06-05-2017 Agenda - Public Hearing VN_9 4 1'
ocoee
/tondo
DISTRICTING COMMISSION
PUBLIC HEARING
Commission Chambers
150 N. Lakeshore Dr.
Ocoee, FL 34761
REVISED
June 5,2017 AGENDA 6:30 p.m.
I. Call to Order
1. Pledge of Allegiance and Moment of Silence
2. Roll Call and Determination of Quorum
II. Old Business
1. Presentation on Legal Restrictions Governing Redistricting—
Dana Crosby-Collier, City Attorney
2. Presentation on Data Related to the Maps and GIS Methodology—
Mike O'Halloran, City of Ocoee GIS Analyst
3. Presentation on Board Plans 1 & 2 and Proposed Board Plan 3 —
Chairman Keethler
III. Public Hearing
1. Public Comments for Board Plans 1 & 2 and Proposed Board Plan 3
(See Attached Maps)
(Each speaker must fill out a speaker form and present it to the Recording
Secretary prior to speaking. Speakers shall be limited to 5 minutes per
speaker/per meeting.)
2. Discussion of Public Input
IV. Motion to Present the Districting Commission Recommendation to the City
Commission
V. Adjournment
ONE OR MORE CITY COMMISSIONERS MAY BE PRESENT AT THIS MEETING.
PLEASE NOTE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH FLORIDA STATUTES 286.0105: ANY PERSON WHO DESIRES TO APPEAL
ANY DECISION AT THIS MEETING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS AND FOR THIS PURPOSE MAY
NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE WHICH INCLUDES THE
TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS BASED.
ALSO,IN ACCORDANCE WITH FLORIDA STATUTE 286.26:PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES NEEDING ASSISTANCE TO
PARTICIPATE IN ANY OF THESE PROCEEDINGS SHOULD CONTACT THE OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK, 150 N.
LAKESHORE DRIVE,OCOEE,FL 34761,(407)905-3105 48 HOURS IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING.
Board Plan 1
Population Figures Based on Modifying 2010 Census Data to March 1, 2017
Sources:2010 United States Census Bureau and City of Ocoee
1 yy�� '' 'ii _Th
t, '�f`�l Distract: 4
a \ Population 10091
_ :P1-'''''''Se' t"'"....,viz -On. Deviation from Ideal: -79
District: 1 r �> .- �I� '.a� { ' t `, i4 Percent Deviation: -0.78%
Population. 10214 I 1 '. ,
—L r -' it!'
71
ation from Ideal 44 ...,.'.--(337.4,-,-rt '� y
Percent Deviation 0.43% r, f, �j 111:10I_
:, t c,/ tat i �
LAKE I .,..,,,
•
� b t�
„„..:„ .-..,....., •
�� t=s t
4 _ A / (..iw,-' I. 1 �'�'j,. tram r` ? r
,Fi
i I. ti
i WI
_ •—/♦w;..4 -_ M m ,�. CAKE u11 —
p. r 7 �' L 1K. I , ! , ilm,� tlgT �V t i -
w/ r /sem lit _ _ �� I'.il_
.iii 111F •cTh
� A. r i
iii ■. i ,r 'F 704isi • I�r "
1JTE{ I I� , gm ■Mom It 1 2.. .0..■ saewG r_/ _�- 11.11 UtrE�i
I MOXtf � � ultF ".,:ii
____.
II , — 1_] = I --—
9 rw 1 a `A� = r �--°tom -, k ` ,r ._/`r n -
lUS
70rR 1111 i IM tl�� ^.y'.r• -; ScaRRE _ i .1`-!. 4"!'',.!.' r
�`m Y
` District: 3 ,- C-=- -''.rarn
Til- -�! _ ,,,,4'*'..''`
f: 'Po ulation: 10559 .--- /
'. Deviation from Ideal: 389 .a, Distract: 2
,.Percent Deviation:3.82% ,"i r. 11 _ "I'" Population: 9816 l
;� .,r t __'. -Deviation from Ideal: -354 ��'
• �.,;� .-r u --. Percent Deviation: -3.48% et''
, 1 I d ' -41111 • . -2--11 ' ''-' ...... ..,..-,..,,i70
�1 ( - 4. `
zikiljv
""A t" 4�1UI\1 i )J '� ..- 1''... - i conA �_ ----i.
1. I ..-__40;,,',',11104.�n -_- ,r - t ._ lit
MNIII—iiii in-" �`■ 1 r�� `` — ,� alttl�'�� -_. g +3 n { , ,te a'
r��il - " -°t '` (�-az '� -r Ir. �� ,-W--' ,-kms
y 7!
L1.1� ;ow , f ii, 'tI( - — . \t,,t\ Y. a�J,,,,,,-(1,,,i,• Existing Commission Districts;
1
< \ a -.tiY La. I -
` / /■. r t i),1,,_=..„ 1111 n� - : '.... _Existing Commission
eL '__ s..--
- ..off d aY .j}_l Tr District Boundaries
1 n• FJ R7 .p x' %1 r .—_—_Parcels
LL.:.., , r . '� f N'v t r_- ..1a 111 r •`e. 1\\\ <\ City Limits
w a' ,r:A - •-I a� Unincorporated Territory
e tie � �T�u .1P441111.It I.
and corpo ratedMunicipalitiesry
��,0 I-'d 'M� u T ,:.-4..0.60,40/.,,,..:,.�- tLakes and Water Bodies
0 750 1.500 7.000 ; ,�N ' _. ."11 \ 1.p itS ..r
Q Feet! J� C 1( o., L y�S /•\�S . /J_ --r'T UVCa.d.u.rm 2011
IDEAL ACTUAL DEVIATION
DISTRICT POPULATION POPULATION FROM IDEAL % DEVIATION
1 10170 10214 44 0.43
2 10170 9816 -354 -3.48
3 10170 10559 389 3.82
4 10170 10091 -79 -0.78
40680 40680
Board Plan 2
Population Figures Based on Modifying 2010 Census Data to March 1, 2017
Sources:2010 United States Census Bureau and City of Ocoee
'T -" 12S;
I
- 1 _ 1 611-'1`k
1.,`, �,_ ,U-� '• District' 4 .
--.---1-
� "`4. �` Population: 10091
,,' ~( ceou Deviation from Ideal: -79 '
District. ' .-,•' 1 't,"..'E Percent Deviation: -0.78% go
Population: 10214 IL l r , " - - 10A.>i, 1
Deviation from Ideal 44 ',II' •rtl, , — -1- 11 I ,__L,-- r
Percent Deviation 043/ k it ,� E� i yM -- trAgilli
ii ill;P
2
III 1 i tIV';, 111,
\Ilh /t, I.. ..E S
/ 4AA _r` Y jam �.uM
Wail a ,End .�• � —o .^
„er,f41,„:':.!IMM,, al:'
� / .I.,. nhit i
g! �.sm
�.,tem! _
�/ems , if'"-net
i 8 II =J ` " rr �J T
. =,----,-„:,-,,,.„ -, , •,m. b ,=_-_.-Li la i--7 Irl
gm i. , l
4` I_ �, "� �_ ami,� >� � Eta:
71
f---711.:-r•-2.10.‘
-> 1la' --.... I •- sUKE -- I I, _,I; I `�- 7J - , �\
District 3 _ - rswu ...
sf I --rr 1
Population: 10240 7 ---T! _
z Deviation from Ideal 70 I. e�I 1� `� __ 135
PopulatDistrict'ion.
2 l
=ti`* ` �.! from1Ido .41
K� Percent Deviation:0.69% - t' ' - 1 r Deviation Ideal: -35
a__
i N ' I ="-" I Percent Deviation- -0.34% !!!".1.541
�T i r7
r-I II� �� lWW
1�IHLt!: - 1 ,,,,,_
■ �i1�t
����I X11¢ < .• i-
i i r `ISI, 1 — )J l-.a ions 7, `1
yrmi rIaJ I�'t� /, It
MT trom l lit r''''.4'.1-'----- -."7--
Y,z ,. _. ,• til—. F-
I
111111111Man• kik..., _....,i...:......Ti, :____..„..
. 1.....nive. . ,,,,,,atti.,. .:44 ___I- J, ifis.L.,
,,, :: , . ...
-... 0-41,40004...:., "..''',,..:.ct_...0.4,. 7.3_,.,...1...•_ _____•.•„..41,,.. .,„„,,e,r.
, • , ., .....„4„:,,rous„iiii, .4,iiii.l.il_...,, ,I.L ir,irra--„,„...,,,,..A .-.,,..
PACIMMEMIlityl - _ ,..01,- :'''''''''''''- - •••••'
UIe-_`,.i 7 '�I-f – — . . _ Existing Commission Drstncts.
,," , ting C
�'a{Il:i '•IU :) ,C s.anlliiu G=ti 1
Niliii
�/; _� , . � En.r1 r��N �� 3
�aalallr 70 ' I _ i 4
_ Existing Commission
'•�3// ' �•b 1Tt7-7,k--..;-4-,..,.:.„ -,.. _ --- '.1 i 'Ili b r '`1 —District Boundaries
� �i A -' -." 1 1i!■ \li rA �, Parcels
JnM...ii �w ,i'„ I fpf, r f —a W4.i, City Limes
rj1 •"..,,. J- ' _np, la _ /`6 Unincorporated Territory
42) •�II' Nub
une -4 e11N1� and Other Municipalities
1 � �,..,
y' `.ra 1°:, � y %�--- Lakes and Water Bodies
0 750 1500 3,000 1 1 ,,. ...... . �, �y'Ines• r/11 N, r.-
y ' 2 _. IJDJMea 5 edr 2017
O Feet 3J_r�-~i — ,:YL`" . . a,, ��..rn,E .7:5,--.-'__
IDEAL ACTUAL DEVIATION
DISTRICT POPULATION POPULATION FROM IDEAL % DEVIATION
1 10170 10214 44 0.43
2 10170 10135 -35 -0.34
3 10170 10240 70 0.69
4 10170 10091 -79 -0.78
40680 40680
Board Plan 3
Population Figures Based on Modifying 2010 Census Data to March 1, 2017
Sources 2010 United States Census Bureau and City of Ocoee
...:ISTITfi.OH UN.11 r ... 1
rL.F.If
-004012 h.:Pr;a7-111 Illatillaill =11-7-11.1 11!112.1g
-
...Ti- ;,7, WrpflaillIER:751. Ei 1 i.....k) ,,,-., ;....... t ,,i7,-..-_' District: 4 Ora
4r T-. 7141110411 ' IL
IIiIPopulation: 10091
,.. . .:::24:.r.ti) ,4,612-76:
Deviation from Ideal: -79 2 I
_ tiVieffili I.'•..-IA .51 lel. 1 i Percent Deviation:-0.78% 9 -
District 1 Jr .. •..................f_L-71T' i
Population: 10214 /.11, li. igi,iiI,EtE:e 1 , NEM 11141ffii „,---..----- --- -- /Val •
Deviation from Ideal. 44Wk.I.,,;:ntilprjer7--. IP:1454...1111
Percent Deviation: 0.43% ii.:76:::::MTWili.if NM 1, sags
,.,;..•:•::V iii:iiillii 'A.2i; ,
„,„,A;ti_t-,„,."1041‘11111-'— 17 • .,ii L\, ‘---L-1-. I 1
,............
-Evil-=i9
%•-iit..ttilwit!,,,,-,...1,-4 , i--
.
, ........ .,,..11,..• •L.• a F.:dtv. .!....,=...1.-. "EMU
f4PlitfLayibmi,i,--40., M.6.......w ..1Liz,,
El'IFloRPAImililluji'Vaal, a-g%'!ang.I':Iigiffligr. illigi'. •' - ..,:liirii:7,.• 7......
ALVT1r4loa-7,41E lbr IVA 4.11122,!=tItTicIIIImigheZilli ' 5:F.: I II I'M
;-t ;•F7 11 .;,11/1F. 111PIA IllE":=7itMr1:Zalligt, •'4 ..:'•:'":.: L"-- L---i I nu
'---ii-• ,-risini EL-.Li.....;,:18,...,,i„,„ ,.N;;;;;1„:„....:.,---,-;,-----r .1 1 mit ===
Hill •pg.ggli ..-pigi:Ii ... iNuita miL,,,,,,,....A!mti.fatioso,%,INtrku - -- -,i_J . AI IMF-Nil
3 peeve
M-
:-.... -_-,_,.,,,,,,J.„,,,,,,„,..,.4,,, 7S -- ' 47/
..0..”"'7,3111 ilf IR. rig., 7---,,-.1,4p,,,ipsiRcLA:.(itt.:,.,:,. r- . i ,i .
ff.,
z,, . -A. - IE.—wi :-_-.-•=40;. . ...11,
SPRING L),/r-----' liF F-17/
talltreik Mall: I
MAL . m=.. .-..ir- IMSTIM-4.;,,07,4-.....t A — LAKE
im mar7,_,,,,._-. f E /,......
a = , r.,..,... .‘: . ' ........
tw;rugq..7r...Mar. E.
- 4 -1 1--- 1
igitimi 4-410=0_11 _-2.-- •-•---' - I - 1... .._-..2.-.1
-s-
pgililiiIIIIM
:AU 1 alpil WWI i
14 .j- I ) 1 Frat"„
AP.---vs-7-m--,- 11A-4141,,,,..{.--
: - grui....• 0 :..._ ,..22,k4,=_T,
; 4 District: 3
...../46
irr
il ,' -a y. --Alin\
.,.''."... Population: 10240 _,J „-1 STARKE ,.;.. ...,
LAKE • I .._) ( I .0!"-logit-14
....,AfKE , .....„Za-----'-' , 0 4
ir ,OLYMPIA s,VI— ,-- - DilE-1 fr)
---c-'--',Lit,?\ -. __] District 2 0.••:N
,r1t. li*...
.1117.1,1 Deviation from Ideal: 70 ' '' ikl. 1,.1— . '<r ,- Tilltigi l'El
------1—Population: 10135
' ' im ilini
'rr[. Percent Deviation:0.69% I ,' -- tORNIE
. -Deviation from Ideal' -35 We.h.E;A"<44A•fi
-.--- 14. 111..
II '
........._
1111IA 11/ ,,4 I Ng ,7_ , 2,21 IST ...II 1 AEI..4,..- ____J;;E•,:al...It
It 1 . I I
iiirinviirtnialip . 1HH .0 1 •
... i ,... ., ,,„,r . . ___ ___ .L.,..1,. ,
I 1 •-=j. wa„,,,,:,„EV En
AEME 'L. Mai ii
Nammliill:
E=lion. : i•----iiiii*E:e.::::w...-..._. 1
gime=ra 'A I _
•
inumiummunit
„..." ,.. BENNE :
1Ia.7,7 GI t. ,
,411 .
, , . - ,___
111' 1k ',., i' LOAKETTA ...—"I• —I-
..,.. E__ ,_
' rt.' --1,---
uwwiriiiiI1111111q.lik— i—ah
/.2:1101.=1.11, 7);
1172"411 MIPI___,Mielli.X‘a-- gl,_ , ' /;01 1.1.1-i'l, l'is 4---- :I ha '
7,, ,.. -----.L- ,-„-• -.--,-----_- ------11 ea iip.g.n Egs:°..- ',•.--7.- lir
111- Nb ------- ,,i; 77,. -_,,,mil
in... ...R.......„ -.--
lir. - lo ,r. - - .
. 11 /2- ' z' z+74,75 FN.,,_-_-_v;iiitp riEiks, ity.igslax.13.1,
Atm.-1,01 ,111
ger
101.7 - - ---71--------, ,, . . .* ,3":
' ' ..,,..." --...--"-' / . . Existing Commission Districts:
j7...e..:-- '-"_f A- L • l..j11v , , r ,
r1H11::?11.:triT..i.. I:::::vit.t. ,, _,,,,,( . .---1, __,,,.Iiir____ s,, /Icl<.;:r11=1.4.4m mu
air- /
" •.-r-i ( ,_ , righ, .L I, .4
./ ' ---''''-1 '' ' '''' -7'• 'N11`4 [MEI i .3
Ilk ,
.1...-4•E...=,:-.-amiv ., -, --„,..---_-.. • .
Lf
M--' 7-LJ1111h-,-."vv. v." a.''
ii"M.Tta_ireir•-4:7...-,.. II , :',11:1111 -- ' Existing Commission
M.F. ,pa- _,orprOarillipp"'.5—M''',,,';';';177,FH'''''''.F-L,..,.._,' -7 j--(-?15.1.•--7,:lik•••77-4-1,.;4",::-
ill'' —District Boundaries
FE lop dir.,-Aimn, ,—,rd.., dmiraga..::t„ ____.1•••=rf gal imi- .r,\. ,.,F.1, Parcels
r-- wilosiak ; ,..\..74
Egre,,,,,,z-9,,, ki_-_
0
'1'f'• 111 FIC LAKE VIIL.'''':417ft!4-- Li 4 IlpIrIU WHE.
1111111r.,;" --- 41.4 . . ---I ..‘44<,•vx.rti mot !so city Limits
Unincorporated Territory
and Other Municipalities
Lakes and Water Bodies
i kJ, .-- ',.....t.e...1.-_-- ig 2 _th...._012..%„FE ......... Updated June 2017
. m..
0 750 1,500 3,000 111111114311 tig VdruzZ1 k 'fg.Aiaild'Esii leg 1
'Fee`ril — git:: kw WA11.10.1.-E'SrA,?!..a= .---,i.A- :L_ 1_8
IDEAL ACTUAL DEVIATION
DISTRICT POPULATION POPULATION FROM IDEAL °A) DEVIATION
1 10170 10214 44 0.43
2 10170 10135 -35 -0.34
3 10170 10240 70 0.69
4 10170 10091 -79 -0.78
40680 40680