Loading...
07-16-2019 Minutes MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING JULY 16,2019 CALL TO ORDER- 6:15 PM Mayor Johnson called the regular session to order at 6:15 PM in the Commission Chambers of City Hall. The invocation was led by Commission Firstner followed by the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag led by Commissioner Brinson. City Clerk Sibbitt called the roll and declared a quorum present. Present: Commissioner Brinson, Commissioner Wilsen, Mayor Johnson, Commissioner Firstner, Commissioner Oliver Also Present: City Manager Frank, City Attorney Cookson, City Clerk Sibbitt PRESENTATIONS AND PROCLAMATIONS - 6:17 I'M Legislative Update - State Representative Geraldine Thompson, District #44 gave a session overview which covered major themes, house bills, and funding that was presented before legislation. STAFF REPORTS AND AGENDA REVIEW - None COMMISSIONERS ANNOUNCEMENTS - 6:39 PM Commissioner Oliver—None Commissioner Firstner—None Commissioner Wilsen — Shared the importance of Home Rule and thanked Representative Thompson for being an advocate. Commissioner Brinson—None Mayor Johnson— 1) Announced the Teen Police Academy is scheduled for July 29 - August 2, 2019, from 9:00 AM -1:00 PM at High Point Church which is located at 476 Ocoee Commerce Parkway, and open to teens age 13-18. For more information, please contact Ofc. Jason Strange at (407) 905-3160 ext. 3024. 2) Announced Storytime with Cookies & Milk with a Cop is being held every Friday at 10:30 AM, until July 26th, at the West Oaks Branch & Genealogy Center at 1821 E. Silver Star Road. 3) Announced the Planning and Zoning Commission currently has a vacant seat with a term expiring June 2020, and staff would like to present a staff report for board appointment for the August 6th City Commission Meeting. Staff have requested the elected officials to please provide up to two (2)names along with contact information to the Office of the City Clerk by Friday, July 26th, in time for the August 6th agenda packet. Once their office has received the selected member(s) name and contact information, they will then reach out to those individuals so they may fill out a board application. The board applications received will be Regular City Commission Meeting July 16, 2019 included with the staff report as this will help assess the member's based on their experience and qualifications. CONSENT AGENDA- 6:42 PM Consent Agenda Motion Motion: Move to adopt the Consent Agenda Items #1 - #11 with Items #3, #4, and #8 being pulled for discussion and separate consideration. Moved by Commissioner Firstner, seconded by Commissioner Wilsen; Motion carried 5-0. 1. Approval of the Minutes for the Regular Commission Meeting held June 18, 2019. (City Clerk Sibbitt) Approved on Consent. Motion carried 5-0. 2. Approval of New Appointment to the Parks & Recreation Advisory Board. (City Clerk Sibbitt) Members of the Parks & Recreation Advisory Board serve two-year terms. The Ordinance provides that the Parks&Recreation Advisory Board shall consist of nine(9)members;and,whenever possible,appointments to the Board may include one member from each of the following organizations: Ocoee Little League,Ocoee Youth Soccer League (OYSL), Ocoee Bulldog Pop Warner Football, and West Orange Senior Citizens Association. Currently, the board has four (4) members. One (1) application has been received by Michael Stewart who has shown an interest in being appointed to the Parks &Recreation Advisory Board for a term ending October 2020. Approved on Consent. Motion carried 5-0. 3. Approval of Contract with ZHA, Inc., for RFQ #19-007 Owner's Representative Services for the New Ocoee City Hall. (Assistant City Manager Shadrix) The City advertised RFQ#19-007 Owner's Representative Services to solicit statements of qualifications from firms or individuals interested in providing professional construction management services for the New Ocoee City Hall. On June 18, 2019, ZHA, Inc. was awarded RFQ#19-007 by City Commission to provide such services and authorized City Staff to proceed with contract negotiations and obtain a fee proposal from ZHA, Inc. The Utilities Department reached out to ZHA, Inc. to negotiate a contract. The Contract includes the attached scope of services and covers the design and construction phases of the project. Some of the services included are: design review and comparison cost estimates at 30,60,and 90 percent plans to verify contractor costs and confirm budgeting, a Construction Inspector during construction, and a part-time Project Manager for the duration of the project. The Owner's Representative will also be assisting with the City's Direct Purchase Program and move coordination. The City will be providing office space for the Project Manager at the Utilities Administration Building during the project. The flat fee for these services is$365,000 plus up to $3,150 in reimbursable. The contract also provides for a building envelope consultant and a commissioning consultant for an additional fee at the City's discretion. Commissioner Oliver asked for clarification on this item as he has concerns with the Owner's Representative that the City is seeking to hire. He was further interested in how bids were received. Assistant City Manager Shadrix explained that the item before them is to hire 2IPage Regular City Commission Meeting July 16, 2019 professional construction management services which is something that staff had intended to do all along. He advised that ten (10) solicitations were received, and staff short-listed it down to three (3) with the committee choosing one to bring forward. He shared there will be more processes coming before them at a future meeting that includes the design construction of City Hall. He further reassured the Commission that City staff did not change any of the processes that could put the City in any risk as the City Attorney has been working with them through this process. Assistant City Manager Shadrix gave further explanation on the modification of the design team which the primary contractor has the right to do with the City's consent. Commissioner Oliver inquired if funds were budgeted for this particular contract since this was anticipated all along. Assistant City Manager Shadrix answered in the affirmative, but gave further explanation on the bond funding. Commissioner Oliver shared his concerns regarding the service fee amount. Mayor Johnson commented that providing professional construction management services benefits the City as it allows staff to not run into any problems during construction as there will be a construction manager overseeing the project. He further shared that tax dollars are not being used for the construction of the New City Hall as the City has bonded $44 million for the downtown project which allows for no tax increase to the citizens during this project. Commissioner Wilsen shared that she is also looking out for her residents, but is aware of the conditions of the current City Hall building which is sinking. She would like to see a new City Hall that will last longer than 20 years and is built correctly so residents will not be paying to maintain it years from now. Commissioner Brinson inquired if there is any City staff that has the skill set to provide the functions of an Owner Representative. Assistant City Manager Shadrix answered there is not. Commissioner Brinson further inquired if the fee service they are approving this evening for the Owner Representative is comparable to what the scope is for that type of work. Assistant City Manager Shadrix answered in the affirmative, and advised the incentive of the hired Owner Representative is to get the best possible building constructed at the best possible price. Commissioner Firstner shared he did not have any further comments to add, and agrees that there should be a professional overseeing a project this large. Commissioner Wilsen, seconded by Commissioner Firstner, moved to approve Item #3 - Contract with ZHA, Inc., for RFQ #19-007 Owner's Representative Services for the New Ocoee City Hall. Motion carried 4-1 with Commissioner Oliver opposing. 4. Approval to Set the Proposed Tentative Millage Rate for Fiscal Year 2019/2020 Budget. (City Manager Frank) The TRIM act requires local governing bodies to set a proposed tentative millage rate annually during the month of July. The property appraiser is then notified of the rate and uses it to advise taxpayers of their proposed tax levies for the next year. The rate can be lowered during the budget hearings in September and has historically been done so by the City. State Statutes establish levels of approval by the governing body in setting the millage rate. The statutes provide for a maximum millage that can be levied by the governing body with a majority vote. This maximum millage rate for the upcoming fiscal year,7.0119, is an increase over the 3IPage Regular City Commission Meeting July 16,2019 current year millage(5.5000). The rolled-back rate for 2019/2020 is 5.1551.This rate is lower than the current year rate. The City's overall assessed value increased by$363,430,110. This is an increase of$1,949,586 at the current millage rate of 5.5000. The Commission can set the proposed millage for FY 2019/2020 up to 7.7131 with a supermajority vote by the Commission. This millage rate would generate $22,369,702 in ad valorem revenues.A millage rate higher than the 7.7131 would require a unanimous vote by the Commission. Commissioner Brinson inquired about the millage rate and if it is comparable to surrounding municipalities of the same size. Mayor Johnson shared that the millage differs in every City because it is based on their budget process. City Manager Frank explained that historically the City Commission would set the millage rate higher so there would be leeway when they worked on the budget. The high millage rate is then published on the TRIM bill which causes the elected officials to receive many complaints. City staff has met to discuss what flexibility is going to be needed this year and thought that 5.75 mills is closer to what they are hoping to bring the millage rate to. Mayor Johnson commented that the last three years they have lowered the tax base which benefits the citizens and allows the City to manage with the budget they need. Commissioner Wilsen, seconded by Commissioner Oliver, moved to approve Item #4 - Set the Proposed Tentative Millage Rate for Fiscal Year 2019/2020 Budget. E• Motion carried 5-0. 5. Approval to Set Workshop and Public Hearing Dates for Fiscal Year 2019/2020 Budget Process. (Finance Director Roberts) Workshops are held during August for staff and the commission to discuss the proposed budget for the upcoming fiscal year. Public hearings are required by the TRIM Act in September serving as a mechanism to notify the citizens of the proposed budget and allow the opportunity for their comments. The TRIM Act has specific timeframes for scheduling and holding the required hearings. The hearing dates cannot conflict with Orange County (9/5 and 9/19) or Orange County School Board (7/30 and 9/10) hearing dates. Staff recommends the commission approve the following dates for the August budget workshops: August 8th and 14th. Staff recommends the city commission approve the following dates for the September budget hearings: September 11th and 25th. Workshops and hearings will begin at 6:00 p.m. Approved on Consent. Motion carried 5-0. 6. Approval to Piggyback off Orange County Public Schools' Contract for Installation of a Chain Link Fence with All-Right Fence Services, Inc. (Parks and Recreation Director Johnson) As part of improvements for Vignetti Park,the Parks and Recreation Department is proposing to upgrade and replace the existing fence for the softball fields. Staff is requesting permission to piggyback off the Orange County Public Schools Contract#ITB 1502028 for these services.All-Rite Fence Services,Inc.,has submitted a proposal to supply and install the fence in accordance to the plans, with unit pricing, in the amount of $26,342.40 per field, based upon the aforementioned contract. The Parks and Recreation Department will replace the fencing on two(2)fields for a total of$52,684.80. Approved on Consent. Motion carried 5-0. 7. Approval for Crossing Guard Services with All City Management Services. (Police Chief Brown) The City of Ocoee Police Department's current crossing guard contract with All City Management Services ended on June 30,2019.The Police Department is seeking to renew the contract for an additional three years. The contract would begin on or about August 1, 2019, and end on June 30, 2022. The estimated cost of this 4IPage Regular City Commission Meeting July 16,2019 contract during the first year(2019-2020) will be $19.50 per hour, per crossing guard, and is a fully loaded rate to include recruitment, background clearance, training, equipment, insurance, supervision, and management. The Police Department would continue to designate a liaison between the Police Department and All City Management Services to address any future crossing guard needs. Approved on Consent. Motion carried 5-0. 8. Approval of Resolution and State Highway Lighting,Maintenance and Compensation Agreement. (Public Works Director Krug) This agreement provides for funding from the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) to the City to help defray the costs of street light operation and maintenance on several State highways within Ocoee's corporate limits. The work order under this Agreement will provide Ocoee with an annual payment of $39,595.82 for the 2019-2020 fiscal year, which represents a 3% increase over the current FDOT lighting supplement. Public Works recommends approving the new work order under the State Highway Lighting, Maintenance, and Compensation Agreement with the FDOT. Commissioner Brinson inquired about the 3% increase over the current FDOT lighting supplement. Public Works Director Krug explained the increase is a stipend to help defer the cost of the actual street lighting. He advised that some years it will increase, and some years it F, will decrease, depending on what the State government is offering. Commissioner Oliver, seconded by Commissioner Brinson, moved to approve Item #8 - Resolution and State Highway Lighting, Maintenance and Compensation Agreement. Motion carried 5-0. 9. Approval of Lakefront Park Phase 3 Conceptual Design and Master Plan Update with S&ME,Inc. (Public Works Director Krug) The Commission awarded the design of the Lakefront Park to S&ME in June of 2017. S&ME developed the park master plan with construction to be implemented in phases. Phase 1 is currently under construction providing site and parking improvements to support the Maguire House and expanded Lakeshore Center. Phase 2 is the block incorporating the location of the new City Hall. Phase 3 incorporates the northern stormwater canal and the lakefront. Public Works is requesting approval to move forward with the portion of Phase 3 which incorporates modifying the stormwater canal area into a linear park feature connecting Lakeshore Drive with the proposed Master Stormwater Park west of Bluford. The first task in Phase 3 is to create a conceptual design and update the Lakefront Park Master Plan. The $18,700.00 negotiated for these services fall within industry standards and is adequately funded in the Stormwater Division Capital Improvement funds. Public Works recommends the award of the work to S&ME. Approved on Consent. Motion carried 5-0. 10. Approval of Capital Program Management with FBG, Inc. (Public Works Director Krug) The Commission has embarked upon an aggressive capital improvement program implementing the Downtown Master Plan. Public Works recently experienced changes in personnel and has determined the most proactive way to maintain the momentum of the current workload of the program is to utilize the assistance of a consultant on a short term basis. When Public Works recognized the potential for the workload to temporarily overwhelm the new staff members, several firms were approached for their availability to provide an individual who can act as an extension of the Public Works Team for an eight(8) month period. Public Works is requesting approval to utilize the services of FBG Engineers&Consulting, Inc. (FBG), one of the firms which recently submitted on the City Hall Owners Representative solicitation. Public Works is requesting Commission waive the process to advertise for another owner's representative as the scope of 5IPage { Regular City Commission Meeting July 16,2019 { services required on the projects in the Capital Improvement Program are equivalent to the scope for the City Hall Owner's Representative RFQ on which FBG submitted. Based on the similarity of scope,Public Works recommends waiving the bid process and secure the services of FBG for assistance with management of the City's capital improvement program. This work is adequately funded within the Public Works Department. { Approved on Consent. Motion carried 5-0. 11. Approval for the Replacement of Oxidation Ditch Rotors. (Utilities Director Smith) The Utility maintenance program has scheduled replacement of three Oxidation Ditch Rotors. Ocoee's Wastewater Treatment Facility (WWTF) processes wastewater using a Bio-Denitro process. This process, through a phasing system,supplies and denies oxygen to influent wastewater to produce treatment.Mechanical aerators (rotors) are a critical piece of equipment in this process. The current rotors have been in place approximately 27 years and are at the end of their expected lifecycle. Staff has experienced intermittent break- downs of individual components on the four rotors over the last few years. Recently one rotor completely failed. The rotor needs to be replaced as expeditiously as possible along with the other two rotors that are scheduled for replacement.One of the four units was replaced in late 2017 using a non-Kruger product so the City could test performance, which results did not match the performance of the Kruger equipment. Due to the critical nature and cost of the equipment involved, Staff has continued to explore options for replacement and received three quotes from different providers. Utilities had Reiss Engineering assess each option. After reviewing the options and Reiss'recommendation,Staff is recommending staying with the Kruger system and replacing the gearbox with the US made NORD gearbox. This was the most cost effective of the three option and requires the least amount of time for delivery and installation.Veolia(dba Kruger)is the sole supplier of NORD gearboxes and the original designer of the City of Ocoee's WWTF.The quote of$208,074.55 includes replacement of the motor,gearbox,end and drive bearings and installation. Approved on Consent. Motion carried 5-0. PUBLIC HEARING - None FIRST READING OF ORDINANCES— None SECOND READING OF ORDINANCES—PUBLIC HEARINGS - 7:13 PM 12. Second Reading of Ordinance for Orange County Public Schools - Substantial Amendment to the Ocoee Crown Point Planned Unit Development(PUD); Project No: RZ-19-05-05. (Advertised in the West Orange Times on Thursday, July 4, 2019.) (Zoning Manager Gajadhar) This project was initiated as a joint venture between the City of Ocoee and Orange County Public Schools. Prior to purchasing the 360-acre property, a feasibility study was conducted to ascertain the development potential of the property and to identify the best mix of future uses to benefit both parties. On September 15, 2015,the Ocoee Crown Point PUD was amended to change the land use of Tract 3 from park to residential, and the maximum number of single-family dwelling units from 264 to 333. OCPS currently owns several tracts within the PUD, including those that consist of the existing Ocoee High School, and a proposed elementary school.Several of the other tracts owned by OCPS are intended to be used for workforce education. The specific tract modifications being proposed for this use in the amendment are as follows:Change the land use of Tract 13 and 41 from bus depot/townhome and stormwater drainage to workforce education/townhomes; change the land use of Tract 7A and 7B from workforce education to workforce education/townhomes;change the land use of Tract 34 from right-of-way to workforce education/townhomes. Zoning Manager Gajadhar presented a brief PowerPoint on this proposed substantial F amendment to the Ocoee Crown Point PUD Land Use Plan (LUP) for multiple tracts owned by 6IPage 4 Regular City Commission Meeting July 16, 2019 Orange County Public Schools. This PUD is approximately 360 acres which is located on the northwest side of the city and was a joint venture approved in 2003 between OCPS and the City. Currently, the PUD consists of the Ocoee High School and a proposed elementary school as well as the Preserve at Crown Point subdivision. The specific parcel within this PUD to be amended consists of 37.46 acres, five tracts (5), and is currently vacant. It is located to the northwest of Fullers Cross Road and SR 429, west of Ocoee Apopka Road and south of the West Orange Trail. The proposed five (5)tracts to be modified are Tracts 13 and 41 from bus depot/townhome and stormwater drainage to workforce education/townhome; Tracts 7A and 7B from workforce education to workforce education/townhome, and Tract 34 from right-of-way to workforce education/townhome. The Development Review Committee and Planning & Zoning voted unanimously to recommend approval of the Orange County Public Schools (OCPS) Amendment to the Ocoee Crown Point PUD. Staff also recommends approval. Chris Wilson, Applicant representing OCPS, Marchena and Graham, P.A., 976 Lake Baldwin Lane, Orlando, thanked the Board for their time and introduced the following individuals associated with this project that were present for questions: OCPS Sr. Director of Planning & Design Faz Ali; OCPS Planner Jamie Boerger; Rick Baldocchi, P.E. with AVCON, Inc. Mr. Wilson presented the proposed substantial amendment to change certain land uses to workforce/townhome. In reviewing the Declaration of Conditions they have found some amendments that are required to be consistent with the proposed changes of the bus depot/townhome to workforce education/townhome; therefore, a Fourth Amendment to the Declaration of Conditions is needed. Rick Baldocchi, P.E.,AVCON, Inc., 5555 E. Michigan Street, Suite 200, Orlando, highlighted two major modifications. One modification was the access off of Ocoee Apopka Road, and the other one was the pond, which will be incorporated into the larger parcel. Mr. Wilson provided information on the type of workforce education that would be provided as those were the concerns voiced at the Planning&Zoning Commission. He advised while students can come from any area of the county, they are expecting that most will come from the western portion of the county. He further mentioned the educational facility will be constructed for about 500 students. Mr. Baldocchi discussed the trip generation data, which was gathered from a nearby bus depot and a technical college. That data showed a future reduction in the number of trips for the proposed project. Mr.Wilson concluded by stating OCPS concurs with staffs recommendation. He mentioned the City and OCPS have had a great working relationship on past projects with the high schoolas well as the future elementary school and this future technical school. He said they are available for any questions. City Attorney Cookson explained that there will be two separate items to approve as part of this staff report; the first is the Substantial Amendment to the Land Use Plan and Preliminary 7jPage Regular City Commission Meeting July 16,2019 Subdivision and the second would be the Fourth Amendment to the Declaration of Conditions of Approval for Ocoee Crown Point PUD. He further read the title of the ordinance. The public hearing was opened. As no one wished to speak, the public hearing was closed. Commissioner Brinson inquired if the facility would utilize High School students. Mr. Wilson answered that it would include both high school and post high school students. Faz Ali, OCPS Sr. Director of Planning&Design, confirmed it would be a combination of both high school and post high school students. He further explained the high school has a more structured schedule where everyone comes and goes at the same time; whereas, a technical school has classes throughout the day and into the night. Commissioner Oliver inquired about the trip counts and if there would be an incline or decline in trips due to the buses. Mr. Baldocchi advised that the bus trips are being deleted as the bus depot is being eliminated. Motion: Move to adopt Ordinance No. 2019-024, Orange County Public Schools - Substantial Amendment to the Ocoee Crown Point Planned Unit Development (PUD); Project No: RZ-19-05-05; Moved by Commissioner Brinson, seconded by Commissioner Wilsen; Motion carried unanimously. Motion: Move to approve Fourth Amendment to Declaration of Conditions of Approval for Ocoee Crown Point PUD; Moved by Commissioner Brinson, seconded by Commissioner Wilsen; Motion carried unanimously. REGULAR AGENDA - None STAFF ACTION ITEMS - None COMMENTS FROM CITIZENS/PUBLIC - 7:02 PM (Heard out of Agenda order.) Donna Deitrick and Brent Deitrick, 2625 Cedar Bluff Lane, family members of the former Mayor Vandergrift, came before the Commission requesting to have a park or building named after him. Donna Deitrick highlighted many of his accomplishments of the former Mayor over the course of his twenty-five years of service. Together, Donna and Brent Deitrick shared many loving memories of Mayor Scott's interaction with the residents, expressing his deep love not only for the City, but the residents as well. Donna Deitrick conveyed a deep desire to have Central Park renamed in her father's honor. Mayor Johnson replied in favor of honoring Mayor Scott's memory and shared that he believed Central Park would be the appropriate choice, given his involvement with the Little League. Commissioner Oliver shared a few of his memories with the former Mayor and also agreed that it would be a great gesture. Consensus of the City Commission was to allow staff to move forward with renaming Central Park after former Mayor Scott Vandergrift. Wage Regular City Commission Meeting July 16,2019 COMMENTS FROM COMMISSIONERS - 7:29 PM Commissioner Brinson— 1) Shared that he has received many calls regarding an alley that leads to Spring Lake Elementary School, and explained the condition as unacceptable,with overgrown weeds and debris. He expressed deep concern knowing that children use this path. City Manager Frank asked Commissioner Brinson to meet with him to address the problem. Sgt. Iannuzzi explained two years ago the police chaplains addressed the concerns along this alley with the Blue Jay Way Project. She shared that just before a new school year, the Police Department organizes a community event to clean up the alley for the children. She further added that this project is very near and dear to their hearts and it is a great community outreach event because they return on the first day of school to greet the students and hand out items such as pencils. She ended by announcing they will be out again this year. 2) Relayed concerns from residents regarding a leaning tree on Ingram Road, and shared that multiple residents fear the tree falling during the next storm. Public Works Director Krug acknowledged that Ingram Road is within the City's jurisdiction and that the tree is located in the right of way. He further explained that the tree has a power line going through it, and shared that staff has reached out to Duke Energy for assistance on this matter.3)Requested insight on the fountain at Crown Point. Public Works Director Krug explained that the City has ordered a new fountain, and will address the electrical issue. Once completed, the new homeowners' association will take over maintenance of the pond. Commissioner Wilsen — 1) Requested an open house for residents, once the Lakeshore Center renovations are complete to showcase the downtown projects and inform residents of the current status. Parks and Recreation Director Johnson shared that his Staff is currently working on a wedding expo which residents will be invited to attend. Assistant City Manager Shadrix added that he is in discussions with Staff regarding a public open house alongside the CRA to showcase a downtown update. They are currently trying to narrow down an appropriate date. Commissioner Firstner — Asked for an update on the Ocoee Youth Council. Commissioner Oliver shared that there is a presentation planned for the next Commission meeting, on August 6th by Coordinator Dorcus Dillard. Mayor Johnson requested copies of the applications to be sent to the Commission for review. Commissioner Oliver — Humbly apologized to Mayor Johnson for cutting him off during a previous meeting held on June 4th. Mayor Johnson respectfully accepted his apology. Mayor Johnson—1)Inquired about the lighting on Ingram Road. Public Works Director Krug explained that with tonight's approval of a temporary project manager, his department will be able to address many issues that have been unresolved, including not only Ingram Road but Maguire Road as well. 2) Noted that along Ocoee-Apopka Road, many County sidewalks are overgrown making them difficult to use. Public Works Director Krug stated he would contact Orange County and request maintenance along those sidewalks. 3) Shared that the Lakeshore 9IPage Regular City Commission Meeting July 16, 2019 Center is nearing completion, and they are currently working on the new wedding venue near the Maguire House and that the grass should be installed later this week. 4) Thanked staff for their hard work on the many projects around town. 5) Confirmed budget meeting dates: August 8th and 14th are the workshop dates, and September 11th and 25th are the hearing dates. He then directed staff to place the dates on Ocoee TV broadcast. 6)Reminded the Commission that names for the new Planning and Zoning appointment are due to the City Clerk's office no later than July 26th. ADJOURNMENT— 7:42 I'M APPROVED: Attest: City of Ocoee 4 16/1)---- , 1 . mss•.. elanie Sibbitt, City Clerk Rusty John%i n, ayor 10IPage •