Item #18 First Reading of Ordinance and Public Hearing Amending the Land Development Code (LDC) Relating to Article II Definitions, Article V, Section 5-8 Prohibited Uses and Table 5-1 Permitted Use Regulations in Overlay Districts ()CO?e
florida
AGENDA ITEM COVER SHEET
Meeting Date: November 7, 2017
Item # /f
Reviewed By:
Contact Name: Mike Rumer, City Planner Department Director:
Contact Number: 407-905-3157 City Manager: Ad/g *
Subject: First Reading of an Ordinance Amending the Land Development Code Article II
Definitions, Section 5-8 Prohibited Uses and Table 5-1 Permitted Use Regulations for certain
uses in Overlay Districts.
Background Summary:
Back on September 6, 2015, City staff made a presentation to the City Commission relating to the
development and redevelopment of parcels within the Special Overlay Areas. Topics of specific
concern to staff and the City Commission is the redevelopment of parcels within the Overlay Areas,
density and compatibility concerns with development and redevelopment, allowable uses in the
overlay, and the development of zoning standards that will enhance economic development and
redevelopment in the Overlay Areas with the following uses or intended uses: pharmaceutical
dispensaries, fast food and other drive through restaurant establishments, check cashing stores, self-
storage facilities, vehicle and tire service, sales, and repair facilities, and discount retail stores.
A moratorium was put in place through March of 2017, to allow staff the time to evaluate the current
Special Overlay Area standards and update the standards as necessary. Since the moratorium has
expired, the City has adopted a zoning overlay over the SR 429 Corridor by establishing three (3)
character areas and has a final ordinance on the agenda to prohibit medical marijuana dispensing
facilities.
As a final step in addressing the concerns stated in the moratorium, staff has proposed
amendments to the Land Development Code (LDC) which addresses uses and provides for
additional requirements in overlay areas (CRA Target Areas, SR 429 Overlay, and Downtown
Overlay) for the following uses: Fast Food Restaurants with Drive-through, Self-Storage Facilities,
and Automotive Tire and Repair facilities.
Issue:
Should the Honorable Mayor and City Commission approve an ordinance amending the Land
Development Code Article II Definitions, Section 5-8 Prohibited Uses and Table 5-1 Permitted Use
Regulations for certain uses in Overlay Districts?
Discussion:
With regards to Exhibit A, staff is proposing to better define self-storage facilities and prohibit the
use unless it is integrated as part of a multi-use development.
With regards to Exhibit B, staff is proposing to eliminate the drive-in restaurants like a Sonic Burger
and to limit fast food restaurants with drive-through locations based on access to main roads like
Hwy 50 or Plant Street.
Lastly, in Exhibit C, staff is proposing to limit automobile service stations that change oil, tires and
other minor work.
All of these uses will be permitted in non-overlay areas just as they currently are by code. See
attached exhibits for further information.
Recommendation:
Staff recommends the Honorable Mayor and City Commission approve an ordinance amending the
Land Development Code Article II Definitions, Section 5-8 Prohibited Uses and Table 5-1 Permitted
Use Regulations for certain uses in Overlay Districts.
Attachments:
Ordinance
Exhibit A—Self Storage Facility
Exhibit B—Drive-through Restaurants
Exhibit C—Automobile Service Station
Financial Impact:
None
Type of Item:
Z Public Hearing For Clerk's Dept Use:
® Ordinance First Reading 0 Consent Agenda
❑ Ordinance Second Reading [ ] Public Hearing
❑ Resolution 0 Regular Agenda
❑ Commission Approval
O Discussion& Direction
[ ] Original Document/Contract Attached for Execution by City Clerk
0 Original Document/Contract Held by Department for Execution
Reviewed by City Attorney ❑ N/A
Reviewed by Finance Dept. ❑ N/A
Reviewed by ( ) ❑ N/A
ORDINANCE NO. 2017-
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF OCOEE, FLORIDA,
AMENDING THE CITY OF OCOEE LAND DEVELOPMENT
CODE, CHAPTER 180 OF THE CITY CODE; AMENDING
ARTICLE II, SECTION 2-4, REDEFINING THE TERM MINI-
WAREHOUSE AND CREATING A DEFINITION FOR THE TERM
SELF-STORAGE FACILITY; AMENDING ARTICLE V, TABLE 5-
1, TO INCLUDE LIMITATIONS ON SPECIFIC USES IN SPECIAL
OVERLAY DISTRICTS; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION;
PROVIDING FOR CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY;
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, as provided in Article VIII of the Constitution of the State of Florida and
chapters 163 and 166, Florida Statutes, the City of Ocoee (the "City") enjoys all home rule
authority, police power, land development and zoning authority, and governmental and
proprietary powers necessary to conduct municipal government and perform municipal
functions; and
WHEREAS, the City may exercise any power for municipal purposes, except as
expressly prohibited by law; and
WHEREAS, Section 5-3.1 of the City of Ocoee Land Development Code ("Land
Development Code") allows special overlay areas to be created by the Ocoee City
Commission to facilitate unique development activities and to ensure coordinated and high
quality development within the Special Overlay Areas; and
WHEREAS, the Ocoee City Commission has established Special Overlay Areas in
the City to allow for such coordinated and high quality development; and
WHEREAS, on October 10, 2017, the City of Ocoee Planning and Zoning
Commission held a public hearing on proposed amendments to the Land Development
Code to provide for regulation of certain uses in Special Overlay Areas and
recommended that the Ocoee City Commission approve said amendments; and
WHEREAS, this Ordinance has been considered by the Ocoee City Commission
in accordance with the procedures set forth in Section 166.041(3)(c), Florida Statutes;
and
WHEREAS, the Ocoee City Commission finds that the proposed amendments
are consistent with the goals for development within Special Overlay Areas and are
consistent with the Ocoee Comprehensive Plan; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission in good faith determines that this Ordinance is
in the best interest of the City and its residents and promotes the health, safety, and
welfare of the public.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF
THE CITY OF OCOEE, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Recitals. The foregoing recitals are hereby ratified and confirmed
as true and correct and incorporated herein by this reference.
Section 2. Authority. The City Commission of the City of Ocoee has the
authority to adopt this Ordinance pursuant to Article VIII of the Constitution of the State
of Florida, and Chapters 163 and 166, Florida Statutes.
Section 3. Amendment to Section 2-4, Land Development Code. The term
"Mini-warehouse" is revised and a new definition for the term, "Self-Storage Facility", is
added to section 2-4, Article II, Chapter 180 of the City of Ocoee Land Development
Code, to read as follows, with underline showing additions and strikethroughs showing
deletions:
Article II — Language and Definitions
Section 2-4. — Definition of Terms.
(197) Mini-warehouse: See Self-Storage Facility. A building or group of buildings in a
or lockers of equal or varying sizes for the dead storage of a customer's goods or
wares.
(273) Self-Storage Facility: Self-storage uses provide separate storage areas for
individual or business uses. The storage areas are designed to allow private access by
the tenant for storing or removing personal property. Examples include but are not
limited to, self-storage warehouses and mini-storage facilities.
(Renumber subsequent subsections.)
(All other provisions of section 2-4, City of Ocoee Land Development Code, remain
unchanged by this amendment.)
Section 4. Amendment to Table 5-1, Land Development Code. Table 5-1,
Article V, Chapter 180 of the City of Ocoee Land Development Code, is hereby
amended to read as follows with underline showing additions and strikethroughs
showing deletions.
See Exhibit "A" attached hereto and by this reference made a part hereof.
2
Section 5. Codification. This Ordinance shall be incorporated into the City of
Ocoee Land Development Code. Any section, paragraph number, letter and/or any
heading may be changed or modified as necessary to effectuate the foregoing.
Grammatical, typographical and similar or like errors may be corrected, and additions,
alterations, and omissions not affecting the construction or meaning of this Ordinance or
the City Code may be freely made.
Section 6. Conflict. All Ordinances or Resolutions, or parts of Ordinances and
Resolutions in conflict herewith are hereby made ineffective to the extent of such conflict
as of the effective date of this Ordinance.
Section 7. Severability. If any section, subsection, sentence, clause, phrase
or portion of this Ordinance is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any
court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct, and
independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining
portions hereto.
Section 8. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall become effective immediately
upon passage and adoption.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this day of , 2017.
APPROVED:
ATTEST: CITY OF OCOEE, FLORIDA
Melanie Sibbitt, City Clerk
Rusty Johnson, Mayor
(SEAL)
ADVERTISED , 2017
READ FIRST TIME , 2017
READ SECOND TIME AND ADOPTED
, 2017
UNDER AGENDA ITEM NO.
FOR USE AND RELIANCE ONLY BY
THE CITY OF OCOEE, FLORIDA;
APPROVED AS TO FORM AND
LEGALITY
This day of , 2017.
SHUFFIELD, LOWMAN &WILSON, P.A.
By:
City Attorney
3
EXHIBIT A
TABLE 5-1
4
EXHIBIT "A"
Article IV, Table 5-1 — Permitted Use Regulations is hereby amended as follows:
USE A-1 A-2 RCE-1 R-1A R-1AAA R-2 R-3 RT-1 PS C-1 C-2 C-3 I-1 I-
2
RCE-2 R-1 R-1AA
Commercial
Uses
Storage _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Warehouse
Self- - - - - _- - - - - - - P** P**
Storage
Facility
**** In Special Overlay Districts:
1. Self-storage is permitted only as an accessory use. An accessory use shall be
defined as no more than 35% of the building or parcel of land may be used for
self-storage. If the mix of uses is separated on the site, the self-storage area(s)
visible from roadways must be lined with office and or retail frontage.
2. Any self-storage facility with frontage on an arterial street must be located
behind a retail business.
Article II, Section 2-4 — Definition of Terms is hereby amended as follows:
•197)
Mini-warehouse: See Self-Storage Facility. ' •: . : .. . . -••: • .
•273)
Self-Storage Facility: Self-storage uses provide separate storage areas for individual or
business uses. The storage areas are designed to allow private access by the tenant for storing
or removing personal property. Examples include: self-storage warehouse and mini-storage
facilities.
EXHIBIT "B"
Article IV, Section 5-8.B.(8) — Use Regulations, Prohibited Uses is hereby amended as
follows:
Drive In Restaurant.
Article IV, Table 5-1 — Permitted Use Regulations is hereby amended as follows:
USE A- A- RCE-1 R-1A R-1AAA R-2 R-3 RT-1 PS C-1 C-2 C-3 I-1 I-
1 2 2
RCE-2 R-1 R-1AA
Commercial
Uses
Restaurant - - - - - - - - - P*** P** P** P** P
Drive In - - - - - - - - - - P P P
Restaurant
*** In Special Overlay Districts:
1. New drive-through fast food restaurants may not have access or be located
directly onto an arterial or collector roadway as designated by the City of
Ocoee.
2. No drive-through lane(s) shall be visible from any public right-of-way.
EXHIBIT "C"
Article IV, Table 5-1 — Permitted Use Regulations is hereby amended as follows:
USE A- A- RCE-1 R-1A R-1AAA R-2 R-3 RT-1 PS C-1 C-2 C-3 I-1 I-
1 2 2
RCE-2 R-1 R-1AA
Commercial
Uses
Automobile - - - - - - - - - - - p**
p**
p
Service
Station
**In Special Overlay Districts:
1. Facilities shall be limited to three (3) bays, unless a waiver is granted by the
City Commission.
2. No bays shall be visible from any public right-of-way.
N
I I I 1 I 1 I 1 1 1
c-1
I I I I 1 I I I I
M
1
U I I 1 I I I I I I U)
N
I
U 1 I I I I I I I I (r)
I
IA U I I I I I N I I 1 Ln
C N
a) a I I I I I 1 I 1 I L/)
E
CD
L IL
= C I a
1 I 1 1 I I a 1
CD
C I a a a a a a a 1 ,
a
E N
I
0
a a a a a a a 1 1 ,
Ln a) a
CU
a
O
a & c lc
I a a a a a I 1 I ,
• o ao Q
D -0 O ,i
'L I a a a a a I , , ,
`, w 1a m
L!) cc y a
LU w t I-1 CNI
m N f9 V w w
Q '- U U
I- 0 v 0 CC z I a a a a a I I 1 ,
w I a
r O L N
Q) Q I a a a a a I 1 1 1
2 N .�
cc Ln t
LU CU ‘-I
a a) >
23 v Q I a a a a a a I a 1
CO <a
I- 0 — o
o L Lam.)
L = 'L y,+ C
a a)N a) a)
cc v o t
U ca
c a
C O
U v) O > .v _
•L N a L
0 -ai.d >
OA LL L L
C
U
0 0
a
• - a)
OA C Q a a U
CNC v Q
O +- a
N4-,- — a a X U
M a- co O O a "a
M
t = L LL 2 2 +•+ �' a
+ a GO a) C w
C C a to C (Is co >' a -a v
CU p w •v� • c c C T E C its CD-
H 0. a D a w a -0 Zs L E CI
in
N L LJJ a) Q OiA a a rto O +J 3 a) >. a)
cc a w a, cc z C 3 = O 0 -0 E
E •C) N H a) Q on • Y in I- 2 2 a a v
a N D w U = ==o C C C 3 a
�i U p +., E E = = = = "a ° a
a a a a
L
II u V))= UJ C-7 a`o an w -0 E E 3 3 3 3 X v a
`" D Q Q Q z Q U U C Ci CC c .Q
, , , I d d d I t1 d tl , , , , t1 d d N
* I*
CL a a a a 0.. 0 i a a a a a a a is tl
�
*
*
O LI) a a a a a tl a tl a a a a a 0-
**
0 , a , a , N I , 0 V) , , , a a LI) 0-
- , I I , I , I I , , , , I , d 0- , ,---
I I 1 , I I I I , I , , 1 , a I , I
CL I I I , I , I I , I , I I I I I I ,
I I I , I I I I , I , I I I I , I I
I 1 I I , I I I I , I , I I I I I I I
, - , I I I , I I I I I I I I , I I I I
I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I
I t) I I I I I , , , I I I , I I I I I
I N I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
I I I I I I I I , I I I I I I I I I I
N
t2
O
a)
O.
IrlV)
a)
an
110
to *4= L1)
C >N CO
a)E v a) V) C7
to to C -C
> Co �=
N L 3
Y ra
C CO UI N N a) a)
a) roE }' L �+ *' 0 to t10 CO C C
n w f6 O 3 ° a) c a) u a) a)
O �, • J a) to c c U 'O c C
> w a)cu in c C L Z U U •'..,- L > >
IA '5 _ c c o
CI D E d "O Y Q a) L c co cn L
C L 0 t0 a) co a) 'O a' O 0 U U CC
a) N Q as 0 m 0.. cc cn to V C —
E EL ci a) a) a) a) a) a) to 0 CO CO CO CO m
O U z1• 1 Ln
) °D w C (L'
m 0▪ 0 0 0 0 0 2 -cmn p L a) a) a)
° cEEEEEE toa) tiEEE
QO 0 0 0 0 0 v LL O ).- CO H L E E E
OOO "a0- OOcOOOtotOO Oto •- 000
2 Z U44
a a Q a a a m CO CO COUUUUU
, I n. I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 ,
CI- CIL a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a
CL q. a a a a a a a a a a a a V) a a a
CL al a a a a a cn . n. a cn a CL CL ,
, I V) , I , , I , I , I I I I , , ,
, I , I , , I , , , I I I , , I I I
, I I , I I I I , I I , , I , I I ,
, I I I , , I , I I I I , I I , I I
, I , I I , I I I I I I , I I I 1 I
, 1 I , I I I I I , I I I I , I I t
, I I I , I I I , , I I I I I I I I
, 1 I , I I , I I I I V) , , I I , ,
, I , I I I I , I I I V) , I I , I I
I I I I I I I I , I
U
• .0 N
4-' V)
•
06
CU I;
• U a)
fC
.. (n V)) 0
-0 N ++
V
C Q al to
C co Q E an a)
C ro
L. raV) L
• u aJ V) b.0 E 0 CU
_
C 0 Y C In V)
.. .L H-
E
.0 L
E D E •
a a o ° a) >
,F C Q CU 0 OA y.. C 0 H
aJ • ++ (O O C C C C 0 0 -a
L • U to L E V) U �... a-•+ QJ o U C
o ra a) c \ L aJ ca as E 4_ CD
• o (AM o v 0 V) s CDtai) c o 0 0 aJ
O L
0 v L 0 E
N C a) a CU CU
O N > — N 0 cu =
E • r3 E (6 L L aca-+ >' oA t° (O 0 L C () c cu
L �••+ y,. L ..... C -0 C 4 o
CU L
W0 (0
0 to 0 C L L In 0 CO }N.. N Q a• a) aJ 0 C
CU N 0- 7 7 7 CO CO L CU = a) 0 0 •,17.° > 0
0 ■t u W LL LL LL l7 0 0 10 = = _ • J a 2
, a I t 1 1 I t a 1 N a I
*
* 1 *
* *
CL a a a a a a a a a v) a * a q. a ,
*
* 1 *
* *
* *
CL a a a a a a a a a &) a a a ci. a ,
** 1
, a a a
*• �*
I , I , , , a , , a , , 1 ,
, , I I , I I , a , , I I I 1 , ,
, , I I , I I I , I I I I I 1 , ,
, , , I I I , I , I I , I , , , ,
, , p , I , I I I I I , I I I 1 ,
, , I , I , I , I I I , , I I , ,
, , I I I I I I I , I I I I , , ,
, , I I I I , I , I I 1 , I , , ,
, , I I , I I , I I , I I , 1 , ,
, , I I I I , , I II , , ,
N C ,
U
ao E 3
C 0 -O
� °� C
°o C
0 0
a "O U
-a C
C cn CD
Co
C t
_C
a 0 V)
cD +7, N
O
H N a)
a) N a) 4., -
Co •
Co J MI CO 'C
til C
a Q- DA C a Co
O O O N C co
L cn V) O C U to V a.+ Q. ate-+
L a) m 4- vI cu C) _c Q' LLI
V)
fD a1 N -a -10
Q Co > N 0 D
• .� CO • C7 Q Co 0 Co7:3 CD a_, a1 = av
v m C C <
a) H s •L O LO O CU ) C iv a) 2 a
C O > •N N C u , +, O a) H a •
a) (�.7 D 2
L C C 46 73 U V) 4' C 4-, 7 0 L
2• 2 2 2 z a a aL a a Co Cl) a) cn if) > ,) z co
a a a V) a a , , , a a V) a a V)
CL a , a V) , , a a V) a a V) ,
, , , , , V) V) V) a a V) a a V) V)
, , , , , , V) V) V) a a V) 0- 0- V) V)
V) V) V) a , LI) a , V) V)
, I , , , I I I V) a I V) a , V) V)
, I , , , I I V) , a , V) a , V) V)
of
, I , , , , V) V) V) a a V) a , V) (1) ull
0-
ns
, , , , , , V) V) , a a V) a , V) V) 2
c
ro
ch
, I , , , , , Va V
) , a ) a , V) U) LA
L)
c
O
, , , , , , , V) , a a V) a , in V) U
CL)
V)
a
0- 1 a a N a 1 a 0- U
L
Q
, , , I , , , 0- , a 0- V) 0.. , a a 0
4I
L
CL)
,-
a
, I , , , , , 0- , a a v) a , a a OC
N
a
0 U
VI 73 0 CO
UJ U .0 LL
V) L a
D a O U
O V E L c
7 co va) U ca E O '� N
O > > L = c U Z VI
. a
N >=
a)
+,
ro
L
(9 y) L 0Nco O co
in ••
co c 3
>
n 3 -5 co
73 = O
a) co c L-
4-,
Y L O _0 a)
E O Y
C
L 4..I E
Q aJ O OL
T O O W
CO u LA a)
U L M -0
O C 'v)
U f03. 0Q L +, U, a1
vs CU
a)
iis
c CO O W .�
C E as o
o
co O a)
Cl)` _� O c •• co
o E o m f° 4)
O L
O E -a vii m
+, U U4
WC
CU ++ i) CU L
v v � -a a) v
a -C _0
(1) 'a +-'
U 7. +, 4-,CU
_ ro oY
L U CO
c0L U
V) • Ill C 0
15 CU CU G3 cu 0 —
04 +' 7
C QJ
L V 13)L O 0 L ro v.,
�• a t v) co_^ E
N L o CU U •L U vUi a)
> Q) U CUD .•^
4-. 3 > 0 Q aN) N
C CO .0 U) a)
H 4' a) L
c V 0 c V) a)
O a) 0 c co c 0
+�
X co
Q C ca E
a)aN E o oN aai ro
L
x U c a) U 4
CU
U en =
CU c > tCC a) a)
0. aJ +.+ a) •• •• c
U) LJ C v .0 C 0
>, L fo L = O C
+-' E -o ca E vii OL s
-0 0 O c o *- 4 +�
N *' 2 O
ate+ a1 N N •C 3
a1
E
} as O .4- O +_
a) ai Ev
Q O = •j O a O as
O a) a)
L_ U _o a) O O •, 0 :J vl u a)
co — _o v1 L U
a1 v —_ 4_, O a) c0
C .0 i• N VI V) ; a) Q CLO fo 4-+ U)
7 U
OQJ Y 7 N •L ro 0 v)
L — -0 CO -0 � L w.. C a)
ao 3 as m o a) a) o > v E c
Y aJ a) u. Z > Z '..CY, Z O V) 4- - Q
v' > O CO 0 �
O a: 0 c m
co _ a) +,
O N U N a) L- 7
O
CCU y c-I N .--c -a N r/) .--c • E (-4
v) C N C
L- as N C —
m C c — iE
-0 — * *
L * * *
* 0 * dF *
COPY OF ADVERTISEMENT
Date Published and Media Name
2B The West Orange Times Thursday,October 26,2017
Advertisement or Article
FIRST INSERTION
CITY OF OCOEE
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
FOR AN AMENDMENT TO
THE OCOEE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE
PERMITTED USE REGULATIONS IN OVERLAY DISTRICTS
NOTICE IS HEREBY given that the City of Ocoee City Commission will consider
a proposed Amendment to the City of Ocoee Land Development Code relating to
Article V,Permitted Use Regulations in Overlay Districts.
The OCOEE CITY COMMISSION will hold a public hearing on the proposed
amendment on TUESDAY,NOVEMBER 7,2017,AT 6:15 PM or as soon there-
after as practical. The public hearing will be held in the City Hall Commission
Chambers located at 150 North Lakeshore Drive,Ocoee.
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF OCOEE,FLORIDA,AMENDING
THE CITY OF OCOEE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE,CHAPTER 180
OF THE CITY CODE;AMENDING ARTICLE II,SECTION 2-4,REDE-
FINING THE TERM MINI-WAREHOUSE AND CREATING A DEFINI-
TION FOR THE TERM SELF-STORAGE FACILITY;AMENDING ARTI-
CLE V,TABLE 5-1,TO INCLUDE LIMITATIONS ON SPECIFIC USES IN
SPECIAL OVERLAY DISTRICTS;PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION;
PROVIDING FOR CONFLICT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY;
PROVIDING AN EFFEC'T'IVE DATE.
Interested parties may appear at the public hearing and be heard with respect
to the proposed actions above.The complete case file may be inspected at the
Ocoee Development Services Department/Planning Division located at 150
North Lakeshore Drive,Ocoee,Florida between the hours of 8:00 a.m.and 5:00
p.m.,Monday through Friday,except legal holidays.The City Commission may
continue these public bearings to other dates and times,as it deems necessary.
Any interested party shall be advised of the dates,times,and places of any con-
tinuation of these or continued public hearings shall be announced during the
hearing and no further notices regarding these matters will be published.You
are advised that any person who desires to appeal any decision made at the pub-
lic hearings will need a record of the proceedings and for this purpose may need
to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made which includes the
testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based.Persons with disabili-
ties needing assistance to participate in any of these proceedings should contact
the City Clerk's Office 48 hours in advance of the meeting at 407-905-3105.
October 26,2017 17-05691W