 1975, and recorded in Official Records Book 2652, Pages 643 to 645, inclusive, of the Public Records of Orange County, Florida, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and by this reference made a part hereof (the "Easement") in order to allow for the relocation of the Easement and connection to adjacent parcels; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Article II of Chapter 153 of the Code of the City of Ocoee, an application has been filed by Florida Auto Auction of Orlando, Inca (the "Applicant") to abandon and vacate the Easement; and WHEREAS, the Applicant has complied with the provisions Of Section 253-10 regarding the provision of certain information in connection with the application; and WHEREAS, the Applicant owns simple fee title to the land upon which the Easement is located and the Easement is within the corporate limits of the City of Ocoee; and I 09/18/93 18:59 '$407 848 1743 FOLEY & LARDNER Q003/008 WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 153-13 (D) (1) of the Code of the City of Ocoee notice of the public hearing before the City Commission vas provided by regular mail to owners of real property abutting the Easement and all owners of property within three hundred (300) feet in all directions of the Easement; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 153-13 (D) (2) of the Code of the City of Ocoee a Notice of Public Hearings was published one (1) time in a newspaper of general circulation in the City of Ocoee; arid WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 153-13 (D) (3) of the Code of the City of Ocoee, a sign setting forth notice of the public hearing before the City Commission was posted upon the land upon which the Easement is located; and WHEREAS, no person or persons have appeared, in opposition to the granting of such application; and WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Ocoee finds that said application and supporting documents are in accordance . with the requirements of Article II of Chapter 153 of the Code of the City of Ocoee and that the requested action is not inconsistent with the City of Ocoee's Comprehensive Plan; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF OCOEE, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS: SECTION ONE. Authority. The City Commission of the City of Ocoee has the authority to adopt this Resolution pursuant to Article VIII of the constitution of the State of Florida and Chapter 166, Florida Statutes. 2 0:3/18/4)3 17:Ju '$407 643 1743 FOLEY & LARDNER -U114/008 SECTION TWO. Abandonment and Vacation of Drainage Ditch Easement. The City Commission of the City of Ocoee, Florida, hereby abandons and vacates the Easement as set forth in the Ditch Easement Agreement between Roper Bros. , Inc. and the City of Ocoee, dated July 2, 1975, and recorded in Official Records Book 2652, Pages 643 to 645, inclusive, of the Public Records of Orange County, Florida, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A" arid by this reference made a part hereof and renounces any rights to the Easement. SECTION TBRSE. Recordation. A certified copy of this Resolution shall be filed with the Orange County Comptroller and duly recorded among the Public Records of Orange County, Florida. SECTION FOUR. Severability. If any section, subsection, sentence, clause, phrase or portion of this Ordinance is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portion hereto. SECTION FIVE. Effective Pate. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon passage and adoption. 1 3 09;'16;93 17:00 12407 648 1743 1-70 LEY c L RDNER OU5/008 PASSED AND ADOPTED this day of , 1993. APPROVED: ATTEST: CITY OF OCOEE, FLORIDA Jean Grafton, City Clerk S. Scott Vandergrift, Mayor (SEAL) PCR USE AND RELIANCE ONLY EY TES CITY OF OCOEE, PLOBIDA APPROVED AS TO PORN AND LEGALITY this day of , 1993. FOLEY i LARDEER By. City Attorney cmmiramcmmummarmaimpimmlummo 4 09/16/93 17:00 33907 648 174 FOLEY & LARDNER 4006/108 ��•. - — EXHIBIT "A" — j 93 "`f Oa 13 3 sa 11115 U. rt 643 r of FwserMCr mare 1 TRIS &tom entered into this Zme, day of Jug"` k 1975, by and beth mom MOS., INC., a Florida corpacati,on, bereineltar referred to as "First Pasty" and CITY OF QCOEE, a t o Placid& Municipal corporation, hereinafter referred to as "Second Party". ' I I SAS, Fist Psi is the comer in fee simple of that ' .3°. portion of Lend more fully described on Schedule i which is attached hereto and made a part hereof lying westerly of Marshall Farms Road, Orange County. Florida. and 1 r, «£ E'S, am said land is a 70 foot drainage easement co 20 be teed es such for themtual benefit of the parties hereto in 21 perpetuity or until entualiy canceled by the parties hereto. NOW TBEREFORE, in consideration Of the mutual promisee made one to the other and other valuable caasidaretion6, it is , agreed: . I 1. That the parries hereto shall each have a mutual use including Ingress and egress avec, yes and upon that `y certain70 foot drainage easaaeet more fully described aft% nd set e out send =irked Schedule A which is attached hereto end made a ' part hereof In perpetuity or until mutual cancellation hereof. 2. That . i Parry of the Second Part hereby accepts said ` easement and future maintenance thereon. i f ! I ; ; '.nn WITNESS ifCF. me have heresmro set our hands and i • `3 ails,, fib:day and 200th and year above actioned. °x, .:•. ,141S I ;1!"-)•-•."_ ' 4• Z. ROPyJ S., IHCep Firs t Party 107 1M„ ik. �' r ....r: ' • r^... /s'Lr- (Seal) I Sem t , CTrf OF OCOEE, Seco d Party ATTEST: r -- —.... (SEAL) r. City Clerk 09/16/93 17:01 /2407 848 1743 FuLEY Y LARDNER 41007/008 I11:rSUM OF ?tank PI .., ia. a 64Co' ir': OF 0ZI x. 57 "X that on this day ha:o-.a at. spao:.icar a�J1y gwli`.:ad to talo s,.knleZyssoes. pzxsamll7 aPPea.-rd -f?.a••ff. a.e re — ax:d — A�F. CI•__= ..Fs__- , rresidane and Sec�etaery taspsc- • lively of Mar= an1S., L4C.. a Florid. , sa ioo. to as ham,to hse tS.. pexsana drserSbad 3a a 4 vbo a=ecuted the fo ag LvTM" 't and actuwledSed b.F6:a no that they eaea ed tae secce. 1. r xsgr band a off.-:fico as&11, i . r�.e c',o�ty end ;';3ear. . et aeot.aaid sbis 2d day of . 197_x. , P ; ' h -Cor aiL esptzeso - OF 11=Itla: - CaQRrY C7 MANCE: I ME= CzitrL't that on this day tan re aa. and e=five= daly qualified Co take teknowloftmcatos para4aa117 apgaas�daid _ c '.tales and city Clock ee pas- f Healy .f :*ae C17": r2F OCDE . a F10xtda 25raLcipa] entper'atloa.. ro ne known to be the p emcee described 3n god wbe executed _ the r.:antooins :aitr teat e34 40l12orledged be re x that racy azee art the mime. , , - Y Ti*?''SS Z7y bead and o=f!-c.ial ;cal in =Bo County and 5-ace :•:a: zcr.mxid Chid da, of -Nee• 1°75. i :etari !wain :'I7 Co�.ssioa LapL-es: ' - 2 - 09/10/93 17:01 407 048 1743 FOLEYARDNER 008/008 :'"`eSi& X1 Schedule "A" rl Ll." 2652 tC 645 • neacr±ptiaa for a 70 foot drainage casement: ?run the 8W corner of the BE 114 of the SW 114 of Section 19, Townehip 22 South. Range 28 East, avenge County. 71or2da son thence f 88' 12' 27" E along the North line of said RE 1)4 of the SW 1/4 and the centerline of Story Road 19.90C feet; thence S 00' 19' 22" E. 30.00 fest for a p.c.b; said p.o.>b. beiug a pOSIt ora eke voutherl right of ver line of aforesaid Scary Rood- rot thence S 00£19' 22" E. 605.00 feet: thanes 8 88' 12' 27" V, 198.00 feet to the vast line of aforesaid NE 1/4 of the SW 1/4; rum theme* S 00'. 19' 22" 3i algin said Veer line E 702.06 fast to the SW coewer of the 1/4 of the e SW 1/4 of said Section 19, rim thence B 80' 53' 14"E slang the south Lite of said NE 1/4 of the SW 1/4 a distance of 1313.25 feet to the SE corner of said NE 1/4 of the SW 1/4, said corner also being the SW corner of the BW 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of said Section 19. run thanes B 88' 52' 30" E aloes the south line of maid NW 1/4 of the SE 1/4 a distaaen of 264.00; thence S 46' 06' 00" E 524_07 ftj thence N 88. 52' 90" S 878.82 feet to a point in a County Drainage Viten; rust thews. 8 41. 50' 31" E along said ditch and parallel to the easterl ri tmarshal].of say ofmarshal].Farts Road. 95.66 feet: rsenoe S 8• 2' 30" V 91:.17D feet to a point en the aforesaid easterly tight of way lire of Marshall Farces Road; run thence 8 46' 0d' 00" If 524.07; thence S 88' 32' 30" sr 292.51 feet. thence S 88' 53' ib" Si 124:.78 feet thence N 00' 19' 22" V 562.86 feet: thence N 88' 12' 27" E 188.00 feet; thence N 00' 19' 22" W 675.02 feat e4 the afore- • said southerly right of way line of Story Road; rue thence S 88' 12' 27" V along, said southerly right of w line 70.02 feet to the point of begLnniag; containing 7.1450 acres pore or less_ Ji.�CSphEriT .r �51..YF�t: i SU MA.= 'f"uf'tie4tileut•.• r' i as F-0111 A r = r;, lezi T: =•?r.� �. U L. v C t hi s. 7�tIPr11 fit\ [Ea a 5 5 1Si 7 gam 7.1 • r 1 VERIFIED RECDRgED i IBM • 93r+4 Ct.raear4 ara4de i